Guardians are put into place to defend morality and rule society because they know the truth and posses the knowledge and wisdom of true forms. In order for there to be a just state, there must be a balance between the different types of people, namely; reason dominated, spirit dominated and appetite dominated people. This balance is similar to that of the need for balance in a just individual between the tripartheid soul. Those dominant in reason become philosophers, those in spirit become soldiers and those in appetite become commoners. Balance in these traits is necessary in order to achieve a just state.
The state must be governed by reason (philosophers) and they should have complete control over the states affairs because to much liberty in appetitive people allows for self corruption without reason. From the ages 8-18 the chosen children for guardian education undergo general primary education, followed by two years of physical training. Ten years of training in mathematics then follows and if successfully completed there is 5 years dialectic training. After all of this has been completed the philosopher will serve 15 years apprentice in managing polis leaving the end product at age 55 the best at everything. This shows that Plato also does not believe that young people are capable of ruling.
Fiction is prohibited (poetry and lit) to aid in protection from untruth at early age until they are able to evaluate the truth for themselves. There is also a suggestion of a transcendent God and no possible forms of corruption should be overlooked. A noble lie is a myth or untruth told by an elite to maintain social harmony, it benefits all parties but is different from a white lie in the sense that it will cause discord if uncovered.
In Plato’s theory of the guardian class the state may end up serving the guardians and education may become the primary goal, instead of the well being of the population. The notion that all private interests be abolished within the guardian class would also leave guardians with little drive to excel.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Plato believed that this was the way to conduct the ideal form of political justice. Everyone must do what best suites their nature and not pry into any business other than that which is naturally suited to them. According to Plato, his society was separated into three roles: Producers, Rulers and Guardians. Producers produce the goods (carpenters build, artists paint, doctors heal, etc), philosophers rule, and Guardians fight and protect. Specialization guarantees that each class remains in fixed relations of power. Warriors abide by the commands of the rulers, producers to not interfere with political affairs, each person worries only about their own business to which they are suited, participating in other aspects only as far as obeying the rules that are created by the rulers,…
- 677 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Plato was an interesting individual, and has always been one of my favorite Philosophers. I personally like most of his political ideals, and find them almost in alignment with my own. In particular I like his reasoning when it comes to the citizens that make up the city-state, along with the leadership. So throughout this essay I plan on drawing from the Republic to talk more about this Philosopher’s ideas.…
- 694 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Plato believes that education is the surest way to an ideal society. In today’s society education is atopic brought up in debates quite frequently because it is important that the youth are educated so they can fill in jobs and run the country when they are older. This does not mean everyone gets an education, for there are many countries where education can not be afforded or is not the best. Yet in today’s school system students are not treated for their full potential.…
- 664 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
In his book “the Republic”, Plato tried to build up an ideal society. He divided the ideal society into three classes: rulers, guardians, and workers. As long as each class of people lived harmonious and did their responsibilities, the society would become stable and prosperous. How did make people live with harmony? Obviously, the core issue of “the republic” is justice. Justice is a proper, harmonious relationship among the people in the three classes. Plato suggested that three virtues of individual which were wisdom, courage, and moderation would make individual person just. Also, in order to get the justice, Plato used the “Gold lie” to placate unhappiness with one’s place in life.…
- 683 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
In the Republic Plato endeavours to answer complex questions about justice by introducing a unique account of what justice actually is, and how morally sensitive people are educated and informed about the real nature of justice and morality [3]. Our understanding of justice is more profound if we insist that what really matters is not merely the observance of external demands — normative and conventional moral rules — but the character of the truly just person [4]. Justice and goodness, based upon judgement as the virtue of a decent life, are seen as congruent in the context of a well ordered society.…
- 3158 Words
- 13 Pages
Powerful Essays -
By appeal to part V of Plato’s the republic there are a few positions that he has based on the location of the qualities of wisdom, courage, discipline and justice in the state. The first of these qualities, wisdom is located within the guardians and it’s the first thing Plato sees in the city. First off, he finds the city to be wise because of its respectable judgment which is looked upon as some category of knowledge called guardianship and only the guardians possess this kind of knowledge. Furthermore, Plato goes on to explain that a whole city established would be wise because of the least numerous class, which would be seen as the governing or ruling class, and their virtue. Since they are the ruling class their personal virtues are reflected through the city which in turn makes the city wise (428b). The second quality, courage, is located in the auxiliary class of the city. Plato believes that if you are to determine whether a city has courage, the best part to look for it would be in the soldiers. He also believes that courage is a type of preservation for the law. No matter the pain, pleasure, desire or fear the guardians will never abandon the belief that has been inculcated by the law (429b). The third quality of moderation is located all throughout the city. He…
- 1251 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
Main views about society Plato wrote in his book called the Republic. The Republic was written around 380 (BC). In this book Plato tries to define justice, right order and character of the just city and the just man. In the Republic different philosophers like Socrates try to argue, what is the meaning of justice. They also discuss if a just man is happier than an unjust man, if they are ruled by just philosopher kings. (Brickhouse, Thomas & Smith, Nicholas, 2010)…
- 1509 Words
- 7 Pages
Good Essays -
The the men come up with the most important question who will make the laws and rule the city. Socrates says the guardians will rule. With this ruling they come up with many different attributes that the guardians must…
- 603 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Plato's most famous work is undoubtedly The Republic it has weathered the test of time to provide us with the most influential philosophical doctrine surviving from the ancient Mediterranean. Over the years Plato has been hailed by some as an advocate of women's rights because of some views he puts forth in The Republic. In Book V of the work Plato has Socrates, acting as his voice, engage in a discussion of the perfect state with Polemarchus, Adeimantus, Glaucon, and Thrasymachus. In the conversation Socrates puts forth the notion that women should be equal to men and that just because a person is of a certain sex it does not mean that they cannot still be beneficial to the operation of the society. This idea will be the focus of this paper, specifically the question of whether or not Plato's utopian society depends on the realization of equality between the sexes. In examining this question it must be kept in mind that notion of equality that is put forth in Book V is not in the modern day sense. Plato is exploring the possibility that women in ancient Greek society remained an untapped resource that was confined mainly to the household and devoid of civic duties.…
- 1232 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Rulers seldom prioritize conditions which benefit those who are subservient to them, as personal advantage is a consistent ambition for those in power. In Plato’s Republic, when conversation leads to the description of an ideal city, Thrasymachus’ belief that rulers rule for their own advantage plays a key role in Socrates’ explanation of how to strategically educate an elite class of guardians whose virtue will be in governance and supervision of society. Education of the mind, body, and soul is what encourages the guardians to be just sovereigns for the ruled. Strict ideals placed on objective censorship of classic literature will guide their intellect, severe training in the arts of gymnastics allows for physical competence, and a lack of monetary influence maintains a just soul; these are all facets to create an ideal ruling class who are compassionate to subjects but ferocious to adversaries (375a). In Childhood, guardians would be bred to rule…
- 1013 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
But being the just man is so much harder then being the unjust man. The most just man has justice in his soul. But you cannot do all the fun and cool things that the unjust man can do. You also have to follow every rule and you cannot break one of them. Adiemantus the brother of Glaucon said, “no one praises justice for its own sake, but only for the rewards it allows you to reap in both life and afterlife.” As you can see Adiemantus and Glaucon both think that justice is only useful for the afterlife. Adiemantus is saying praise justice in itself not for its reputation. Glaucon says praise justice in itself not for its rewards. Justice is like currency and you can buy rewards in the afterlife. This is a plausible argument because why else be just? You could say because of their good soul they can feel good about their actions at the end of the day. Or as Socrates says the soul is a kind of a mental health. Socrates also says that justice is kind of a correct ordering of control amongst parts of the city/soul. That could be true but even with that your not totally confirmed that there is an afterlife. It is actually going for a risk being the just man and not going for a risk if you are going for the unjust…
- 1332 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays -
Studies show that getting students to talk in the first five minutes of class gets them effectively…
- 4301 Words
- 18 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Plato was a totalitarian judging from The Republic. With the definition of totalitarianism in mind, Plato illustrates features of authoritarianism and ideology in his political worldview, which entails a strict division of classes, the dependency of the fate of the state on the ruling class as well as the superiority of the interests of the ruling class over the subservient and inferior classes. Furthermore, the uncompromising rules for breeding and educating this class combined with the strict supervision and collectivisation of the interests of its members create a close enough representation of the totalitarianism depicted in the definition. Firstly, in addressing the issue, which Plato begins with in The Republic of what justice is Plato, asserts that justice is that which is in the interest of the…
- 1486 Words
- 5 Pages
Powerful Essays -
he designates different types of educations for three different levels of society - producers, soldiers, and rulers, and says that each class must be kept strictly distinct. education will begin from early childhood, and each level of education will end in an examination to see if the person is qualified to proceed further in his education. for plato, the ruler is a philsopher who know about Forms rather than their images, and is thus the only one who is qualified to rule. his education and testing would last until he is about 50. the soldiers are both gentle and harsh (like a dog- gentle to friends and harsh to enemies) and respect and uphold the authority of the ruler. they are to be educated in both physical training and culture. also, they are to have all wives and children in common so as they do not exhibit loyalty towards…
- 673 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
“A State is as the men are; they grow out of human characters” (Glaucon, “The Republic”). In Plato’s “The Republic,” Socrates, Glaucon, and Adeimantus discuss five forms of government - aristocracy, timocracy, oligarchy, democracy, and tyranny - and the individuals the five systems create. These forms of government are not solely used to define societies, however. They can be used to characterize anything, such as courses offered at a school. Hercules High School is a good example of this. Courses offered at the high school can be classified as one of Plato’s governments and can create students that influence the political systems of other classes.…
- 696 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays