Preview

Tell the Women We'Re Going

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1020 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Tell the Women We'Re Going
Tell the women we’re going
Analysis of the Raymond Carver short story
In my analysis of “Tell the women we’re going”, I have chosen to write a brief resume of the short story. Afterwards I will analyze the relationship between men and women and discuss how the story relates to the frontier theme, and how the wilderness is depicted. Furthermore I have used the Hollywood model to analyze the short story. I believe that the short story is very suitable to this type of analysis, because his style of writing is minimalistic and quite cinematic.
The short story deals with a typical theme for Raymond Carver, who in almost all of his texts portraits the working- and middleclass in the United States for better and for worse. The theme “disappointment over life” which is described through one of the main characters, Jerrys escape from his disappointing life ends with the murder of two girls.
As Raymond Carver often has raw themes as alcoholism, death, violence etc. in his stories is his style of writing not just realism, but often described as dirty realism.
In this assignment we are suppose to describe how the wilderness is depicted in the story. I have found that part very difficult because Raymond Carver has a very limited figurative language. It is actually not possible to form an impression of the wilderness, the impression you get is almost only through the names, cities and places he writes about. But despite his limited figurative language, he nevertheless succeeded making the reader understand that the story takes place in the middle of nowhere.

“Tell the women we’re going” is a short story about the friendship between Bill Jamison and Jerry Roberts. The two friends have grown up together, went to the same schools and shared almost everything including clothes, car and girls. They have always went together right until Jerry drops out of college, marries a girl named Carol and gets a job at Robby’s Mart. When Bill graduates from college, he has many

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    A vast range of literary techniques is employed in the text, all of which contribute to exploring the negative outcome of journeys. Imagery is a predominant throughout the entire text, appealing to the auditory, olfactory, tactile and visual senses. This is highly effective in depicting the wild beauty and the horror of nature. Quotes such as “…the clouds brewing above and the dirt swirling around his feet” and “skyline rushing down to drown his brittle form” conjure up images of the uncontrollable force of nature and the insignificance of humans in comparison. Fudge also encompasses more harsh imagery to further reinforce the harshness of life. This is evident in the quotes, “…spluttered mucus and blood” and “…covered in crusted blood, jaws ripped from his skull”. All these descriptions are then directly linked to nature’s ferocity. Fudge has characterised “The Land” as nature’s representation in the text. He emphasises and reinforces The Land by encompassing heavy use of personification. “the Land was speaking”, “the Land throbbing” and “the Land had suffocated his family” all use personification. The repeated use of ‘the’ before the subject, ‘Land’, combined with the effect of personification, emphasises and reinforces the authority and dominance of nature.…

    • 1240 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    As the two young men drive through the desert, Alexie applies significant imagery to show the isolation and importance of the situation. There is a certain tension in the air when the two old friends reconnect after their falling out. They are alone in the middle of nowhere: “Victor looked around the desert, sniffed the air, felt the emptiness and loneliness” (159). Alexie uses imagery to encapsulate the situation that the two young men are in. To help the reader feel the tension of the isolated experience, imagery is used to describe the spacious and lonely desert. As they trudged through Nevada they “had been amazed at the lack of animal life, at the absence of water, of movement” (149). Alexie’s imagery in this particular scene shows us the fog of tension between Victor and Thomas and gives the readers the feeling of tense isolation. As they travel the sixteen-hour-journey back home, they have hours and hours of desert to think about their shared past. The desert is vast and stripped, which forces them to either be deep in thought or forcibly converse with each other. All of this tension is shown through the description of the desert.…

    • 490 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Raymond Carver’s portrayal of the setting, the physical environment and the homes his characters inhabit completely correlate to a sentimental connection the characters have in their particular stories. Common themes of conflict, acceptance, and separation signify the characters struggle within the stories, more so relating to the differences with their significant others or their family. Carver’s use of household separation and the seasonal influence within the story “A Serious Talk” signifies the characters indifferences as the story progresses. As for the story “Popular Mechanics”, the setting helps foreshadow the relationship at the brink of a devastating occurrence/interpretation. Furthermore, this paper will identify the significance…

    • 119 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The story starts off talking about a cranky Grandmother who wants to get her way all the time; as most old people are cranky and want their way. The Grandmother is arguing with her impatient son, Bailey, and his wife. The family decided that they would be taking a road trip to Florida s that would be more fitting for the whiny grandchildren: John Wesley, June Star and the baby. Along the way, the family stopped to get food and met Red Sammy Butts and his wife. With them, they spoke about the Misfit; the serial killer who escaped prison. As the family was driving, the family got in an accident and was found by the Misfit and his side kicks: Bobby Lee and Haram. As the family was getting murdered, the Grandmother attempted to save the Misfit by telling him the word of God and ensuring him that there is good in the world. Whether the author used this family or another, It shows the importance of religion and family to the reader. Although some may say the characters in her stories are mere vessels to show her religion, the morals of the stories can be shown by using real life characters to prove a…

    • 557 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    “First, it is a commentary on the American Dream. Herb Clutter has made a wonderful life for himself--his daughter, after all, bakes apple pies. But Herb Clutter's American idyll is abruptly and arbitrarily shattered by two petty criminals. The American dream is fragile, and it only functions if marginal people (ex-cons) are not present.”…

    • 4839 Words
    • 20 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Comparatively, in Irving’s short story, Rip Van Winkle, a man goes up to a mountain to hunt to escape from his wife’s nagging. In the short story, the main character’s desire to escape from his responsibilities and his nagging wife was seen as misogyny from female…

    • 416 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Thesis: The author uses imagery, diction and foreshadowing on the characters’ dialogues and narration to evoke a sense of curiosity accompanied with the fear of discovering the truth. All of that is then inserted into the readers’ minds to describe the setting and also the characters’ personalities.…

    • 723 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    First, Raymond Carver's Post-Modern story demonstrates Dirty Realism in a way that many of us…

    • 876 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    This particular play is about an estranged mother and her precociously initiative daughter going on a road trip stretching from Paoli to Yellowstone, both seduced by the idea of a getaway. The daughter is living with her father who is granted full custody by the court in the divorce between her father and mother. The little girl aged fifteen at the time was called Olivia and her beloved father Aaron, but he has married another wife, who is a nasty piece of work in how she treats Olivia. The little girl calls her mother Beatriz a pretty distressed and angry Cuban woman whose intuition to solve the dilemma at hand is to go on a road trip. This paper will be looking at the variables and events that influence’s Olivia’s journey to self-identity…

    • 1062 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    Campbell, Ewing. Raymond Carver: a study of the short fiction. NY: Twayne, 1992. PS3553 .A7894 Z58…

    • 254 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    The idea of the American dream brings tremendous promise and opportunity, however it also brings heartbreaking failure. A character like Jay Gatsby seems to have achieved the American dream with his wealth, power, and lifestyle; however, he is restless and is constantly searching for something more. One is never truly happy, when they are chasing after the unattainable. In this case, Gatsby has been living his life with the hope that one day, he and Daisy could return to the times that they had been together all those years ago. The failure of Gatsby in achieving the elusive American Dream is a symbol for the difficulties in obtaining true happiness.…

    • 814 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Into the Wild

    • 1095 Words
    • 5 Pages

    To Chris McCandless and many others of his ilk like Henry Thoreau and Jack London,the wilderness of the west has a very specific allure. McCandless sees the wilderness as a purer state, a place free of the evils of modern society, where someone like him can find out what he is really made of, live by his own rules, and be completely free. Yet, it is also true that the reality of day-to-day living in the wilderness is not as romantic as he and others like him imagine it to be. Perhaps this explains why many of his heroes who wrote about the wilderness, for example, Jack London, never actually spent much time living in it.…

    • 1095 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Harness

    • 696 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Characters are what draw the reader into a work of fiction. Analyzing another person’s thoughts and feelings is fascinating, so it is crucial that an author depicts a complex character that will occupy the reader’s minds. Many characters surprise us through the course of a story, developing in unexpected ways. An author can use various literary devices to reveal their characters gradually. Hernando Téllez wrote a short story called ‘Just Lather, That’s All’ that contains two contrasting characters. ‘The Harness’, which was written by Ernest Buckler, also includes very strong individuals. They are both portrayed in detail and they leave no doubt in the reader’s mind of the nature of these characters. The method of these depictions varies considerably while accomplishing the same goal.…

    • 696 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Gender Roles

    • 819 Words
    • 4 Pages

    This story takes place on a small farm back in the 1930s, when women hardly had any rights, whether it was in the house or out. The men were the dominant gender no matter what the issue was. Any reader could easily tell that this family was very tight with their money, as many families were back in that day of age. The father had a manual labor job skinning fox for the pelts and the mother had the typical house wife details. At first, I believed that the narrator was going to grow up as a tomboy but as the story went on my thoughts began to evolve just as the story did. Munro slowly but surely changed the theme into a time of struggle for the young female growing up on her father’s farm.…

    • 819 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The American Dream

    • 2100 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Generally considered that the American Dream consists of a healthy family, a well-paying job and a sturdy home. A lot of people dream about it and use all their opportunities to achieve it. However, the socioeconomic situation of the United States is an obstacle to this ideal. The characters who inhabit Raymond Carver’s Cathedral are blue-collar Americans confused and illusioned by the hollow image of an American dream they see on the TV screen every night. Denis Johnson’s protagonists, however, have never heard of an American dream, and are certainly not devoted to achieving it; their lives slip by a state of alcoholism and drug use and futures become brutally shapeless. Their despairs and disappointments are displaced instead through drug addiction, alcoholism, infidelity and unemployment. Nonetheless, there are rare but genuine pulses of hope in both authors’ stories. (Carvarian people find their own ways to communicate and affect each other in order to survive in this brutal world. Johnson’s character is influenced by his own experience and surroundings; his sparks of hope occur while he is on his journey to recovery.) Despite the fallacy of the American Dream, the characters of Denis Johnson and Raymond Carver have occasional moments of hope, either in the struggle to achieve the American Dream, or in spite of it.…

    • 2100 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays