Preview

“Student” vs. “Consumer”

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
655 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
“Student” vs. “Consumer”
“Student” vs. “Consumer”
Simon Benlow begins this essay by telling us how the current faculty and staff at is school received a memo in regards to “National Customer Service Week.” He is extremely bothered by the assumption, in this case, that the “customer” the memo is referring to is actually their students. In addition, Benlow begins to tell us how he is concerned “about the slow and subtle infiltration of consumerism into education” (151) and how the consumer has almost replaced the student in higher education. Benlow wants to counter this assumption and offer a brief description of some of the differences between the “customer” and the “student.”
“The customer is always right.” In other words, keep the customer and keep them coming back for more. This phrase is used to keep the customer at ease even if things aren’t going their way. Again, “Have it your way!” Gives the consumer the idea that the business will do anything to meet what we want or need. Finally, “the meal deal bargain” (151), as the author describes, takes away the need to decide on every detail of a potential meal as it is already decided for us. In any case, this is what the consumerism culture is moving towards, limited interaction with the business, less time to think about what we want, and a cut in the amount of energy we are putting into what we are consuming.
Benlow moves on to say “costumers are encouraged to be passive” (151). As customers we should be mentally uninvolved in the decision making process when consuming products. We don’t have to think for ourselves. We purchase someone else’s product, creation, or invention. Benlow continues, “in short, the world of the customer is based on intellectual inactivity.” As consumers we don’t have to invent or research it’s done for us. “Being a customer means being driven by simple and personal desires… and ultimately demanding that those desires be met” (Benlow 125).
As opposed to the passive, cant think for themselves, consumer,

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    In Simon Benlow’s article, “Have it Your Way: Consumerism Invades Education”, he expresses his condemnation towards the college where he teaches, as they are now referring to “students” as “customers”. His disapproval is clearly seen by his use of words like “deeply troubled” and “hostile” (139). He talks about the consumer mentality that lures the individual into a false sense that every want, wish, and desire will be met at his or her discretion by using marketing slogans such as “Have it your way” (139). Benlow fears that continuing with this mentality in education will create students that “will become increasingly blind to the difference between consumerist culture and college culture.” (142)…

    • 249 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Jennifer Croissant presents the article, “Can This Campus Be Bought?” in a persuasive way, discussing how the image of a university is affected due to the relationships with large corporations. Croissant provides multiple examples as well as standpoints allowing audiences to view a problem from different perspectives. She points out the reason the corporations are willing to donate money to universities; yet, it is in a form of commercialization on campuses. They are interested in gaining power over the educational institutions, in regards to their popularity and advertisements. On the contrary, the institutions lose the core values, freedom, virtue, and autonomy; strictly speaking, their tendency of being independent has been declined. According to Croissant, this leaves bad images for the schools and they will lose the public and community’s trust and credibility on a large scale. Although she is not against being associated with the commercial activities to stay connected with the outside world, she justifies that there should be a limit in order to prevent the school’s pride, images and capabilities of making decisions. I, as a reader, have a neutral thought in despite of seeing Croissant’s arguments very convincing and helpful because corporate sponsorships also have a big impact in students’ academic lives.…

    • 816 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    He talks specifically about the “buyer’s market” known as college, and how its recent changes now “serve . . . the students” (14). Similarly to his previous section, logos is apparent here, more so than any other rhetoric appeal. His claim that universities are “customer driven” in order to survive in an “ever more competitive market” is his main point, and he shapes this claim based on the evidence of not only America’s history and the expansion of its universities, but also how the universities and even departments are collapsing to the whims of the students and their tuition-paying parents (12). Universities have begun to appeal to students not by offering them a thought-provoking and stimulating education and proposing to them what sort of people they will shape out of those willing to learn, but by enticing students with the promise of the fun social activities they will have available to them once they are released from their boring…

    • 1447 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mark Edmundson is a professor of English at the University of Virginia additionally, he is the author of the article “On the Uses of the Liberal Education: As Lite Entertainment for Bored College Students.” In the article, he describes how the students perk up during the evaluation of him as a teacher. The student evaluations commend him as being interesting and humerous which leads him into the rant about what he thinks of college students today. The article describes students as having “little passion and little fire” and indicates their more devoted to “consumption and entertainment.” Edmundson argues students education would be more effective if it is treated as a privilege rather than a commodity.…

    • 940 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Docwra's book provides frank views on the course consumerism has put the society on. Docwra takes a serious approach to the aspects of consumerism, the sections in Docwra's book are at first problematic and situational but then become rectifying and provides direction on everything from the effects of consumerism to what is wrong with consumerism resulting in what can we do about consumerism. Docwra informs us on the negative effects consumerism places upon us, but Docwra puts most attention into providing tactics we can use to stop consumerism. He states: "To move away from a culture of consumerism, we will therefore need to challenge the philosophy and values of this current economic system. Essentially, we need a cultural shift in our society…

    • 262 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    The number of students pursuing a higher education has increased over the last few decades. Universities are creating new innovate ways to accommodate the increase in students attending. As a result, many academic intuitions are commercializing. Commercialization is the process of managing something for financial gain. Many corporations commercialize with organizations to make a profit. For this reason, many corporations are now commercializing in universities to expand their businesses. In fact, colleges can gain profit from collaborating with commercial interests. In “Can This Campus Be Bought?” by Jennifer L. Croissant, she discusses commercialization in academic institutions. Jennifer L. Croissant is an associate professor at the University of Arizona. She proposes that commercialization is negatively affecting universities. She uses this claim to support how students and education are impacted by commercial restraints.…

    • 1028 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Students enrolled at community college are lost high school graduates and employees seeking to gain certain skills is the minor persuasiveness found in the argument. This statement is persuasive due to the audience of a select few higher class individuals, whom probably never attended community college. Farrington opens the readers to categorize community college students within these two stereotypes. The lack of morals demonstrated in his approach to stereotyping, reveals an ad hominem fallacy. The biased tactic of bullying to get his way leaves readers disgusted by Farrington’s stereotypical remarks. More or less, Farrington unsuccessfully argued his way into an abysmal ending with his personal attacks. If personal accounts of students continuing towards a university but were confined by financial obligations was stated, a more intelligent, unbiased argument could have been…

    • 1037 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Does one ever find themselves feeling more like a customer rather than a student? If so, don’t think you are alone. Today more people are thinking about the so called “Student Customer” metaphor, and how it can have a huge impact on their future life and decisions. Mark Edmundson’s 2013 book “Why Teach?” explores the real meaning of the metaphor, and argues how Colleges and Universities in the United States are only focusing on the financial aspect of life.…

    • 1228 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Emerson vs Swimme

    • 2156 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Swimme, Brian. “How Do Our Kids Get So Caught Up In Consumerism.” The Human Experience: Who Am I?. Ed. Winthrop University. 8th ed. Littleton, MA: Tapestry, 2012. 155-157. Print.…

    • 2156 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Edmundson’s opinion, being a consumerist instead of being a student makes you lose parts of yourself identity and you start acting like the ones around you and the people you see on TV. He states in this article that schools have replaced the word genius with the word consumerist. He explains that if your purpose of going to school is to learn then you are considered to be an outcast. Even though teachers like the outcast, because they think for themselves, they change their classes for the students that are there to fill up the seats instead of their brain. Television shows that the right thing to do is go to college after high school, and since kids mimic what they see on television they go and have no real reason or point of being there. This shows how they are…

    • 482 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the article, “Are Colleges Worth the Price of Admission?” by Andrew Hacker and Claudia Dreifus, the authors did research on several colleges around the country to see whether our investment on higher education is really worth the money that we pay for it. The authors believe that universities are the ones responsible for the doubling of tuition costs compared to what they used to be , and not fulfilling the most important objective to student’s which is: “to challenge the minds of young people” (180). In the article, Hacker and Dreifus outline some things they think would help improve some of the problems in the college system and a few universities that they like, and tell us why these schools have won their favor. Being an incoming freshman at Grambling State University, I’ve been able to see some of the issues universities can have from budget cuts, to problems with the G-men football team.…

    • 822 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Rhetorical Analysis Essay

    • 1157 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Regarding these businesses, such as Barnes & Noble and Starbucks, having a dominant presence on campus Lugo Lugo states, “It is no surprise that college students behave not like people seeking a higher form of knowledge but like customers of academia. They walk into the bookstore as customers, and they walk into my classroom, latte in hand, as customer as well” (195). Describing how student attitudes morph her role, she says that “[t]rying to accommodate the I like it better this way or I like it better that way turn professors into customer service representatives…” (196). More than customer service representatives, I feel it almost turns them into a wait staff at a restaurant; students being the fussy guests. If students function under the assumption that the sole purpose of an educator is to cater to each and every whim, rather than provide a chance for them to grow academically and personally, then I believe they’ve missed the mark entirely. A college education is much like employment in that you’re there to gain experience, not to be served. However, when faced with the realization that society does in fact seem to have a heavy focus on shopping, it is not surprising that universities have turned into “a shopping mall” with the professors view as the retail employees…

    • 1157 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Edmundson

    • 742 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Mark Edmundson’s “On the uses of a Liberal Education” provides interesting points on why the liberal arts education is becoming part of consumer goods and how education is being advertised. Edmundson states different causes for this effect and comes up with consumer culture in society. He believes that the liberal art education is unsuccessful because Americans are attracted to consumption and entertainment. Education is becoming more about consumerism and not about students’ education because it is what they are expected not because they want they choose to higher their education. Edmundson’s view on what education means that the students are learning and improving their education and not just doing it for consumerism.…

    • 742 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Visual Analysis Paper

    • 973 Words
    • 4 Pages

    It is no secret that our society is increasing the demand for a college education, as more and more people are going to college each year in hopes of making a better life for themselves. The main purpose to go to college is to expand the minds of students and to offer them the knowledge to attain good, quality jobs that they could not have received without a degree. The blame for expensive university costs can be spread among a handful of subjects, but political cartoonist Jeff Parker’s “Higher Education” places the blame on the public universities themselves. In this cartoon, various rhetorical strategies are used to show the cartoonist’s opinion of universities increasing the already large financial burden of higher education. The cartoon hints that colleges and universities are to blame for raising tuition costs by showing a student standing on top of a mound of debt trying to reach a degree that is being pulled away from him. The political cartoon suggests public university students are subject to the discretion and motives of the university itself by oversimplifying the university’s effect on rising tuition costs and budget cuts, which represents a growing concern the author has for the future.…

    • 973 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Pamela Spencer Case

    • 2177 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Cited: Brown, Carol A., Christina L. Grippi, and John W. Mullins. Pamela Spencer: Is the Customer Always Right? The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc., 2012. Print.…

    • 2177 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays