Preview

Rhetorical Analysis of “The Dangerous Myth of Grade Inflation”

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1229 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Rhetorical Analysis of “The Dangerous Myth of Grade Inflation”
Ronnie Reed
Dr. Dixon
EH 132
16 October 2014
Rhetorical Analysis of “The Dangerous Myth of Grade Inflation”
There is proof in the pudding. This cliché has been used an immeasurable amount of times to express that evidence to the claim leads to its legitimacy. It has been speculated for many years that grades are being inflated, and students are receiving A’s for mediocre work. In fact, the introduction of Alfie Kohn’s “The Dangerous Myth of Grade Inflation” shows reports of the matter made by Harvard Professor Harvey Mansfield and Harvard’s Committee on Raising the Standard, respectively, with a gap of over a century (pg. 1). Kohn expresses his take on the matter of grade inflation and asserts that these accusations are false and ill-supported. Using arguments and logic to give his assertions a backbone, Kohn is successful in illuminating that grading as a whole, not grade inflation, is the overlooked problem by educators and students in colleges everywhere. So you be the judge. Is there proof in the pudding?
Alfie Kohn is addressing the topic of grading inflation to educators and students, and his widely respected lecturing status attests to his knowledge on the matter. The author of 13 books, Kohn has been speculated to be "perhaps the country 's most outspoken critic of education 's fixation on grades and test scores" (www.alfiekohn.org). In “The Dangerous Myth of Grade Inflation,” he is debating the existence of grade inflation and pointing out factual evidence to prove his assertions.
As I stated above, he begins his piece with quotes from the prestigious Harvard University. To show that some really do consider grade inflation a serious problem, Kohn states that The Boston Globe “in a tone normally reserved for the discovery of entrenched corruption in state government” posted articles on a surplus of Harvard students receiving A’s and graduating with honors (pg. 1). He then goes on to notify the reader, when it comes to investigating this issue, the



Cited: Kohn, Alfie. “The Dangerous Myth of Grade Inflation.” Authenticity. Ed. Shane Borrowman. Southlake, Tx: Fountain Head Press. 2012. Print. Kohn, Alfie. www.alfiekohn.org. Retrieved from http://www.alfiekohn.org/bio.htm

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    When someone asks you why earning a higher grade in class is important to receive, your first response might be to help increase your grade point average (GPA). But why is a high GPA so coveted? Is it to get into a good post graduate school? But then why is this important? You would probably respond by saying to create more opportunities for yourself when it comes to a career to venture in. These are the questions that Steven Vogel dives into, and gets to the point that through all of these questions lead up to one underlying factor that grades are money and learning is what is paid for. He believes students will attempt to maximize…

    • 979 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Response Essay

    • 809 Words
    • 4 Pages

    I embrace Alfie Kohn’s ideology that by grading a student’s work one actually hinders the process of learning. Having three school-aged children myself, I see the effect grades have on their mindset. If they do not achieve an “A” they feel less than their peers. I also have seen instances where they will pick the easiest assignment or not bother to complete extra credit assignments for grading. Therefore, in this regard I do agree that grading does play a factor in their learning experience. However, the practicality of overcoming the mindset of a nation of people is a daunting task that may very well take years to persuade. As much as I may agree with Mr. Kohn’s ideology, I do not see this becoming mainstreamed within the educational system any time in the near future. His ideology would have to be fully embraced by the educational system for steps of improvement in grading students to take hold. This may very well take a grass roots effort from the parents and citizens themselves before ideology could be changed, which would take much time in educating the public on this subject. As much as I personally would love to see this type of learning be prevalent within our educational system I do not see it happening in my lifetime. One can only hope.…

    • 809 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the article, The Case against Grades, Alfie Kohn talks about how the grading system is deflecting the actual purpose of why students are interested in classes. He speaks on how grades tend to diminish students and create a preference for what a student has to aim for in his or hers course. I myself have experienced this in my academic life.…

    • 784 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “Making the Grade” by Kurt Wiesenfeld, was published in June, 1996, in the Newsweek magazine, explaining the possible threats of grade inflation and cynical grading. After thoroughly analyzing Wiesenfelds article, I was astonished at how critical and potentially dangerous it is, in the present university grading systems, to allow students alleged “potential” to outdo effort and intelligence. Weisenfeld later states, “Last year a light tower in the Olympic Stadium collapsed, killing a worker. It collapsed because an engineer miscalculated how much weight it could hold.” This is completely unacceptable. Engineers do not miscalculate, students working towards their master’s degree do. Once they receive their master’s degree, they should of course, have mastered their profession. This was not the case. Not only does this demonstrate that titles aren’t always properly earned, but also that unqualified persons are flowing through our work system.…

    • 569 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Ny Times Review

    • 630 Words
    • 3 Pages

    An article was published in The New York Times by Max Roosevelt titled “Student Expectations Seen as Causing Grades Disputes.” The focus of this editorial was to highlight what is often seen as a disruption to grades and our educational system. Many students these days feel they are entitled to higher grades because they did what was only expected of them which do not involve the greatest effort. In my opinion, a student that subjects themselves to minimum effort should receive the minimum grade without any complaints. In past experience, I have realized that students fail to recognize their creative abilities which cause typical mind-sets and projections. Professor Marshall Grossman of the University of Maryland presumes that he will receive complaints whenever he returns assignments to students; many feel as though they are privileged in this manner. Grossman’s point is outlined relatively throughout the article, providing useful information through personal experience based on his observations. A recent study by researchers at the University of California, Irvine, highlights his objective whereas 40 percent of surveyors believe that they should receive a B just for completing the required reading.…

    • 630 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Standardized exams are made to measures a student’s achievement level. Educators what to see if their kids are ready for college. Now, some have argued that teachers’ grades are sufficient. But the reality is that teacher grading practices can be wildly uneven across schools and…

    • 488 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Ferritor, D. (2006, Vol. 12, No. 6). “Grade Inflation in Higher Education Isolated or Symmetric?” International Journal of Learning.…

    • 2140 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the essay, “What Our Education System Needs is More F’s”, Singleton suggests that educators should embrace the grade letter F instead of adopting a system of leniency that allows a student to not fully master his assignments and still obtain the opportunity to pass his grade level. The author feels that by adopting a black and white grading system, awarding students who meet academic standards and presenting F’s to those who don’t, will call the attention of students, parents, and teachers. He doesn’t claim that giving out F’s by the dozens presents a solution, but he feels that handing out F’s sends out a message and draws a starting line towards a more active and responsible education system. Singleton identifies the lack of student motivation, the absent parent involvement in education, and poor teaching skills as results of America’s poor education system.…

    • 961 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    College students are receiving high A’s in which they don’t deserve to get at all. He also states that students are threatening to complain if they do not turn C's to A's. Brent Staples writes in that one way to stanch grade inflation is to change the way the grade point average is calculated because if not the more challenging courses wouldn’t get the credit that they fully need to value then to those other courses that are less challenging. He further states that if that doesn’t happen diplomas will become worthless in the future for all. He supports the argument by saying students should be given a grade that they earned and the amount of effort they put into it getting that particular grade that they received, not just getting an A that they wouldn’t benefit or learn from. Brent staples show evidence that students are demanding and getting what they think of as their money’s worth. However, he’s angry at the fact parents and students may find it rewarding to receive an easy A without doing anything which isn't the proper way to receive an education because you basically don’t learn anything. If professors keep making it easy for students to receive an easy A, education wouldn’t matter at all, and diplomas would become much weaker and valueless as the years go by. However, I disagree with why colleges shower their students with A’s because in my college it isn’t easy to get an A, you actually have to work very hard and show lots of effort to receive an…

    • 1503 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    We live in a society that uses grades as a reflection of learning. Grades are supposed to show how well you know a subject, but is that what they really show? In our society it has become more about getting the grade than actually learning the subject. What impact do grades even have on learning? Jerry Farber, a professor at the University of California wrote an article, titled “A Young Person’s Guide,” that discussed grades and the impact, or lack thereof, they have on learning. Farber is correct in saying that our school grading systems are terrible because grades are not an accurate representation of someone's knowledge.…

    • 1006 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    One positive to Grade Inflation is the fact that students are less stressed over grades and school over all, besides the more money the school gets as a result of higher letter grade output. Although students are less stressed, the do however become lazier which in the end results in more stupid people. Some students might take advantage of this and take more classes or do positive and valuable things outside of school. This would not be a problem if students are responsible for their education, and see that grades are not the main reason why students go to school. Students go to schools to learn and understand what they learn. Teachers in grade school should teach students to focus on the material instead of the grades. The grades should only be a representation of what the students knows and what the students is capable of understands, not how well they can hold their bladder or the amount of printer paper they can take to school.…

    • 873 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Annotation

    • 1248 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Goodman’s other proposal is that the elite universities should “abolish grading, and use testing only and entirely for pedagogic purposes as teachers see fit” (Goodman). He finds that grades are…

    • 1248 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the article, “Students Expectations Seen as Causing Grade Disputes,” Max Roosevelt uses six separate interviews to illustrate the fact that students need to go above and beyond what is considered “average” to receive an A. Students have the belief that if they do what they are supposed to and meet the standard requirements they should get an A, when in truth that is just simply what you are supposed to be doing in the first place. To receive outstanding academic achievement, students go to school not just to learn, but to give opinionated feed back, be interactive, and put high amounts of time and dedication into their studies. Roosevelt proclaims that a sense of entitlement to A’s and B’s may come from their prior experience from kindergarten to twelfth grade, a school system where “doing the work” implies high grades. Sarah Kinn, a junior English major at University of Vermont agrees with the majority of students, claiming “[Students] feel that if [they] do all of the readings and attend class regularly that [they] should be able to achieve a grade that of at least a B.” Students think that if they work hard, they deserve a high grade. In contrast, professor Marshall Grossman does not give an A for meeting the minimal requirements; he gives a standard C. Professor Greenberger assumes that giving an easy A can lead to a heightened sense of entitlement, which is be directly related to the increase of achievement anxiety. The fear of failure, pressure, and competition that one faces could play an effective role towards their belief of deserving good grades. Another example would be how Dean Hogge puts an emphasis on the locus of control. There needs to be a desire to earn an A rather than just easily receiving an A. The student’s dilemma is that they tend to put the responsibility on someone else if they receive a low grade, which leads to irresponsibility and does not prepare you for the real world. Lastly, professors at Wisconsin emphasize the true purpose of…

    • 404 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    As the years go by, the education being offered in the United States keeps changing. More and more students are receiving A's than students from the past ever did. In the essay, "Doesn't Anybody Get a C anymore", Phil Primack, a journalist, editor and policy analyst states that professors are having to choose between going along with the grade inflation or being part of the change to stop it. The problem has created different issues for college students. In the essay, "Grade Inflation Gone Wild", Stuart Rojstaczer, a former professor of geophysics with a PhD in applied earth sciences, elaborates on the issues colleges are having and how it has affected the studying hours and effort students give. Students have come to expect high grades for…

    • 171 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Grade inflation has and continues to effect the nation. Year after year we see many students graduating with high grades but few with average grades. Our group of high achieving students has suddenly disappeared. In this day and age the key to success is a proper education. At least that is what we have been taught since we started first grade. Why is there a dramatic change in our country's average GPA? Making students believe that they have earned an A when in fact they deserved a +C doesn't help them. It only makes it worst. Students are loosing educational value due to grade inflation, and we can no longer differentiate the "great" from the "average".…

    • 979 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays