Lecturer: Brendan Pigott
Dipak Prasad Chaulagain
Student ID: 211895
FCT vs Applegate
This is the case where Applegate fight with federal court asking he don’t want pay a taxes when he was not in Australia most of time in that year saying he was not in Australia for whole year so he cant pay taxes. On 8/11/71 he surrendered a lease on his flat, went to Villa for an indefinite term with his wife to set up a law firm there, a branch office. He organized a house in Villa, entered into a lease for 12 months with an option to renew for 12months. He came back to Australia in December 1971 when his wife had a baby then went back to again. He had been sent to Villa for a long period, but not permanently. He didn’t leave any assets in Australia before, although he retained his membership in a hospital benefits fund. In July 1973 he became ill and, in the light of medical advice, decided against remaining indefinitely in the New Hebrides. At his request, he was replaced and returned with his family to Sydney. But for the illness he would have remained in the New Hebrides. During the period he was there he returned to Australia for short periods, twice on vacation and once in connation with the birth of a child.
Issue: Tax must pay on an annual basis; residency must be determined on an annual basis. Was he a resident for the financial year ending 30/6/72? It’s very hard to say he is resident for tax purpose because he has another resident for where he is staying temporally. It seems realistic as well but rules are rules and nobody can go beyond it. The taxation office ask him to pay taxes and he declined and then case gone to court where both parties give the reasons why they wand want taxes and why Applegate don’t want to pay taxes. The taxpayer's permanent place of abode was outside Australia and so he was a non-resident during the part of the year in question. The income then earned by him from sources... [continues]
Cite This Essay
(2011, 09). Taxation Law Assignment. StudyMode.com. Retrieved 09, 2011, from http://www.studymode.com/essays/Taxation-Law-Assignment-781626.html
"Taxation Law Assignment" StudyMode.com. 09 2011. 09 2011 <http://www.studymode.com/essays/Taxation-Law-Assignment-781626.html>.
"Taxation Law Assignment." StudyMode.com. 09, 2011. Accessed 09, 2011. http://www.studymode.com/essays/Taxation-Law-Assignment-781626.html.