Preview

Representativeness vs. efficiency

Satisfactory Essays
Open Document
Open Document
371 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Representativeness vs. efficiency
Germany has a better representative system

The US has our bullshit two party system

In Germany, since the chancellor is chosen from the majority party in government, the chancellor directs policy and knows she has the support of the bundesrat

In the United States system allows for the legislature to

In Germany the chancellor is an extension of the legislature whereas in the united states the president and legislature may be separate as voters vote for both in different elections. The system in the united states that purposefully gave both congress and the executive a lot of power in order to check each other

The system in the united states wanted the legislature to be the most powerful/ important branch, demonstrated by how much more the legislature is talked about in the constitution than the executive branch which is mentioned last. As the president has taken more powers over the years, this had lead to the potential for a increasingly combative relationship between the two. Also, minority parties in congress carry a lot of power to block legislation and even shut down the government as a whole through blocking budget legislation. Now, Congress has passed the fewest laws of any congress in the last XXXXXXX amount of years.

While the German government has a proportional representation, their minority parties have less power than the minority party in the United States to influence decision making. Also, the minority party in the united states has the power to shut down the government as we have just seen. This power was given to the minority party in order to ensure the majority in the united states not be a brute jamming through laws with a 51% majority. However, based on the absolute ineffectiveness of the united states congress the minority party has too much power. I

Efficienty- thnk about when country had an emergency and think about how that country was able to solve the problem and then compare them to a country that

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Checks And Balances Essay

    • 623 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Our checks and balances system is an endless circle of power. Delegates at the constitutional convention did not want any one man or group of men to have all the power over the United States of America. They were afraid that if they gave too much power to one person or a group of people the United States would end up in a dictatorship. In order to avoid such problem they divided the government into three branches: executive branch, legislative branch and judicial branch.…

    • 623 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Apush Chapter 6 Summary

    • 1528 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Chapter 12: The Presidency I. Presidents and prime ministers A. Characteristics of parliaments 1. Parliamentary system twice as common 2. Chief executive chosen by legislature 3. Cabinet ministers chosen from among members of parliament 4. Prime minister remains in power as long as his or her party or coalition maintains a majority in the legislature B. Differences 5. Presidents are often outsiders; prime ministers are always insiders, chosen by party members in parliament 6. Presidents choose their cabinet from outside Congress; prime ministers choose members of parliament 7. Presidents have no guaranteed majority in the legislature; prime ministers…

    • 1528 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In the executive Power of the United States we have one leader, or head of state, which is a president. The president enforces laws that are passed by congress. In Rome however, there are consuls who handle public affairs and lead armies. Magistrates are under consuls and are subject to them. They have limited terms, summoned assemblies, introduced measures and popular decrees. The executive branch differs in both countries because in the United States the Vice President is the president of senate, Veto power and may force adjournment, whereas in Rome they introduce ambassadors into their senate.…

    • 503 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Canada and Germany are countries that have different political ideologies also they have some parts of government bear similarities.Although they are two different country, there are have three clear difference between two government systems they use.First, Canada has a three parts of parliament,with House of Common, Senate and Government Governor. In contrast, Germany only have two parts of parliament,with a Bundestag and Bundersrat.Secondly, Canada is president have power, but in Germany is Chancellor.Finally, compare advantage and disadvantage of two government system, Germany’s goverment system is more…

    • 87 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The US federal legislature is bicameral, therefore it consists of the Senate and the House of Representatives, and in theory they should both be of equal power. However, in reality it is the Senate which is considered to hold the most power, although there are arguments to in favour of them having equal rights. In order to reach a balanced judgement I will consider both sides of the argument, beginning with the claim that the Senate is more powerful than the House of Representatives.…

    • 767 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Divided We Govern was written by David R. Mayhew addresses the American government and the topic of united and divided party control. Throughout the essay, the author tried to talk about unified and divided control of the government from both views with five questions. The first view is that a united government allows the decisions of the country to be more effective in enacting laws, being held accountable, good government administration, better foreign policy decisions, and more benefits for the “non-rich” citizens of the United States (188). As Randall B. Ripley said, “To have a productive majority in the American system of government the President and a majority of both houses must be from the same party” (181). The second view is that a divided party control is just as effective as a unified party control of the government. Analysts John E. Chubb and Paul E. Peterson said, “When governments of quite different political combinations all fail to perform effectively, it is worth considering whether the problem is the government itself and not the people or parties that run it”…

    • 580 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Imperial Germany was replaced by the Weimar Republic on the 9th of November 1918 opening the door for the democracy which subsequently lead to political instability and a contrastingly new liberal society. This new republic adopted the Weimar constitution which created the first parliamentary democracy in Germany. The change in society from a previously autocratic society is highlighted by a passage in the Constitution saying “The German Commonwealth is a Republic. Political authority is derived from the People”. Electors were now all men and women above the age of 20 compared to before where it was men only above the age of 25. It also guaranteed personal freedoms such as religious freedom and freedom of speech. This new highly liberal and democratic society highlighted a change in society from the previous autocratic one controlled by the Kaiser. However the Weimar constitution had flaws in it which were used ultimately in its fall such as Article 48 and proportional representation in the Reichstag. Historian Eric Weitz said “The flaws…were to do [more] with…the fact that German society was so fragmented” highlighting that although there were flaws, they could have worked under a society more committed to democratic…

    • 1649 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Chapters 10 through 12 in Political Polarization in American Politics explain what causes polarization and who is involved. This reading supports the ideas from chapter four which says that politics has become polarized on more issues than before due to conflict extension. Both Congress and the voters are deeply polarized, driven by two major factors, coming from a change in government and social interactions as well as a “long-term realignment”. Therefore, polarization comes from previous political beliefs and alignments, splitting Republican and Democratic opinions on how much government interaction should be present on policies such as welfare, tax cuts, and Obamacare. Increased competition leads to higher stakes in every political dispute,…

    • 379 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    For example the legislative wants to pass a law; they have to approve it with the executive branch before they can do anything. Also each of the three groups has a special job and when they want to do something they have to check it with someone higher up, so they don't make bad decisions that will start an argument or something of that sort. Although I can see how people would think one group has more power than the other or more important tasks than the other. But if we didn’t have this system then the whole government would fall apart. In other words someone might mess up and start something they didn’t want to start in the first…

    • 497 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Federalist 51

    • 378 Words
    • 2 Pages

    People have selfish motives, each branch wants to have power and if one has more power than another they will have less…

    • 378 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    ways when comparisons are drawn from two similarly strong western liberal democratic systems. They both enjoy the same fundamental principles of liberal democracy, with those living under this system enjoying the same rights and freedoms with comparable economic conditions. The real difference between these two systems lies in the division of power (). Parliamentarism has been defined as having the parliament as the only democratically legitimate institution is parliament, whereby the government’s authority is completely dependent upon parliamentary confidence. (). While argues that there are three conditions necessary to declare a system parliamentary: All major government decisions must be taken by people chosen in elections conducted along party lines. Policy must be decided within governing party (parties if coalition). The highest officials (ministers) must be selected within their parties and be responsible to the people through their parties. On the other hand, in presidential systems according to , an executive with considerable constitutional powers - generally including full control of the composition of the cabinet and administration - is directly for a fixed term. The president is also the symbolic Head of State.…

    • 928 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    We believe that the legislature have the most power in our society. Legislature is a branch of the government who are also often known as the legislative branch and the congress. The legislatures are most commonly known to be able to create laws. Laws are defined as a system of rules that regulate actions. The legislature has control over what the citizens can or cannot do. Some might say that the president also has control over the laws created because of the fact that in order for a law to pass, the president must write his signature of approval. This is true, however in reality; the president cannot stop a law from being created by the legislature. Why, because although the president can veto the legislature’s decision, the legislature can also return the favour and veto his decision. For example, if the legislature decided that marijuana should be legalized and the president refuses to sign his or her approval, the legislature can veto that decision and the law will pass. Countries are controlled by laws, not the president. The legislative is also the branch in the government that declares war. They have the sole power to decide whether war will happen or not. Not only does that, but the congress also regulate our military system. They have power over weapons that can destroy the world. Another reason why the legislature has the most power in our society is because they regulate and control money. They control the international commerce. They control the taxes. They can make the taxes skyrocket if they pass the bill. They can borrow money at their will. They have economic power. The legislation is made up from two very important parts in our government: the House of Commons and the Senate. The Senate examines the bills, and decide whether or not they will become laws. They can also make their own bills. No bill can become a law without the Senate approving it. Together with the House of Commons and also the queen, they become the Parliament of Canada. The…

    • 408 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    6 Basic Principles

    • 480 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The American government is separated into three branches: executive, judicial, and legislative. This is what creates the separation of powers because each of them is equally divided with power. However none of them have absolute power or complete authority over each other because they are all tied together through checks and balances. This means each branch is subject to restraints by the others, so one branch will always be able to check the actions of the other two. This ensures that no branch of government gains absolute power over the other two.…

    • 480 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Overall, what I learned was that throughout history, whether it is American or history within other countries, the game never changes. We repeat incidents in history and though we might expect the outcome to differ, it rarely does. “The names of the players change but the game does not.” There are trends in history and almost every incident we face can be referred to similar happenings of the past. But the most predominant and reoccurring theme throughout the centuries, and possibly back to the beginning of human civilization and governing, is the role of federal government in the people’s lives. From Ancient Civilization, to Tories versus the Whigs, all the way up to controversy between republicans and democrats the same question has been asked. Do you want a big, intrusive government that decides what is best for you or a smaller government whose primary purpose is to protect you and provide a bit of order and structure so that we are not running about doing anything we please? It is important to recognize this theme. For the role of federal government will always impact our lives directly and decide the amount of freedom allowed to both the people and the government.…

    • 1974 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The United States of America is known as a land of equals and a land “of the free.” From separation of powers to check and balances, the Founding Fathers displayed a desire for equilibrium, rather than for usurpation. Although the three branches of government display equality, the development of the legislative branch over time- i.e. the shift of delegation powers- has shown that Congress holds the most power making final decisions through impeachment, oversights, and accepting or denying presidential requests- i.e. treaties and the appointment of judges.…

    • 1206 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays