A Post-Modern Analysis of Women in the New East
Good intentions do not beget positive results. Indeed what may seem to be good from one perspective may be seen as the complete opposite from another. Case in point: Western Feminism. To prove my point I will analyze the work of Ruth Frances Woodsmall, Women and the New East, written in 1960 as a feminist work, from a post-modern feminist perspective, and using works from Coco Fusco (English Broken Here) and Trinh Minh-ha (Women Native Other).
One of the first problems encountered in Woodsmall's work is in the delineation of her methodology. She writes that she began her study for each country with,
" the selection of a number of women leaders as advisers on the study as a whole and on specific phases The individual advisers were very helpful in making contacts, in giving advice about special interviews, suggesting institutions and projects and interpreting the general situation." (viii)
These women that she chose as her starting point from were most likely how many of the other informants and sources of information were found and therefore must have had a serious affect on the results of her research. These women are leaders, and therefore not accurate representations of the average women of Turkey. Indeed in the biographical appendix Woodsmall lists some of these leaders and not only do they all have "careers", but they are all centered in military or scientific areas not exactly a cross section of any society. This means much of this work was funneled through one class, and Fusco in her work exemplifies how class can make a difference in cultural views.
"The reactions of Latin Americans differed according to class. Many upper class Latin American tourists voiced disgust that their part of the world should be represented in such a debased manner. Many other Latin Americans and Native Americans immediately recognized the symbolic significance of the piece, expressing solidarity with us " (56)
This means... [continues]
Good intentions do not beget positive results. Indeed what may seem to be good from one perspective may be seen as the complete opposite from another. Case in point: Western Feminism. To prove my point I will analyze the work of Ruth Frances Woodsmall, Women and the New East, written in 1960 as a feminist work, from a post-modern feminist perspective, and using works from Coco Fusco (English Broken Here) and Trinh Minh-ha (Women Native Other).
One of the first problems encountered in Woodsmall's work is in the delineation of her methodology. She writes that she began her study for each country with,
" the selection of a number of women leaders as advisers on the study as a whole and on specific phases The individual advisers were very helpful in making contacts, in giving advice about special interviews, suggesting institutions and projects and interpreting the general situation." (viii)
These women that she chose as her starting point from were most likely how many of the other informants and sources of information were found and therefore must have had a serious affect on the results of her research. These women are leaders, and therefore not accurate representations of the average women of Turkey. Indeed in the biographical appendix Woodsmall lists some of these leaders and not only do they all have "careers", but they are all centered in military or scientific areas not exactly a cross section of any society. This means much of this work was funneled through one class, and Fusco in her work exemplifies how class can make a difference in cultural views.
"The reactions of Latin Americans differed according to class. Many upper class Latin American tourists voiced disgust that their part of the world should be represented in such a debased manner. Many other Latin Americans and Native Americans immediately recognized the symbolic significance of the piece, expressing solidarity with us " (56)
This means... [continues]
Cite This Essay
- APA
-
(2002, 04). A Post-Modern Analysis of "Women in the New East". StudyMode.com. Retrieved 04, 2002, from http://www.studymode.com/essays/Post-Modern-Analysis-Women-New-East-40899.html
- MLA
-
"A Post-Modern Analysis of "Women in the New East"" StudyMode.com. 04 2002. 04 2002 <http://www.studymode.com/essays/Post-Modern-Analysis-Women-New-East-40899.html>.
- CHICAGO
-
"A Post-Modern Analysis of "Women in the New East"." StudyMode.com. 04, 2002. Accessed 04, 2002. http://www.studymode.com/essays/Post-Modern-Analysis-Women-New-East-40899.html.
