Preview

The Good Woman of Setzguan Brecht

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
511 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Good Woman of Setzguan Brecht
Shen Te’s male “other” in Brecht’s “The Good Woman of Setzguan” Brecht’s “The Good Woman of Setzguan”, with its intense surrealist element, cruelly unveils the immense ugliness of a capitalistic society, displaying aspects of exploitation and materialism through the prism of each of the two genders. Providing his heroine with a male “alter ego”, Brecht remarkably places the female in a male dominated society projecting women’s need to adopt male characteristics to survive and their endeavor to preserve their love and goodness, attributes inevitably erased in a self-centered and alienated world. Initially, Shen Te’s forced choice to become Shui Ta underscores the impossibility of good and evil’s coexistence. Through Shen Te’s exploitation by the family and the unemployed man and through the extravagant demands of many of her acquaintances, the playwright argues the selfishness and nonchalance which infect people’s public relations, creating an ominous environment for good to exist in. Hence, he provides Shen Te with a male self to supply her with characteristics acceptable for the masculine gender such as forcefulness, aggressiveness and determination, impressively succeeding in good and evil’s parallel existence. Undoubtedly, the writer equips Shen Te with the indispensable weapons – on Shui Ta’s character - to survive society’s cruelty while protecting her humanity, goodness and generosity - on her real character. Further in the play, Brecht brings out love’s obliteration within a selfish world through a woman’s hopeless attempts to conceal her loving feelings and the pain of betrayal behind the mask of a powerful man. Yang Sun’s desperate attempt to use Shen Te’s love for the attainment of his dreams boldly shows the estrangement and inhumanity of the capitalistic society. On top of that, the confection of Shui Ta’s character deftly highlights how much the emotional and sensitive disposition of the feminine belies the non-emotional and tough-skinned

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Gender identities and roles are a crucial part on a women’s life in 17th century in Spain and what will be later become America. When looking the histories on these century, women transgression toward society norms shaped by Spain influence of a “ideal” women behavior should be like. Two fitting examples of how women transgress in society at the time is Catalina de Erauso and Sor Juana Ines de la Cruz. These two women had to change many aspects in their life to accomplish an internal freedom, which at the time society didn’t approve as appropriate for an ordinary woman. Some of the crucial aspects affected by this choice are gender and how they are predive at the time, transgression towards social rules, identity and how it had to be changed to be accepted and personal freedom…

    • 499 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The central character Bridie never loses her core identity although the power of the truth alters the dynamic of the relationship she has with Sheila. Initially, she is introduced to the responder demonstrating the ‘kowtow’. The use of stage directions emphasises that her experience during the war has impacted her and continues to impact her physically and emotionally. Her recollections of the painful events of war are expressed in an emotion- free way which defines her as a strong persona. The use of tone ‘calmly’ whilst she describes her experiences: “The lightest I got was exactly five stone” exemplifies this notion. Throughout the play Bridie has a defined perception of the world. She appears perceptive about British inadequacies during the Japanese invasion as highlighted when she states “I’ll forgive the Japs for what they did to us in camp” and further states her views on sleeping with a Japanese “To go with a Jap to give him pleasure- how could you ever live with yourself”. Ultimately, it is when Sheila tells her about the self- sacrifice she made for her that Bridie’s role and perception is dramatically altered. Ultimately, she evolves into an understanding individual, which is evident when she is talking about Sheila’s actions “They don’t give medals for things like that, but they should”. Hence, the truth serves as a catalyst for the shift in dynamic of their relationship. Throughout the play she remains having a motherly role towards Shiela, as evident when Shiela states “We fought all the time. You were worse than my mother” and when Bridie calls Shiela “My dear girl”. Therefore, the character of Bridie shifts in her role and perception throughout the play the Shoe Horn Sonata as a result of the truth being…

    • 294 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Shoe Horn Sonata

    • 1155 Words
    • 5 Pages

    In act one: scene 1 Bridie and Shelia, the two fictional characters, are a visual and dramatic representation of the women who faced the real life experiences of the Australian and British female POW’s captured while trying to flee from Singapore in 1942. In 1996 John Misto created a dramatized staged production which exposed a “untold story of hundreds of women imprisoned by the Japanese in South East Asia as a ringing indictment against Australian indifference to the lots of these women”. Distinctively visual features are purposefully included from the play’s opening scene to aptly recreate the reality of their past experiences, which begins in complete darkness. Two deliberate and commanding hand claps are they first things you hear, this is used to capture the attention of the audience. The word “Keirei” is cried out upon command by the male Japanese guard, gender and power inequality are further established as an older women’s emotive dialogue is heard giving instruction to how to bow, in tribute, to the Emperor of Japan. A spotlight shines down on a women who is demonstrating how to bow properly, she is stiff…

    • 1155 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Atwood’s ‘Villainesses’, aims to captivate audiences and arguably has the most textual integrity of all the prescribed speeches. The composer challenges society’s attitudes towards women and urges social reform. Atwood was an illustrious novelist and poet, renown for the complexity of her work. Her speech was delivered during the rise of the third wave of feminism and she ensured to distance herself from this ideology, hence her epideictic speech is not bound by context, emphasised by the polyvocality of the speech. If she had embraced the dogmatic feminism she dissociated with, the speech would be far more context dependent and the textual integrity of the speech would have been lessened. Atwood challenges the representation of women in literature, arguing that lack of evil women in literature is suppressive to women in society, while Suu Kyi argues that the lack of women in politics is suppressive to women. The title of Atwood’s speech alludes to Shakespeare’s Lady Macbeth, emphasising that women are multidimensional and capable of evil. Atwood attempts to create a middle-ground between the patriarchal and ideological feminist representations of women. The recurring motif of the ‘eternal breakfast’ acts as a symbol of the static state of which she is critiquing. Atwood argues that a…

    • 891 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Throughout history male dominated societies have been prevelant. The primary structure of the household has been patriarchial for the most part. Some women have accepted this condition; others women, however, find strength and pride in their sex and have thus ignored the norms of male domination. In her nove, Like Water for Chocolate, Laura Esquivel comments on feminism and society’s instated role for women. Through the story’s protagonist, Tita, Laura depicts a women in her traditional role and shows shows how she deters from what she is expected to do and how she is expected to act and embraces life in the manner she wishes to do so. Ultimately, Laura Esquivel utilizes Tita’s role as a women, cooking, and her nience, Esperanza, to depict the triumph of feminism.…

    • 861 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Flore Rape Quotes

    • 907 Words
    • 4 Pages

    She conveys the neglect women of lesser rank experience from Haitian society regarding their safety and respect through Flore’s rape and Max Ardin Senior’s beliefs about the event. For example, he questions, “Wasn’t even the girl expecting it?” when looking back on Flore’s rape because “sleeping with the house servant was not an uncommon rite of passage for young men in houses like his” (Danticat 185). As Max Sr. highlights the commonality of situations of rape similar to Max Jr. and Flore’s, Danticat expresses society’s immunity to the horrors of rape and failure to punish the powerful men behind the acts; thus, she depicts society’s disregard for poor women. Furthermore, with Flore’s reaction to her rape, Danticat exposes the harsh reality for low-income women living in Haiti. Flore explains to Louise, “I could not lose my job . . . I am—was—paying . . . the rent for my mother’s house” (175). Danticat exhibits trapping nature of poverty for the workingwomen as having to accept harmful, violating situations due to their desperate need for money to survive. Moreover,…

    • 907 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    New Woman: Book Synopsis

    • 747 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The “New Woman” is “appealing in her appearance” (Moeller 35), independent, and changes all assumptions about femininity. She is one who “go[es] to the cinema in the evenings… buy[s] Elegant World and the film magazines,” (Wehrling 721-723) she can be seen as promiscuous and sexually liberated. Mia Pinneberg models all these adjectives. She wears her “brown suit and smart hat” (Fallada 278) voiding any feminine assumptions, she formerly worked as a hostess at a night club, and even upon aging, continues her quest for social superiority through her constant evening parties and booze. Mia is the independent “New Woman” that bounces around from lover to lover with only her self-interest in mind. She is currently using Jachmann, her “current lover” (Fallada 107) for solely her own pleasures, and openly admits that she “sleep[s] with him” (Fallada 107). All of these aesthetic qualities and aspirations demonstrate how society saw the “New Woman.” However, underneath the mass stereotype for modernized bourgeois women, the pressures and expectations create an alienation from themselves, others and society itself as displayed through Mia.…

    • 747 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The House on Mango street is a feminist piece of literature because it brings attentions to the sexist way the men in Esperanza’s society regard women. Esperanza tells her story by focusing on the women around her who are owned by the dominant men in their lives due to restricting gender roles that encompasses not only women but men. “My great-grandfather threw a sack over her head and carried her off...She (Esperanza’s grandmother) looked out the window her whole life, the way so many women sit their sadness on an elbow.” (11) Cisneros brings attention to the cruel way that men in Esperanza’s society treat women. The normality of these discriminatory actions describes a gender role that society has set for men, to be the dominant figure in…

    • 273 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Cisneros repeats various negative and similar cases of different women which ultimately shed light on the need of improvement of the situation of women. This could be seen in the similarity of the vignettes “Marin” and “Sally”. In the vignette “Marin”, Esperanza writes “Is waiting for a car to stop, a star to fall, someone to change her life.”, and in the vignette “Linoleum Roses” were Esperanza writes “She says she is in love, but I think she did it to escape.” These two vignettes are both very similar since the both use the rather negative parts of the situation of women, marrying young/the dependence of a man, to highlight the gravity of the situation, to express the…

    • 437 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    By examining institutions representing a female unity like the Frauenhilfsktion Wien, Healy shows us how the relationship between the “ladies” and the working women reduplicates the capitalist-bourgeois mode of production, a class relationship that fundamentally challenges the transcendental female love that was supposed to combine them together as one unity. Although this capitalist structure had always existed to differentiate women in different class, Healy pointed out that the working class women during the war in particular “resented the depiction of their labor as ‘coming from the heart,’ originating in feminine selflessness,” (176) which disguised the exploitation reality. This clash between class and gender has a much deeper implication not only in WWI, but also throughout the century. In Fassbinder’s film The Bitter Tears of Petra von Kant (Die bitteren Tränen der Petra von Kant, 1972), for example, the homosexual love among the three women was deeply entangled with class inequality and the impossibility of…

    • 713 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Blackrock Essay

    • 596 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The theme of masculinity is prominent throughout the play. Physical strength and other male attitudes are revealed The audience are positioned to respond to the theme…

    • 596 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In The Good Person of Szechwan, Bertolt Brecht portrays his Marxist ideals through the actions of his characters and their reactions to their poor social conditions. The major theme of his work emphasizes that those who survive are the ones who rule not by goodness but by the evil and corruption in the society. Shu Fu, a wealthy barber, reinforces this notion that good deeds are taken advantage of in the evil and capitalistic world. As the Gods quest for a good person, they come across a man named Wang, who directs them to Shen Teh. Although she does not live by the commandments, Shen Teh convinces the Gods that it is hard to live a good life without money. To maintain her “good” reputation, Shen Teh creates an alter ego cousin, Shui Ta. While Shu Fu is very generous towards Shen Teh financially, he is not perceived as a “good” person. Shu Fu is a significant minor character in The Good Person of Szechwan as he serves to illustrate the difference in Shen Teh and Shui Ta and portrays Brecht’s perspective on goodness.…

    • 1781 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    means a man is limited to see and that is to see the truth and…

    • 263 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    He portrays his humanist views as he alludes to the end of the play where he defines strength as human traits not gender traits. Today the play is seen as a great work of drama because it boldly pointed out the flaws in this patriarchal…

    • 1076 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    contradictory attitude towards power and sexuality. The playwright as a selfconscious critic cum social reformer of his contemporary age, has unveiled…

    • 7939 Words
    • 25 Pages
    Powerful Essays