Truth Essay on Scarlet Letter and Crucible

Only available on StudyMode
  • Download(s) : 203
  • Published : October 12, 2008
Open Document
Text Preview
Is it possible for one man’s truth to be another’s lie, or is it that the two’s interpretation of the absolute truth differ? Truth cannot be viewed from a subjective perspective for then there would be endless “truths”, rather, the truth must be viewed objectively for the fact that it is. Despite the obvious flaw with subjective truth, many believed, and still do, in its reasoning. Authors Nathaniel Hawthorne and Arthur Miller of The Scarlet Letter and The Crucible, respectively, both write about how Puritans, filled with fear and ignorance, blindly believed the subjective statements and accusations they heard without considering the objectivity of the truth. In the Scarlet Letter, two opposing views of Roger Chillingworth and Mr. Dimmesdale’s relationship exist; the public thinks that the union is beneficial because it will save the reverend’s life, but Hester Prynne knows that Roger is seeking revenge and therefore thinks his actions evil. By presenting these two perspectives, Hawthorne is able to reveal the objective truth which is a surprising combination of the two aforementioned views. Hawthorne argues that the love and hate that Roger seems to posses are essentially just his desire for intimacy and affection, but whereas, “…One happens to be seen in a celestial radiance, the other [is] in a dusky and lurid glow” (Hawthorne 225). Thus, subjective ideas can never be absolutely true, for they are formed with biases that not everyone can agree to, whereas objective truths are derived from pure facts. Just as people are inclined to make subjective observations and statements, so to are they to believe them. In The Crucible Danforth, the judge, blindly believes nearly every claim he hears and rather than make an objective conclusion with presented information, he strictly relies on subjective accusations. For example, he ignores the fact that the accused women were loyal church-goers and that nearly a hundred credible people declared the...
tracking img