The Argumentative Essay: The Independence Of Scotland

A subject I have recently analysed is the possible independence of Scotland where I found very strong and opposing opinions about this recent topic. Scottish independence is a relevant and important matter that has been debated for many years but is now at the pinnacle of debate. Both public and politicians have very strong and opposing opinions about independence and throughout this essay I will evaluate the most current and most emotive arguments: those of wealth and cultural identity. Scotland’s finances will always have a massive impact on the decision of independence, and those in the country for the change believe so due to the significant financial increase this could have. A journalist for The Guardian stated that: “In 2004-05,
It is a historic nation with a strong heritage that the country should take pride in. There are certain aspects of Scottish culture that are very distinct and very uniquely Scottish. No where else in the world is tartan made and fashioned into a kilt – that even Scottish men nowadays wear with pride and nostalgia for a time when Scotland was free. Scottish food has almost mythological status as tourists are attracted by the Haggis, expecting to eat a rare Highland animal but instead find out that it is just a mix of offal and oats. However, the tradition of eating Haggis, neeps and tatties on Burns day celebrations is not a laughing matter – as Scotland celebrates one of its most prized poets and writers. Scotland’s literary heritage is something to be extremely proud of: from Sir Walter Scott and Sir Arthur Conan to Liz Lochhead, Carol Ann Duffy and Edwin Morgan Scotland have a rich and diverse literary heritage. With such a strong sense of identity Scotland must surely wish to come out from the shadow of Britain without having to be associated with
In football matches at clubs in Scotland the main flags paraded there are British flags instead of Scottish flags. This also may be due to Scotland being a part of the British army as many people feel it is necessary for them to say they are British if they maybe know someone who is serving their country in the military. Even though Scotland is a part of Britain it has maintained its own identity as a nation. This would not change if it continued to be part of Britain. Scotland would still have their famous writers and famous foods. They have had them when they were independent and still have these foods and these writers now. As haggis is still a regularly used food and we still have new exciting Scottish writers such as JK Rowling. Scotland will continue to be known for this in the