3/19/13
Pro’s and Con’s of The Prohibition
In the 1840’s America started to see the want, and the need for the removal of alcohol, in 1919 the 18th amendment was created. This amendment was called prohibition, the legal act of prohibiting the manufacture, transportation and sale of alcohol and alcoholic beverages. Life at home and at work improved as abuse was greatly lessened, and money was spent on necessities instead of boos. However, Prohibition did not go as planned, illegal activities were still increasing and bootlegging was at its all time high. Sadly, completely illegalizing the production and consumption of alcohol was a great plan that ended up being a great failure.
The prohibition act had many positives. The amendment helped assess implications in the home. “In general, informal social controls in the home and community helped maintain the expectation that the abuse of alcohol was unacceptable.” (***) Here for instance when the law was set forward banning alcohol men at home were not able to drink, thus they stopped beating their family and spending all the money. Francis Willard president of the WCTU stated, “It was believed that if it could ‘get to the children’ it could create a ‘dry’ sentiment leading to prohibition.” (****) If she could stop abuse in the household she would be able to assist the children, bring them to school, have them raised in a proper home. Something all WCTU advocated wanted.
Henry Ford however created a genius idea. He decided to pay his workers who didn’t drink more. And fire the ones who drank. “When Henry Ford first offered his workers the astounding sum of five dollars a day to work on his Model T Ford assembly line he shocked the business world with his generosity.” (*****) Though he wasn’t about to be outsmarted by his employees. Ford wanted to create a production line fast, and efficient. Something an alcoholic in his eyes could not help him accomplish. “Ford went so far as to hire detectives to spy on workers at home to make sure they were not drinking.” (******)
Christian women believed that the removal of alcohol was key to the correction of the damaged society. They however were wrong. As alcohol left and expectations arrived breaking the law was just on the “to-do list”. “Drinking was such a routine part of life for so many Americans that bootlegging quickly became a big business ” (OOM Pg. 692). With alcohol illegal in America men began to import it illegally from both Canada and Mexico. The want for change and good already is being flushed down as law breaking takes a stand. This however was not the only scandalous deed by Americans. Not only were we illegally importing alcohol but we were also selling it. “Nearly every town had at least one ‘speakeasy’, where people could drink and enjoy music and other entertainment.” (OOM Pg. 692). Within months loop-holes are already created and we are jumping through them like fleas. No place to drink? Illegally create a secret bar. Problem solved. Not.
Following right behind the alcohol came the anger. Crime rates skyrocketed as organized crime found its new latch. “Rather than reducing crime, Prohibition had transformed the cities into battlegrounds between opposing bootlegging gangs.” (*) Now not only are men bootlegging, but they are now battling against each other to reap the benefits. One of the most well know conflicts is probably the Saint Valentine's Day Massacre, “the 1929 murder of seven mob associates as part of a prohibition era conflict between two powerful criminal gangs in Chicago: the South Side Italian gang led by Al Capone and the North Side Irish gang led by Bugs Moran.” (**) Due to gang violence seven men were murdered. Today that would undoubtedly be on the evening news, but back then it was just another day.
The creation of the 18th amendment brought forth both change and prosper to the United States but ultimately failed. America wasn’t about to have her toes trampled on. And though there were many cons there were also a large amount of pros, which were the essential building blocks. However we now see how this, in the beginning was destined to fail. You cannot build on something unless you have a sturdy foundation something Prohibition did not have. America still has those problems today as we build with no foresight into the future. And the future is what counts.
THIS ESSAY ISN’T VERY GOOD, I’M SORRY I JUST DIDN’T REALLY UNDERSTAND THE FORMAT OR HOW YOU WANTED US TO ARRANGE THINGS. SORRY AGAIN.
* "Prohibition in the United States." Wikipedia. Wikimedia Foundation, 21 Mar. 2013. Web. 22 Mar. 2013.
** "Saint Valentine's Day Massacre." Wikipedia. Wikimedia Foundation, 19 Mar. 2013. Web. 22 Mar. 2013.
*** "Prohibition in the United States." Wikipedia. Wikimedia Foundation, 21 Mar. 2013. Web. 22 Mar. 2013.
**** "Study & Research Roaring 20s." BookRags. BookRags, n.d. Web. 22 Mar. 2013.
***** "Study & Research Roaring 20s." BookRags. BookRags, n.d. Web. 22 Mar. 2013.
****** "Study & Research Roaring 20s." BookRags. BookRags, n.d. Web. 22 Mar. 2013.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
On the midnight of January 26,1920, America went officially dry. The habit of most Americans was prohibited when the 18th Amendment was passed. The manufacture, sale, or transportation of intoxicating liquors within the United States was forbidden. Prohibition was seen as a solution for one of the most serious problems in America which is caused by drinking, but then why did America change its mind? It happened for three major reasons: crime, enforcement and disrespect of law, and economic issues.…
- 337 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
The 18th amendment, “Section 1, After one year from the ratification of this article the manufacture, sale, or transportation of intoxicating liquors within, the importation thereof into, or the exportation thereof from the United States and all territory subject to the jurisdiction thereof for beverage purposes is hereby prohibited. Section 2, The Congress and the several States shall have concurrent power to enforce this article by appropriate legislation. Section 3, This article shall be inoperative unless it shall have been ratified as an amendment to the Constitution by the legislatures of the several States, as provided in the Constitution, within seven years from the date of the submission hereof to the States by the Congress. (The Charters of Freedom n.d.)” This amendment’s ratification was the realization of all the people in the United States that the temperance movement finally became reality, but long over a century before the ratification of the 18th Amendment the temperance movement was making its way into the United States. When examining the Prohibition its impact is palpable, but it was more than just a trial and error issue. The prohibition was about social reformation that took place long before the initial enactment of the 18th amendment. The era known as the temperance movement brought renovation on many aspects of the United States; politics, religion, government roles and the role of the people. The Temperance Movement is a period in time which we can credit this absolute change of American aspects to the array of prohibition supporting parties and Congressional debate.…
- 5679 Words
- 23 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Alcohol was thought to be the source of several of the nation’s problems. Issues like domestic violence, unemployment and poverty. The Women’s Christian Temperance Union first introduced the idea of prohibition, the illegalization of the buying, selling or consumption of alcohol. Prohibition was made official in 1919 as Nebraska became the 36th state to ratify the proposal. Prohibition took effect one year later in 1920. In the beginning, prohibition had an overwhelming amount of popularity from most of the country however Americans quickly changed their mind. Prohibition ended in 1933 with the 21st amendment to the Constitution. The increase in crime across the nation, several negative financial aspects of prohibition, and the eventual increase in corruption and loss of national restriction were all factors in the nation’s sudden change of heart.…
- 591 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Prohibition was supposedly crafted regarding the ethical issues of consuming alcohol. Some had fear of its effects on social and physical standpoints (Currie 8). This awareness of negative effects had not been recently conjured. In fact, the issues concerning the drink date all the way back to when the United States had sprung into the world. The people…
- 1034 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Banning alcohol dug Americans into a really deep hole that was hard to escape. Prohibition, also known as the eighteenth amendment, was the act of banning alcohol in America. Alcohol created many problems, so people who were supporters of the banning of it, “Prohibitionists” thought that just getting rid of it completely would solve every problem. This idea that getting rid of something entirely just because it causes problems was not well thought through. Women and people involved in religion were usually supporters of Prohibition. Women believed it caused problems in the home and in their marriages, and people involved in the church and religion believed alcohol consumption had too many negative effects.…
- 944 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Prohibition in the 1920’s played a huge role by increasing criminal activity. In January of 1920 the American government banned sale and supply of alcohol, which was known as the Eighteenth amendment. The government thought this would reduce crime and violence…
- 1754 Words
- 8 Pages
Better Essays -
The Eighteenth Amendment to the Constitution was ratified in January 1919 and executed in January 1920. It banned the “manufacture, sale, or transportation of intoxicating liquors”. This amendment was the finishing touch of decades of realization and fulfillment by organizations such as the Woman’s Christian Temperance Union and the Anti-Saloon League, and was also built upon the dry laws of eighteen states. The Prohibition Amendment had heavy consequences. It categorized the brewing and distilling of alcohol as illegal. It then went on and expanded state and federal governments, inspired new forms of sociability between men and women, and suppressed elements of immigrant and working-class culture. During the Prohibition era’s initial years, amendment supporters were delighted by a drop in arrests for drunkenness,…
- 977 Words
- 4 Pages
Better Essays -
In 1919, the Volstead Act outlawed alcoholic beverages with an alcoholic content over 0.5 percent. This topic is debated in the book, Taking Sides; there are two opposing sides to the question, “was prohibition a failure?” David E. Kyvig argues that the Volstead act did not specifically prohibit the use or consumption of alcohol beverages and that liquor was still being provided by gangland bootleggers to provide alcohol to the demands of the consumers. Regardless of the efforts to enforce the law the federal government failed to create an acceptable institutional network that insured the obedience of the people. Even though the consumption of alcohol did drop significantly during the 1920s, the legislation failed to eliminate drinking. On the other hand, J. C. Burnham argues that the enforcement of the prohibition laws were effective in certain areas. The enactment of the prohibition laws led to several positive social significances. For example, during the 1920s, there were fewer people arrested for public drunkenness and fewer people being treated for alcohol related diseases. He concludes that the prohibition was more of a success than a failure. Prohibition led to the first and the only time an Amendment of United States Constitution was repealed more than once. Personally, I think that the Volstead Act of 1919 was a failure and the prohibition laws gave rise to speakeasies and organized crime.…
- 1263 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays -
Though, one could argue the abundance of failure that came out of the prohibition, it also provided success for Americans in the long run. It was almost could be seen as an American chance to hit the reset button. Giving us the opportunity to take a step back and see the negative side effects we were causing to ourselves. During the Prohibition the consumption of alcohol never stopped, it did decrease significantly. This pattern continued decades after the Prohibition ended. The Prohibition is a piece of history we could learn from: yes; it was a failure, yes; it did increase crime, and yes, those who were claiming to be helping American society threw the idea of Prohibition, were usually doing so to push their own political agenda, it did,…
- 161 Words
- 1 Page
Good Essays -
The prohibition movement in the United States was very successful during the era of progressive reform, from 1900 to 1919. This is because of the social composition of the prohibitionists, their motives, strategy, and pressure-group tactics, and the relationship of prohibitionism to progressive reform. The prohibitionists attacked saloons with a passion, they appealed to women's rights, and they tried every mean possible to keep their areas dry.'…
- 805 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
As many of you may know for a brief time in the 1920’s alcohol was banned. The banning of alcohol is known as prohibition. “The Prohibition Era”, as we refer to it today, was brought upon the society of the 1920’s for a few reasons; many people were against the use of alcohol and suggested it was the drink of the devil and congress took a strong moral stance against alcohol use as well.…
- 288 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Starting in the early 1800’s, the temperance movement sought to moderate or outright prohibit the consumption of alcohol. Eventually, in January 1919, the United States ratified the 18th Amendment to the Constitution banning the sale, manufacture, and distribution of alcohol in the entire country. It’s purpose was to reduce crime and corruption, to minimize the tax burden, and to promote a healthier living in America. In contrast to its goal, it evidently heightened the contrary desired outcome. Although against popular belief, prohibition wasn’t what started mob crime, it only fueled it. Poverty arose after a downturn in the economy and later, once a sudden rise in prosperity occurred, the Great Depression resulted. People started to either…
- 168 Words
- 1 Page
Good Essays -
Prohibition was the eighteenth amendment. It prohibited the production and consumption of alcoholic beverages. People would have never thought of "excoriating" alcohol until the 19th century (Tyrrell 16). During this time widespread crime and dismay arose. Some beneficial things did come out of this period of chaos such as women were able to prove themselves as people their temperance movements. During this time many things happened that led to Prohibition's strongest point and to its fall. Prohibition proved to be a failure from the start,. Prohibition was scarcely adhered to and also widely defied but out of this women had a chance to voice their opinions and prove themselves.…
- 766 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
The Prohibition has taught many lessons that still remain to this day. They are used not only on the war on drugs but also with the efforts to reduce the access to tobacco and alcohol and to the issues on bans and restrictions on insider trades, gambling, and abortion. These lessons are important to help us learn from our mistakes and to help us solve the problems we had trouble with back then.…
- 594 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Prohibition. It began in 1918 partly due to World War I and was repealed by most provinces by the early 1920’s, during those few years it caused a number of problems here in Canada but especially in the United States. Prohibition is the legal prevention of the manufacture, sale and transportation of alcoholic beverages. In simpler words, it prohibited people from taking part in the alcoholic beverage business, hence the name, prohibition.…
- 592 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays