Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

To what extent is the party of David Cameron Thatcherite?

Good Essays
662 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
To what extent is the party of David Cameron Thatcherite?
To what extent is the party of David Cameron Thatcherite?
Thatcherism comprised a mixture of ideas and policies such as free markets, privatisation of industries, low taxation and little state involvement in people’s lives. Some may argue that the conservative party today under David Cameron has drifted into a different direction from Thatcherite policies, however others say that Thatcher still has a huge influence on the modern conservative party.
One of Thatcher’s main policies was the privatisation of national industries and businesses, for example British Telecom in 1981. Privatising these industries was thought to encourage competition and force firms to offer cheaper and better services. It can be said that modern conservatives also agree with this idea about privatisation. In fact it seems David Cameron is looking to take further steps and take away government power from sectors such as schools and policing giving the public the freedom to control the state at a local level. This seems to suggest that the party of David Cameron is to some extent Thatcherite.
Thatcher also believed that taxes should be kept low as it would create more wealth for people and businesses. Not only would the extra wealth help people buy a property or allow businesses to expand more, it would also reduce government spending on welfare benefits. The conservative party, as it always has, also hopes to reduce taxes. David Cameron said that his conservative party would cut taxes for hardworking people. This tells us that indeed Cameron and Thatcher share some very similar policies.
Both Thatcher and Cameron have tried hard to reduce the countries debt. Thatcher sold off many government owned industries. However, Cameron has to go about this in a different way as Thatcher had already sold most of the industries, although he did sell off the post office. This is very right wing of the two, and certainly pulls their governments closer in terms of similarity.
However, a strong argument to suggest that the two parties are not similar is simply that David Cameron is in a coalition. This means that he has had to discard some of his policies and even puts decisions through the Lib Dem party. Thatcher never had to do this which enabled her government to be very right wing. The Lib Dems are perhaps more left wing, which makes the coalition government a much less conservative one than Thatcher’s was. This shows that even if there are similarities between the two it is too a small extent as there are major differences.
In addition to this, Thatcher had a strong and harsh belief in law and order, whereas David Cameron is arguably more lenient. His ‘hug a hoodie’ speech seemed to soften the conservative view on crime. This shows us that the Cameron party is not that Thatcherite.
Thatcher was extremely euro-sceptic and even said ‘Europe needs us more than we need them’. Perhaps she would have opted out of the EU had she the chance. Although Cameron believes we may have ‘the wrong deal’, he is still pro EU. Many might think he is against the EU from the way he talks but this is simply because the conservative party has had a long history of division on them matter of the EU and therefore he has to be slightly careful in what he says. He might not want to become one ‘European super state’ but he certainly does not want to leave. This sets Cameron apart from Thatcher as she was very against the EU.
In conclusion, although Cameron’s tendencies may be very Thatcher like he cannot be as right wing as he may perhaps want to be because of the coalition. He has to take into account more socialist points of view from the liberal democrats, and of course has left many successful new labour policies untouched. This means that to some extent the party of David Cameron is somewhat Thatcherite, but largely it involves other political aspects.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    During the formation of the government David Cameron made concessions to the Liberal Democrats so that the prospect of a coalition would look more appealing. These concessions included giving significant cabinet positions to Liberal Democrat MPs, Nick Clegg for example became Deputy Prime Minister. It was these concessions that so much reduced the possible individual power of the prime minister and gave the Liberal Democrat cabinet members large amounts of influence over government policy. This resulted from the conservative fear that any significant cabinet resignations would cause the collapse of the government and a the entering into power of the Labour party (as the polls indicate), this means that Cameron had to keep the Lib Dem party onside.…

    • 548 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Another reason why Conservatives won is that in there manifesto they promised to stabilise the cost of living which would close the gap between rich and poor and double everyone’s standard of living. This was helped by Labour being identified with the working class rather than the nation as a whole. This was a problem as 40% of manual workers now considered themselves middle class so the Labour policies for the unemployed and working class no longer appealed to them, instead they…

    • 451 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The 3rd May 1979 saw the greatest parliamentary swing since the war, with the Conservative Party polling 43.9% of the vote; thereby winning 339 seats (up 62 since the last election). It is due to these figures, therefore, that historians such as Eric Evans believe that it was the strength of the Conservatives under their new, forward-thinking leader, Margaret Thatcher that led them to victory. However, when one looks at the context of the time itself, it seems apparent, as Marr sums up, that ‘it was likely that the current social climate left the Labour Party in an unfavourable position’. In reality, it seems more likely that Labour weaknesses, particularly those of the Labour Leader James Callaghan during the Winter of Discontent, led to the huge parliamentary swing of 1979.…

    • 996 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Many believed that Thatcher offered an alternative to the Labour government, a change, so after Callaghan’s government was destroyed by economic crises, rising unemployment, hostile trade unions and political misjudgements the Conservatives had a landslide victory with 43.9% of the vote. Before the Conservative rise to power with Thatcher, the Labour party had experience many troubles during their time in government, perhaps this is why the Conservatives won the General election. However was this win purely down to the conservatives and their policies or was it down to the failure of the Labour party.…

    • 650 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Hay, C. (1994). ‘Labour’s Thatcherite Revisionism: Playing the “Politics of Catch-Up”’, in Political Studies 42 (4).…

    • 3395 Words
    • 14 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Due to this Lloyd George had to concede to the conservatives at times as he did when they demanded that cuts be made and that Lloyd George agree to the Geddes axe. This was a mistake as it led to him earning a reputation of not fulfilling promises of reconstruction and led to a decline in popularity. The conservatives only needed Lloyd George as long as he was popular with the people and therefore an asset to them, his gradual decline in popularity led to the conservatives questioning his worth. His policies also went against what they stood for the most part and even though they remained loyal to the coalition due to Bonar Law, cracks appeared when Austen Chamberlain replaced him as leader of conservatives. However, it can argued that the conservatives were being pragmatic in letting Lloyd George introduce some social reform, especially since working class had received the vote. This did not deter backbenchers and die hards who grew in number and in criticism of Lloyd George’s policies, which culminated in the formation of the anti-waste league who won two by-elections, evidence that they held influence. As Lloyd George’s unpopularity grew so did the conservative attitude change towards him except in the senior members, which also led to the fear that a split may emerge over loyalty to the coalition.…

    • 1128 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The major political parties in the United Kingdom, the Conservative Party and the Labour Party, have become considerably more central than they were originally. Labour was originally a strongly socialist party, but it gradually centralised and has accepted some ideas of the centre-right under New Labour. The Conservative Party originated as a royalist party, but it has adopted a number of left-wing or liberal ideas in recent times, such as free-market economics and equality of opportunity.…

    • 827 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    There are four key principles in which currently influence modern politics and the direction of the current coalition. Firstly, Paternalism; One nation conservatism is about the stronger (richer) looking after the weaker (poorer) There is the idea behind this principle of a father looking after a son. An example of this principle having influence within the coalition is Cameron handing out and protecting free TV licenses and bus passes for the elderly. This principle clearly contrast with Thatcherites view on helping the poor, whom argue that people should help themselves and not to rely on others to help them. Overall on the principle of Paternalism I believe that the modern conservative party can be considered ‘One nation’ as although the coalition have had to make cuts due to the size and state of the deficit, cuts have included removing educational maintenance from a large number of students to help with the costs of sixth form study.…

    • 980 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    New Liberalism believed in interventionism for those who are ‘deserving’ and aimed to close the gap for those in poverty. Furthermore, New Liberalism supported taxation in order to fund social reforms. This new ideology also supported the movement away from a ‘laissez-faire’ economy, proposing that the state had an obligation to intervene. New Liberalism continued to build the legacy of Joseph Chamberlain (former Liberal who left over the issues of Home Rule and reforms), a politician that sought after the implementation of reforms such as old age pensions, and the provision of loans to the working class for the purchase of houses. Additionally, David Lloyd George believed that social reform would alleviate the threat of socialism – a view shared by Winston Churchill, who had defected from the Conservatives. Another Liberal thinker, J.A. Hobson spoke of “the sovereignty of social welfare”, crucially illustrating that social welfare was the paramount concern for the…

    • 882 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Thatcherism- philosophy that anything that technologically advances is good anything that prohibits otherwise is bad.…

    • 754 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    One nation conservatism (traditional) Vs. Thatcherism One nation conservatism (traditional) Thatcherism Pragmatic – flexible Conservatives willinbg to change policies depending on public mood Accepts positive role of the State Postwar concensus – Accepted nationalisation: Welfare, NHS. Mixing economy.…

    • 81 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Conservatives have also continued to fulfil its traditional principle of minimising the role of the state in people’s lives, or as Thatcher put it: ‘rolling back the frontiers of the state.’ Cameron has done this through his idea of the ‘Big Society’ based on the ideas of civic conservatism and suggesting that people at a local level should take more…

    • 959 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Another one of Labour’s reforms to the UK was the devolution act. In Labour’s manifesto they said that they would address the issues of devolution and making the country more democratic. When Labour got into office they did…

    • 626 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    “The Conservative Party exists to conserve”, but what exactly does it desire to conserve? According to Samuel Huntington, conservatism wishes to justify the established order (Huntington, 1957, p. 455). This established order was, when the Conservative Party was founded in the 1830s, an elitist order that justifies income inequality by saying it is natural and inevitable (Dorey, 2011, p. 5). When the franchise expanded and the working class became represented, the Conservative Party did not disappear from the political field, but flourished and is currently in government as one of the most prominent parties in the United Kingdom. Various factors explain this possibly unexpected success and this essay aims discuss the most…

    • 2456 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    One major policy area where there is both consensus and conflict is the area of taxation. The general consensus between the main parties is to lower taxes – this would boost consumer spending which would help stimulate the economy. In regards to income tax, both parties favour a two-tier taxation system, with the progressive reduction of the taxes of the lower tier. Despite these similarities between Labour and Conservative taxation policy, there are also some significant differences. The Conservatives have a preference for indirect taxes as the New Right thinks that direct taxation is harmful to personal initiative and thus has a negative effect on the economy. The conflict between the parties on the issue of indirect taxes could be illustrated by the changes in VAT. Originally at 17.5%, the Labour government reduced the standard rate to 15% in December 2008. Even though this was later raised back up to…

    • 901 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays