- Using information from the Items and elsewhere assess sociological explanations of boys underachievement in education ( 20 marks )
The male underachievement has been a concern since the mid 90's. The media portrayed this and moral panic went around family households and concerns in schools followed soon after. It is mainly the working class black boys that tended to underachieve in education. Also the male underachievement is partly to do with external factors, these are things that happen outside of school. Poor literacy skills and the decline of traditional male jobs, for example manufacturing etc. Another is internal factors that have affected the underachievement. Laddish subculture, feminisation of education and a shortage of male school teachers in primary schools.
Fancis and Skelton (2005) believe that the concern over this issue has been an exaggerated 'moral panic' - a sudden and illogical outburst about a supposed decline in society that does not reflect reality. However, there is evidence that shoes that certain boys are underachieving. Working class boys still tend to do very poorly in the education system. There has been a widening of the gender gap, the difference in performance between males and females. This suggests that there is some problems to explain the underachievement in boys.
Underachievement in boys also comes from the lack of interaction between the culture of masculinity and the education system. Francis (2000) suggests that both genders face problems in education, but there are number of problems specific to boys. Boys get more classroom attention from teachers, but are criticized more by teachers. This is demotivating them and lowering their expectations. Secondly in the 1970's, boys tended to think that they were more able than girls. Changing teachers attitudes and publicity about male underachievement have led to boys losing their confidence. And lastly the stereotype of the ideal pupil tends to fit girls better than boys. And boys are more keen to remain popular with their peer groups.
Jackson, the laddish subculture 2006 used interviews and questionnaires to study masculinity and femininity in eight schools, she found that the schools were dominated by a culture of hegemonic masculinity which valued toughness, power and competitiveness. Academic work is seen as feminine so is seen as 'uncool' by the boys. Boys mess around and try to impress their peers. This suggests that boys underachieve because mostly of peers and low-self worth and low-self esteem.
Item A suggests that boys and schooling take 3 main forms. There are stories about ' poor boys', who are the victims of feminism of teachers, about schools which fail them and about their laddishness. They seek to use girls to take control and police boys and teach them, leaving boys to retaliate because they think it's uncool so their achievement in school may go down because of rebellion.
Sociologists Mitsos and Browne (1998) found other factors operating inside the education system, they argue that teachers now have low expectations of boys. They expect them to be disruptive and their work to be late and rushed. They therefore tend not to push boys to do better when they are underperforming. Boys may become disillusioned with education in their early years. Primary school environments tend to be female-dominated and may have an excessive emphasis on being neat and tidy, which are not boys strengths. These are some of the reasons why boys are underachieving according to Mitsos and Browne.
Feminists such as Osler (2006) believe that the current concern about underachievement by boys has led to neglect of the problem of underachievement among girls. For example, when pupils are excluded from school more help is now available for boys than girls. The emphasis on the underachievement by boys could also obscure the importance of social class since it is largely working - class boys who underachieve.
Item B says that the statistical data that informs people that boys are underachieving is misleading. It is social class not gender and race differences that continues to have the sing;e most important influence on educational attainment in Britian. This suggests that it is inaccurate to imply that all boys underperform and that all girls do well. The real question is; what action is being taken to raise the academic performance of working - class girls as well as other underachievers?
To conclude, sociologists have different eplanations of how boys are underachieving and what is to be done. They are all very similar to each other and all take into account other social backgrounds. The underachievement in education in boys at school is mostly to do with what happens inside of school and the consequences of these actions.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
When analysing the influence of social class on educational achievement it’s crucial to examine both internal and external factors.…
- 1885 Words
- 8 Pages
Powerful Essays -
This article written by Judith Gill and Karen Starr highlights the history of gender reform in the Australian education system and the backlashes associated with it. The main debate which is being discussed in this article is that of disadvantaged boys. After a long time of feminists fighting for equal rights of girls in Australian schools, the Boys in Education lobbyists are fighting for increased attention to be given to boys in schools. Gill and Starr don’t believe that the boys are disadvantaged and have written this paper to demonstrate the superfluousness of the Boys in Education lobby and the lack of necessity for their demands.…
- 658 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
I will be discussing whether the students underachieving is due to the labeling process’ in school or if there are other reasons for this, and how sociologists may agree with it.…
- 534 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
This essay will explain the history of gender relations and how it has developed to the current situation; identify explanations for boys’ underachievement involving the role of the school, teacher perceptions and learning styles, and; explore the concept of ‘laddishness’, which appears to be a significant factor in the underachievement of boys.…
- 4009 Words
- 17 Pages
Better Essays -
Middle class children have a higher tendency of achieving more than pupils of the working class. A few explanations pay attention on the external factors outside school. This includes cultural deprivation – working class pupils are portrayed as having a lack of correct attitude, values, language and knowledge for educational success. Whilst material deprivation means that working class pupils are most likely to have poorer diets, health and housing and their parents are less able to meet the hidden costs of schooling. The middle class have mote cultural capital – they have a better advantage of their choices within the marketised education system.…
- 1373 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
The school is instrumental in the socialisation of males into traditional hegemonic roles. Becky Francis (2000) found that, although they were more harshly disciplined than the girls, boys’ behaviour was tolerated more by the teachers. This encourages the boys to demonstrate the traditional masculinities. Subject choice is also an important factor in male socialisation as they were traditionally gender biased. This was studied by Grafton in a comprehensive school in which he showed that there were only a limited number of placements available for those who wanted to study non-traditional subjects for their gender. This reduces interest in those subjects and guides males into the more traditional, craft subjects. Males are canalized meaning they are directed into playing with certain toys and activities. For example, boys may play football while the girls play ‘house’.…
- 670 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Contemporary views are that class is still the most significant social factor for accounting for differences in educational achievement. It seems that middle class children tend to do better than working class children. Most sociologists believe that in every social class there is the same range of ability, this means that class differences in educational attainment are not due to class differences in intelligence, but due to other circumstances such as the home and socialization. However some sociologists would argue that attainment in classes results from sifting, sorting and assessment of pupils in terms of teacher’s perceptions of class, ability and conduct. Throughout this essay, the view that working class underachievers in school is because of home circumstances will be assessed.…
- 1202 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
the status generate boys who cannot realize their aspirations by their means. On a cultural level,…
- 273 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
They receive affirmation of this through the media, their peers, and by the longstanding social decree that place more value on male children. This problem is not confined only to American schools. When looking at seventeen nations, females consistently were outranked by their male contemporaries. Peer pressure, consisting of all genders, races, and status, in school also causes a lack of academic excellence. For example, in an all black high school in Washington,D.C., "if they did well in their studies, they might be accused of "acting white."" (Ravitch,3) The student 's are faced with fighting against conforming to what is considered the "norm" for their situation or being ostracised. Those who place their education as more important face the chances of being labeled a number of unflattering terms that could potentially make the school years a trial.…
- 795 Words
- 4 Pages
Better Essays -
In “Mind over Muscle”, David Brooks supports the claim that education has been over feminized. Brooks tells that this world used to be a man’s world until the information age came along, in which education is the “gateway to success. And that means this is turning into a woman’s world, because women are better students than men” (Brooks 410). Brooks asks several questions trying to figure out ways for boys to succeed. He suggests that we need to take a look at the “innate differences between sexes” (Brooks 411). Brooks tells that the problem with females outdoing males could very well be from society but he also suggest that it could be from the basic differences between males…
- 735 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The explanations of differential educational achievement that have been examined so far suggest that pupils’ progress is influenced by factors over which they have little control. Yet the most obvious place to look for explanations is within the education system. Schools play an important role in determining the success of failure of an individual’s education. There are many factors which lead to the under achievement for some people, these fall under three main categories Genetic, External and Internal. The focus of my essay will be to outline factors leading to under achievement through internal factors.…
- 1226 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
There is a lot of compelling evidence to support the view that changes in the education system has resulted in differences in educational achievement between males and females. There is no denying that the statistics show girls are outperforming boys at every level in education, but the question is whether this is largely related to changes in the assessment process and the way each of the genders is educated or whether there are other factors causing the differences.…
- 817 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
From the early 1990’s, girls have started to outperform boys at most levels of the education system, for example in GCSE related in subjects or A-levels. As Madsen Pirie of the New Right Adam Smith Institute states that the modular courses and continuous education today favour the systematic approach of girls, compared to the previous old O level exam which favoured more towards boys. These stated changes are known to be the main major causes which changes gender differences in the educational system. However, as well as these internal factors, there are also external factors following this result, such as the impact on feminism and changes in the job industry which may have influenced girls into working harder resulting in more succession educationally wise.…
- 347 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Terry, B. and L. Terry, (2000) Boys’ underachievement is a problem, but it is not their fault! Current perceptions and practical strategies NFER research…
- 4095 Words
- 17 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Outline the ways in which factors in children’s home background may lead to differences in achievement levels between different groups.…
- 445 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays