On the morning of August 4, 1892 Lizzie Borden frantically called for her maid Maggie to come down to their sitting room. It was there that the body of Andrew Borden was discovered. His wife Abby was later discovered dead in an upstairs bedroom. Lizzie claimed to be in the yard when the murders took place, but police suspected otherwise.
News of the murders spread like wildfire. Stories about the Bordens tragic deaths were printed in newspapers within hours. Citizens of Fall River were in an uproar and no one felt safe. It was soon alleged by a local Pharmacist that Lizzie had attempted to purchase prussic acid, a poisonous colorless acid just the day before. With these new allegations of a pre-meditated attempt at murder, suspicions arose and the case against Lizzie was being built.
Lizzie's trial began on June 5, 1893 and lasted fourteen days. The Prosecution team was led by attorneys Hosea Knowlton and his assistant William Moody. They went on to present evidence such as Lizzie's attempt to purchase poison prior to the murders, a burned dress, her feelings toward her stepmother as well as her motive to inherit money from her father who at the time of his death had no will. But without direct evidence of Lizzie's part in the murder, the jury was not convinced of her guilt.
On June 19, 1893 closing arguments began and for the first and only time during the...