Preview

Romantic love is a poor basis for marriage.

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
2901 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Romantic love is a poor basis for marriage.
Introduction
The decline of marriage in the West has been extensively researched over the last three decades (Carmichael and Whittaker; de Vaus; Coontz; Beck-Gernshein). Indeed, it was fears that the institution would be further eroded by the legalisation of same sex unions internationally that provided the impetus for the Australian government to amend the Marriage Act (1961). These amendments in 2004 sought to strengthen marriage by explicitly defining, for the first time, marriage as a legal partnership between one man and one woman. The subsequent heated debates over the discriminatory nature of this definition have been illuminating, particularly in the way they have highlighted the ongoing social significance of marriage, even at a time it is seen to be in decline.
Demographic research about partnering practices (Carmichael and Whittaker; Simons; Parker; Penman) indicates that contemporary marriages are more temporary, fragile and uncertain than in previous generations. Modern marriages are now less about a permanent and "inescapable" union between a dominant man and a submissive female for the purposes of authorised sex, legal progeny and financial security, and more about a commitment between two social equals for the mutual exchange of affection and companionship (Croome). Less research is available, however, about how couples themselves reconcile the inherited constructions of romantic love as selfless and unending, with trends that clearly indicate that romantic love is not forever, ideal or exclusive.
Civil marriage ceremonies provide one source of data about representations of love. Civil unions constituted almost 70 per cent of all marriages in Australia in 2010, according to the Australian Bureau of Statistics. The civil marriage ceremony has both a legal and symbolic role. It is a legal contract insofar as it prescribes a legal arrangement with certain rights and responsibilities between two consenting adults and outlines an expectation that



References: to children also feature in marriage ceremonies, and for the couples I have worked with marriage is generally seen as the pre-requisite for children. Couples also often talk about "being ready" for marriage. This seems to refer to being financially prepared. Robyn Parker citing the research of K. Edin concludes that for many modern couples "rushing into marriage before being 'set ' is irresponsible--marrying well (in the sense of being well prepared) is the way to avoid divorce" (qtd. in Parker 81). From this overview of reoccurring themes in the production of Australian ceremonies it is clear that romantic love continues to be associated with marriage. However, couples describe a more grounded and companionable attachment. These more practical and personalised sentiments serve to meet both the public expectation that romantic love is a precondition for marriage, while also avoiding the production of romantic love in the ceremony as an empty cliché. Grounded descriptions of love reveal that attraction does not have to be overwhelming and unconquerable. Indeed, couples who have lived together and are intimately acquainted with each other 's habits and disposition, appear to be most comfortable expressing their commitment to each other in more temperate, but no less deeply felt, terms. Conclusion This paper has considered how brides and grooms constitute romantic love within the shifting partnering practices of contemporary Australia. It is evident "in the midst of significant social and economic change and at a time when individual rights and freedom of choice are important cultural values" marriage remains socially significant (Simons 50). This significance is partially conveyed through the language of romantic love, which, while freighted with an array of cultural and historical associations, remains the lingua franca of marriage, perhaps because as Roberto Unger observes, romantic love is "the most influential mode of moral vision in our culture" (qtd. in Lindholm 5). It is thus possible to conclude, that while marriage may be declining and becoming more fragile and impermanent, the institution remains important to couples in contemporary Australia. Moreover, the language and imagery of romantic love, which publicly conveys this importance, remains the primary mode of expressing care, affection and hope for a partnership, even though the changed partnering practices of late modern capitalist society have exposed the utopian quality of romantic love and produced a cynicism about the viability of its longevity. It is evident in the marriage ceremonies prepared by the author that while the language of romantic love has come to signify a broader range of more practical associations consistent with the individualised nature of modern marriage and demystification of romantic love, it also remains the best way to express what Dowd and Pallotta describe as a fundamental human "yearning for communion with and acceptance by another human being" (571).

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    In the essay “The Radical Idea of Marrying for Love”, Stephanie Coontz discusses the change marriage has made among the different cultures around the world and how it went from being an act that was necessary to something that was done for personal joy and fulfillment.…

    • 451 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the essay “The Radical Idea of marrying for Love,” Stephanie Coontz voices her opinion on George Shaw theory, the expectations of love and how it has changed over time. Shaw believes that marriage is “an institution that brings together two people under the influence of the most violent, most insane, most delusive and most transient of passions (Coontz 378). Marriage overtime had different variations depending the time frame in which it was in, and the culture that influenced it.…

    • 1173 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    “Against Love”: immediately controversy is conveyed by the title of Laura Kipnis’ article on modern relationships. The reader is put on the defensive as Kipnis starts her argument with strong metaphors attacking one of the most basic human interactions that we see as natural and embrace without question. Namely, love, a word held in superposition between complex and simple. Kipnis argues it has been overrated and too much is sacrificed in the pursuit of making it last. Defining her own terms that apply to most relationships such as “advanced intimacy” and “mutuality” she provides a new perspective on old notions. Her tone throughout is consistently sarcastic but make no mistake, Kipnis is addressing a real issue on what we value as a society. Descriptive language is Kipnis’ fishing line that keeps you reading, often creating vivid and objectionable images that no one can avoid cringing at. Concepts surrounding love and the ideal couple change from age to age and from culture to culture but Kipnis doesn’t disregard this. She compares today’s norms to historical precedence as she identifies the shift from focusing on the convenience of financially organized marriages to the achievement of unending life-long love. Kipnis’ article presents a fascinating argument by proposing an idea…

    • 1481 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Over the last 40 years marriage rates have declined significantly while the number of couple’s cohabitating has risen rapidly. This is due to our changing society where equality, laws, social acceptance and religions have all contributed into the way we view marriage and relationships. In the 1970’s there were around 400,000 first marriages whereas, in 2011, there were 248,000. The average ages of people getting married have also increased from 25 for men and 23 for women in 1961 to 36 for men and 33 for women in 2011. Cohabitation is a big factor in the decreasing number of marriages with people using it as either an alternative to marriage entirely, or a ‘trial marriage’ which just delays the time of a couple’s marriage.…

    • 918 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    David Blankenhorn is a world authority on the institution of marriage. One of the biggest debates concerning marriage today is whether we should expand the concept to include same-sex marriage. Blankenhorn thinks not, and in his book titled, The Future of Marriage, sets out to make the case against homosexual marriage. But he does so, pre-eminently, by making the case for the institution of heterosexual marriage. Blankenhorn first seeks to get a handle on what marriage is, and then he shows how it has been experienced over the centuries. The first half of the book is about what marriage is, and how it has developed. The second half deals with the challenge of same-sex marriage. Although homosexual couples should have the right to love one another without experiencing prejudice, their unions should not be labeled as a “marriage”, for this would cause our society to rethink the values of marriage and how it pertains to children.…

    • 2069 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Stephanie Coontz’s essay on “The Radical Idea of Marrying for Love” shows her opinion that the expectations of marriage are unrealistic based on different societies around the world in different time periods. For example in George Bernard Shaw’s theory, he believed that married was “an institution that brings together two people under the influence of the most violent, most insane, most delusive and most transient of passions” (qtd. I’m Coontz 378). In our history all of the world marriage has been said to be a tool of survival. Emotional love played a small part in marriage and was even sometimes discouraged. Even in today’s world love is still no seen as a necessity of marriage.…

    • 286 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the short story “Federigo’s Falcon” by Giovanni Boccaccio evidence is shown that points to the change that was coming. In Boccaccio’s story a widow named Monna Giovanna was urged relentlessly by her brothers to remarry as she was wealthy and young. Nonetheless Monna stood her ground finally agreeing to remarry but only on her terms. This small action spoke volumes, though it was something that would most certainly not have happened at the time it illustrated the need for change and foreshadowed the coming of such change. Now, centuries later that change has made marriage a beautiful thing in 2016 people can marry just about whoever they want and actual love is at the center of it all and is now the main focus of this age old…

    • 626 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the article” The Radical Idea of Marrying for Love “the author gives a global interpretation of what marrying for love means to different cultures. While Americans strive to focus on the love connection before marriage, the writer of the article Stephanie Coontz points out that other countries practice the total opposite. Although marriage is an institution that brings two people together, Coontz describes this as being “under the influence of the most violent, most insane, most delusive and most transient of passions” and are required to feel excited about each other every day for the rest of their lives until death do them apart.…

    • 919 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Modern Romance Summary

    • 1309 Words
    • 6 Pages

    This new stage has been growing for the past 50 years, Emerging Adulthood is a time for young adults to travel, educate, meet and date knew people and discover oneself before settling down into a marriage. This new staged has pushed back the average age of marriage from around 23 for men and 21 for women to about 30 for men and 28 for women. Emerging Adulthood has lead to the rise in the “Soul Mate Marriage”, rather than the older model the “Compassionate Marriage”. The soul mate marriage is based on love and passion, and not proximity and hope of love later down the…

    • 1309 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Marriage Act 1961

    • 992 Words
    • 4 Pages

    According to the Marriage Act 1961, marriage in Australia is defined as, “the union of a man and a woman to the exclusion of all others, voluntarily entered into for life.” It is said that a “good law” is that which consists of five key features; one being that the law reflects the changing values of society (Sykes, 2002). The aspect of marriage being allowed only between a man and a woman has been widely contested among people as society has evolved and this provokes debate.…

    • 992 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    An alternative, Brake proposes, is minimal marriage. The theoretical framework for Brake’s minimal marriage is the promotion of caring relationships. In practice, this would be implemented as a selective distribution of the benefits that should be associated with a caring-relationship. If we cannot promise to love someone eternally, maybe we can promise to act and behave in certain ways (Brake 196). Brake gives examples of such promises: sexual-exclusivity, caretaking or even acting amorously toward one another (Brake 196-197). Specifically, Brake specifies that promises that conflict with certain moral requirements such as self-respect cannot be the subject of promises (Brake 197), nor can eternal love be. What further specific promises can or cannot be made would require an empirical discussion of specific cases, which is beyond the purpose of this philosophical work. Thus, issues such as promising healthcare will not be discussed in this paper, but it will be assumed that this is an economic good that can be promised.…

    • 1568 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Fatal Attraction

    • 1662 Words
    • 7 Pages

    One of the reasons that so many marriages today end up in divorce today has to do with the interpersonal personal relationship principle known as fatal attraction. When most people think of fatal attraction, they right away think of the popular definition represented in the movie “Fatal Attraction”. This paper will define the principle of fatal attraction from an interpersonal relationship perspective. Along with a definition of fatal attraction, I will explore some of the causes of fatal attraction. I will discuss my experiences with fatal attractions. Peer reviewed articles together with my own personal experiences will be used to further expound on the definition of fatal attraction. I have illustrated the effect that fatal attraction has had on my own interpersonal relationship. I will also show how in a relationship other principles of interpersonal relationships are influenced by fatal attraction. This paper will also provide an example of how a fatal attraction can take an emotional and psychological toll not on a relationship but also in an individual.…

    • 1662 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Over the past 40 years patterns of marriage, the legal binding of a couple, and cohabitation, an unmarried couple living together in a sexual relationship, have fluctuated. Whilst the number of first-time marriages has declined, remarriages have increased. Cohabitation has also been on a steady increase. Sociologists are very much interested in the reasons for these changes. In the following essay I will explore the reasons for such changes, for example, secularisation, the decline in stigma, changes in the position of women, fear of divorce and forever adapting lifestyles.…

    • 680 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Marrying for Love

    • 654 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Today there are many different types of marriages that are widely recognized; however, monogamy and polygamy are most commonly accepted. While looking for marriage there are many reasons for someone to choose a desirable mate. Looks, personalities, fame, power, money and love are just a few of the things that people may search for when choosing who they want to marry. Many people today feel that love should be the primary factor in marriage, however “very rarely in history has love been seen as the main reason for getting married” (Coontz 378). The views toward different types of marriages from the 1600s all the way up until today are introduced in the article “The Radical Idea of Marrying for Love”. The author Stephanie Coontz explains and informs readers how some cultures and religions viewed love as a basis for marriage then and today.…

    • 654 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Hall, Scott. "Exploring Young Marital Meaning Adults ' Belief Systems About Marriage." Journal of Family Issues. 27.10 (2006): 1-22. Web. 16 Nov. 2011. .…

    • 1073 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays

Related Topics