Privatization: Too Much Risk for Senior Citizens?

Continues for 2 more pages »
Read full document

Privatization: Too Much Risk for Senior Citizens?

By | December 2005
Page 1 of 3
Privatization: Too Much Risk For Senior Citizens?

Imagine a world where the elderly are impoverished, living on the streets, homeless, starving and sick. This is the future of America's elderly if Social Security remains on its current track. There is no doubt that reform is needed, but is privatization the right answer? In the following pages, I will attempt to summarize the pros and cons of Social Security privatization, as well as explain which view really makes sense for our elderly. In Michael Tanner's essay Saving Social Security is Not Enough, he argues in favor of private accounts mostly on the basis of fairness and equality to those receiving the benefits. According to Tanner, Social Security is failing, and will continue to fail, as an anti-poverty and retirement program unless a change can be made yielding the best possible return on a senior's investment. He argues that there is strong evidence that, "Social Security discourages savings" (p. 163), therefore is failing to prevent poverty. To Tanner, the program is also failing as a retirement program because without it, the elderly would be more willing to save and plan for their future. The most logical solution, as stated in the essay, is a new system that is intergenerational. According to the Tanner, although every senior is eligible for the program at the same time, there is a large difference in the levels of benefits one might receive. Seniors who live longer lives will ultimately reap more benefits than that of a senior who dies early after entering into the program, although both had been paying for the program from birth. Thus, the current system is unfair. A new program, based on private accounts, is the only logical step to ensure fairness among those who are retired. If Social Security was privatized, according to Tanner, not only would it yield the highest possible return on an individual's investment, but also the private account will be inheritable by one's kin upon death....

Rate this document

What do you think about the quality of this document?

Share this document

Let your classmates know about this document and more at