Preview

Undergruaduate

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
4769 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Undergruaduate
Content

Introduction 2

Part 1: Overview 2

1.1 Timeline of AIG Accounting Scandal 4

1.2 Relationship Chart of AIG and Its Counterparties 5

Part 2: Accounting Issues 6

2.1 Background on Reinsurance and Relevant GAAP Rules 6

2.2 Manipulation Technique 1 7

2.3 Manipulation Technique 2 7

2.4 Retrospections 8

Part 3: Auditing Issues 9

3.1 Reasons for Auditing Failure 9

3.2 Retrospections 11

Part 4: Corporate Governance 12

4.1 Tone at the Top 12

4.2 Dysfunction of the Board 14

4.3 Low Engagement of Shareholders 15

4.4 Reactions and Its Effectiveness? 15

4.5 Possible Therapy 16

Part 5: Recommendations to Preventing Scandals and Conclusion 17

Introduction

This project focused on the scandal of AIG between 28 Oct 1999 and 30 Mar 2005. It will firstly provide an overview of the scandal and then shed light upon areas of AIG’s accounting, auditing and corporate governance with reference to relevant theories and concepts. The second part begins with accounting aspect which illustrates the motivations behind the insurance industry and the application of finite reinsurance. Regarding the auditing issues, the essay seeks to examine if external auditor PwC bewared, recognized and modified the real “problem” in AIG. Later the symptoms of the corporate governance will be analyzed by looking at agency-principal problem, organization culture, dysfunctional board and unprotected shareholders’ rights which had collectively led to the corporate failure. Finally, some general implications will be revealed.

Part 1: Overview
American International Group, Inc. (AIG) was widely considered as a world’s leading international insurance and financial service organization (AIG official website, 2009). Under Hank Greenberg’s leadership, AIG was regarded as one of the nation’s most profitable companies by the Business Insurance, and was ranked the third among the top ten companies on the Forbes Global 2000

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    Wedtech Scandal

    • 335 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Auditing failure is also a key factor contributing to the Wedtech scandal. It is presented as a result of independence of auditing reporting and confirmation.On the one hand, even if auditors complied with auditing process on the surface (Berg and barbanel, 1987), they are not independent since they were bribed to forge auditing reports.In 1982, Wedtech employed the Main Hurdman to financially audit its financial statementswhen it went to Initial Public Offerings. One of the auditing partners, Richard Bluestinefound a serious fact in auditing that two directors had transiting company’s money to their private accounts. However, he accepted a bribe from the two directors, which includes 9% of company’s shares and $900,000 low interest loans. Furthermore, Anthony Guariglia , the other auditing partner,was also bribed with 1.5% shares and a job position in Wedtech with high payment. In return, both of them covered up their financial crimes in the report and reported to SBA that the invoice falsification was only a minor infringe to the law and had been corrected by the managers.On the other hand, the legal confirmation of the auditing statement lacked independence,as the law firm named Ellenoff, Plesent& Lehrer, who issued this confirmation letter, was bribed by Wedtech (Deleon, 1993). Hence it is highly probable that the letter of confirmation was not reliable.…

    • 335 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Managerial decisions constantly affect the third parties who are the creditors and investor and hence the auditors have a duty to safeguard and protect them from misleading statements by the management. A lot of value is placed by the public on the independent financial statements since it enhances the degree of confidence to the third parties. Currently the financial reporting seeks to address more relevant information to the end user. Therefore there is more judgment that is put on them and increased subjectivity involved in management’s accounting. It is evident the end users of the financial statements need to be protected from deceit and extortion that may be as a result of management decisions which may be scrupulous and…

    • 1210 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    ENRON Case Study

    • 1579 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The ways company is governed today have gone on for a change given the reform in audit functions and the likes. As it is with the case, effective financial reporting is the sole concern of companies. Hence, in recent development there has been a dramatic shift towards corporate governance, because the capital market mostly feeds on the effectiveness of…

    • 1579 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    This essay discusses about the corporate collapses in the new millennium. In recent years the Australian corporate sector has witnessed the failure of number of corporations, including HIH Insurance, Harris Scarf, One. Tel, Ansctt Australia. This paper focuses on the financial audit of HIH insurance, which collapsed on 15th March 2001. This was the largest failure in Australian business history. Royal commission was appointed investigate re-issue of HIH Insurance collapsed with debt estimated $5.3 billion Australian dollars (Mirshekary, S, 2005). A brief review of the incidence of corporate failure will be provided prior to an analysis of the collapse of Health International Holding (HIH) and the involvement of its auditor, Anderson. The issue of audit independence is of basic importance in the collapse of HIH. In order to give arguments it is mandatory for all professional auditors to comply with the joint code of professional conduct conventional by the Society of Certified Practicing Accountants (CPA) Australia and the Institute of Chartered Accountants Australia (ICAA). The collapse of the insurance giant HIH in Australia and Enron in United States has been mechanism for considerable changes in financial report auditing. Many of these changes focus on the presence and extent of the auditor independence. A major issue of the Auditor independence is the treats to independence are usually restrained and difficult to measure.…

    • 2671 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Best Essays

    In 2001, there was an event that had shaken the whole business world. The crash of Enron in US, followed by worldwide collapse of its auditor, Arthur Andersen. It was a greatest corporate failure uncovered in business history. Follow the Enron-Andersen scandal, massive organizations like WorldCom, Xerox and Waste Management confront a similar fate. The debate rested on the issue of audit independence , that is found to be one of the major contributors to crashes like Enron. It is explained that the impact of lack of audit independence is extremely great to the audit quality (Abdullah, 2004). This essay, is trying to define what is 'independence' and discuss about the relationship between independence and quality of external auditors.…

    • 1648 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    In this case study, we will first discuss briefly about the Satyam Fiasco and from a financial standpoint, we would discuss what led to the scam. We will gradually move towards understanding of Corporate Governance. This would cover what Corporate Governance means, what are the principles of Corporate Governance, what are the control mechanisms by which Corporate Governance can be regulated. We would then move to the loopholes on how Corporate Governance could be compromised and what precautionary measures should be taken to prevent a case like Satyam Fiasco in the future.…

    • 949 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    |This research paper discusses the causes for the increase of exposure of the accounting profession to liability from the early scandals of the|…

    • 1710 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    Aig Fiasco

    • 387 Words
    • 2 Pages

    AIG’s predominate problem was that their corporate structure was “pay for performance” but did not allow the executives to have a downside if the risk they took did not pay off. AIG’s system did not reinforce the company’s core values, enhance cohesion and commitment to the goals and objectives of the company, and meet with the organizations overall mission and purpose. This “pay for performance” compensation system also seems to have driven the corporate culture to one in which the name of the game was to look out for yourself, rather than the interest of the firm.…

    • 387 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    Aig Scandal

    • 2990 Words
    • 12 Pages

    AIG, established as a Delaware corporation in 1921 by Maurice “Hank” Greenburg, is primarily engaged in insurance-related and financial activities in the United States and European countries (over 130 combined total); including but not limited to home insurance, car insurance, life insurance and various investments.…

    • 2990 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Guide to Writting Assignment

    • 26909 Words
    • 108 Pages

    study of an American insurance company by Jones (2004), and it was one of the…

    • 26909 Words
    • 108 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Scandal of Xerox

    • 4098 Words
    • 17 Pages

    Xerox, the then world’s largest copier seller, was sued by the U.S. Security and Exchange Committee (SEC) in 2002 for its fraudulent accounting manipulations, which inflated $1.5 billion earnings from 1997 to 2000. Several parties got their hands dirty in the scandal, including the then senior Xerox management, the Board of Directors and external auditor KPMG LLP. The failure of those parties in discharging their duties induces the further thought of trust and accountability among them and shareholders. Furthermore, the external environment in 1990s, including economic bubble boom, irrational investors, fierce industrial competition and ineffective regulations on audit, provided a hotbed for the scandal. Lessons learnt from Xerox scandal indicate the necessity for changes in corporate governance system, regulations on accounting professions and analysts as well as regulators.…

    • 4098 Words
    • 17 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Best Essays

    The greatest modern financial crisis is still unraveling the aftershocks now I feel is the most serious in Europe. In fact, the lifting of the mortgage crisis in the United States and bankruptcy homeowners damaged in progress, but is no longer news. The ultimate responsibility of the crisis, the responsibility of the nature and extent of the problem has not been a satisfactory answer. Therefore, the community has finally improved, responsibilities more solid. It involves the practice of, and vigorously promote low-quality products to customers of big banks, while hedging bets on their own account in the opposite direction. Crime here, is not hedged, but the lack of transparency to customers. Asked to assume greater responsibility and market regulators and government officials, as well as the Board of Directors of the Company, has been a positive impact of the financial crisis. Place to ensure duty-bound, and that corporate responsibility is indeed hope that the Board of Directors and the field of market regulation will be a lasting crisis. Clear from the lessons of the financial crisis has moved from the board of directors of the CEO and the Executive Board to shirk its responsibility for the operation of enterprises and survival. The responsibility of the enterprises has laid a lot of executives. The focus of governance is to provide appropriate security and protect shareholders' interests. This pressure led to the revolution of the economic value added, does not seem any security for many investors. The problem is that the lack of transparency to the business by the Board. It is this transparency, to provide the Board with sufficient confidence, it is recommended that the projections will be achieved. This essay will examine some of the Goldman Sachs’ corporate governance principles with specific regards to code of conducts and principles of responsibilities.…

    • 2587 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    “The collapse of the HIH Insurance group (“HIH”) resulted in a deficiency of up to A$5.3 billion, making it Australia’s largest corporate failure. The ensuing Royal Commission report released in April 2003 provides a rare detailed dissection of a spectacular corporate implosion and a very useful case study from which corporate governance lessons may be learned. This is particular so because HIH was not unusual case of major fraud or embezzlement. The failures identified by Commissioner Owen were by and large failures stemming from mismanagement. Most breaches of the law were designed to cover up the consequential increasing financial difficulties which were engulfing HIH” (Lipton, P., 2003, p.273, Retrieved 19th December 2007).…

    • 4851 Words
    • 20 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Best Essays

    Billions are spent each year around the globe on reinsurance policies to ensure stability throughout the insurance marketplace. Similar to the operations of people and businesses insuring their own personal risk, insurance companies use reinsurance to transfer their respective risks. The first real signs of the reinsurance market was back in 1370, when an underwriter named Guilano Grillo contracted with Goffredo Bonaira and Martino Sacco to reinsure a ship on part of the voyage from Genoa to the harbour of Bruges (Kopf 1929). Since this quote, there have been unprecedented developments in the Reinsurance market. Nowadays, ‘’Reinsurance is a global business, covering risks from insurers in many geographic locations (Holzheu and Lechner 2007). There are many major international players within this particular volatile sector. Munich Reinsurance Company, Swiss Re Company Limited and Lloyd’s were ranked in the top five reinsurers based on gross premiums written for 2011 (Mcmahon 2012).…

    • 3279 Words
    • 14 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Best Essays

    principle of auditing

    • 3509 Words
    • 15 Pages

    ii. Educomp, 2010. Summary Notes of Chapter 1 – Nature of Auditing. [Pdf file] Available at: [Accessed 4 June 2012 ]…

    • 3509 Words
    • 15 Pages
    Best Essays