Mr. Staude
U.S. History
25 April 2013
Truman Doctrine VS. Marshall Plan The years after the war brought times of disagreement and argument. The United States worked at this time to contain and control the spread of communism. During the years of WWII and the Cold War this idea was prominent and an issue America thought must be solved. Their were two strong attempts to fight communism. These attempts were the Truman Doctrine and the Marshall Plan. These ideas go hand in hand making them "two halves of the same walnut." In 1946, Greek communist broke out into war wight the Greek government. On March 12, 1947, Truman gave a speech to congress discussing the events taking place overseas. Truman wanted to aid the Greek government as well as Turkey for they were informed that they would not be receiving Britain's military aid anymore. He was granted $400 million to fight communism in Greece and Turkey. This became known as the Truman Doctrine and was especially influential because it showed the United States would fight the spread of communism worldwide. Before the war, the United States policy was to stay out of foreign affairs. "The Truman Doctrine effectively reoriented U.S. foreign policy, away from its usual stance of withdrawal from regional conflicts not directly involving the United States, to one of possible intervention in far away conflicts." (Office of the Historian). The goal of the Truman Doctrine was to intervene to support any nation that was being taken over by another country. Although the Soviet Union was not directly mentioned by name it was directed towards them saying that the United States were behind any country and support them with military aid so they would not fall into the Soviets way of communism. The Truman Doctrine was a great attempt at stopping the spread of communism. The Marshall Plan together with the Truman Doctrine created an even bigger push in weakening the appeal of communism. The Marshall Plan was the second half of the same walnut with the Truman Doctrine. The Marshall Plan, However took a different approach at containing communism. Postwar Western Europe faced some serious economic and political issues. "Secretary of State George C. Marshall proposed the European Recovery Program, or Marshall Plan, which would give European nations American aid to rebuild their economies" (Appleby, Brinkley, Broussard, McPherson, and Ritchie 768). Because the Truman Doctrine made it clear that the United States were engaging in foreign affairs, the Marshall Plan's main goal was to rebuild the damages from the war in Europe. As a result of the rebuilding, The Marshall Plan weakened the appeal of communism because of the recovery of Western Europe. It also opened up new trade opportunities and market. Not only did both of these plans help contain communism but America. Benefitted especially from the Marshall Plan. "The aid also produced record levels of trade with American firms, fueling a postwar economic boom in the United States" (Containment and the Marshall Plan). America was working to end communism and in return were benefitting from their foreign intervention. The Truman Doctrine and the Marshall Plan both marked a beginning of a new era for the United States. The U.S. has given up on the idea of staying out of foreign issues and have now taken the role as the "worldly police officers". By aiding other countries and working towards peace both of these plans worked together and focused on containing and weakening communism overseas. At the time, both plans were effective but may not be seen as effective today.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
In 1947 the United States and Soviet Union were officially at odds with one another. Both disagreed on ideas on how to handle Europe. This eventually led to a standoff between United States and Soviet Union but it was on Europe’s soil. The Truman Doctrine and The Marshall Plan were used to stop the advancement of Soviet Union into surrounding countries. The U.S. felt that Soviet Union wanted to spread Communism around the world and Soviet Union felt that the United States wanted to spread Democracy in Europe. So to put a stop to it all containment was needed. This consists of using the military and economic persuasion to the surrounding countries and trade partners with Soviet Union.…
- 358 Words
- 1 Page
Good Essays -
The Truman Doctrine announced military aid and an ideological crusade against international communism. The Marshall Plan provided the economic assistance to starving and communist-threatened Europe, which soon joined the United States in the NATO military alliance.…
- 4151 Words
- 119 Pages
Powerful Essays -
The year of 1945 was a time of relief for America and its people. That year was the end of World War II. Germany had lost and the time for rebuilding was near. However, the peace did not last long between the Soviet Union and the United States. A difference in political and economic views caused a rift in the Soviet Union and United States relationship of convenience. The Soviet Union was running on a system of government called communism. Communism's theory of a government run by the economy was the complete opposite of America's dedication to independence. This difference caused great tension between the two nations and became a Cold War. The Soviet Union believed that communism was going to overcome capitalism and that they will win the Cold War. America's retaliation to the Soviet Union's spreading of communism was containment. Containment is the attempt to stop the spread of communism. The Cold War split the world into two large groups, those who were under communist rule and those who were against it. The United States was dedicated in their fight against communism with instances like the Truman Doctrine, which vowed to support anyone who was being threatened by communist rule, and The Marshall Plan, which gave over 10 billion dollars to European countries in the effort to rebuild the damage done during World War II. By 1947, the United States and Soviet Union were constantly on their toes and pushing boundaries to see who would gain the upper hand in the Cold War.…
- 954 Words
- 4 Pages
Better Essays -
Although the foreign policies during this time period contained many similarities, the policies and tactics relating to the fight against communism had changed from the commencement of the war. During Truman’s presidency, tensions between the Soviet Union and the United States as the two world powers intensified through the installment of the Marshall Plan. The Marshall Plan granted financial aid to rebuild Europe and its malnourished people, but withdrew the offer from the USSR (Doc. 1). George F. Kennan proposed the containment policy to halt the spread of communism from the Soviet Union to other nations without advanced military aid and restore the balance of power; however, communism spread to Asian countries in retaliation and the Soviet Union began the nuclear arms race and the space race against the United States, instead of large scale battles. In 1954, Eisenhower cut military spending to focus on other aspects in the nation that required governmental funding, and it remained cut until the Gulf of Tonkin Resolution in 1965, when the American government and President Johnson created the Gulf of Tonkin Resolution during the Vietnam War. The United States neglected to aid nations such as Hungary against the communist threat until the Eisenhower Doctrine was adopted in 1957. John Dulles felt that the containment policy was ‘too soft’ and wanted to liberate those who had been…
- 1160 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
One weapon used by the US was an elaborate financial aid program. The Marshall Plan was a strategy to contain and smother the spread of communism. This decision was made public on June 5, 1947 by Secretary of State Marshall as seen in Document 3. A more specific pan to suppress the communist threat was the Truman Doctrine, a program to aid financially depressed countries in order to maintain their government and not succumb to communism. This included "giving Greece and Turkey $400 million in aid" as displayed in Document…
- 681 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
One way with which the U.S. tried to contain communism was with the use of the atomic bomb. The dropping of the atomic bomb in Hiroshima was a method that was used to bring the war between the Japanese to a quick end with few loss of American lives. Described by Truman as " the greatest thing in history" the bomb had a very devastating effect taking up to 70 000 lives. After that another bomb was dropped in Nagasaki, this was particularly to impress Stalin and scare him if possible. However this was to blow up in Truman's face. Stalin feeling that it was an insult that he was never informed of such a weapon by his allies was not impressed and also became more suspicious of the U.S. And the fact that he was also denied the islands in the far east since he had nothing to do with the defeating of Japan also irritated him more. Truman's attempts did not work instead Stalin sought a production of his very own atomic bomb, and alhough it was initially predicted the Soviet Union would get the bomb within 10 years, mysteriously the bomb was in the hands of the Soviets a lot sooner than that, they had it within 4 years. So Truman had nothing against Stalin now. This was one of the unsuccessful means of containing communism because it rather increased the already existing tensions between both countries during the cold war. And because it was a suspicious thing that the U.S.S.R. got the bomb so soon and the U.S. neglected to…
- 1484 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
At the end of the Second World War two major issues were brought to attention. The first was dealing with the destruction of the global catastrophe. The second issue involved the shape of the new world and what political alliances were to be made. And although the U.S. and Russia were “allies” during the war the second issue was the foremost cause of the contention between the world’s two political/economic systems, Capitalism and Communism. The Cold War was basically an ideological catch-22 in which the U.S. was caught up in, mostly because of the actions taken by the Federal government and the chief executive, Harry S. Truman. Up until Truman’s speech to Congress in 1947, the most powerful influence on American foreign policy had been the Monroe Doctrine, a policy by President Monroe that proposed America ought to keep out of European affairs. The Truman Doctrine completely overturned the Monroe Doctrine. The Soviet Union viewed the actions taken during Truman’s administration as further threats of American imperialism. Truman’s Foreign Policy reflected an entirely interventionist attitude with the implementation of the Truman Doctrine, the crisis in Berlin, and NATO. Therefore the statement is primarily invalid.…
- 857 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
The Marshall Plan extended was a recovery program created by George C. Marshall, the Secretary of State under Truman. The main goal of the Marshall Plan’s main goals were to improve the economic conditions in Western Europe, effectively ending the desire to revolt and convert to Communism, as well as to pry the Eastern bloc out of Soviet control. This plan offered American financial aid to Europe. It was a relief for Europe, as many countries lay in ruins after WWII. Millions of people had been killed or wounded. Various industrial centers were destroyed. In addition, Europe was on…
- 671 Words
- 3 Pages
Better Essays -
The Truman Doctrine of 1947 is believed to be the start of the Cold War. It stated that America would help any non-communist nation to resist communist force. It was simply a promise and was not in any case responsible of dividing Europe into two. Where the Truman Doctrine was the decision, the Marshall Plan was the action which seemed to bring the two nations (USA and Russia) more towards the Cold War than ever. In the summer of 1947 American general named George Marshall decided that America should give out $17 billion for aiding Europe. He reckoned that Europe…
- 629 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
a. President Harry Truman alarmed by British weakness and the possibility of soviet expansion into the eastern Mediterranean, responded with the Truman Doctrine: said that the U. S. would provide money to countries that claimed they were threatened by Communist expansion…
- 2834 Words
- 12 Pages
Better Essays -
The Truman doctrine of 1947 was created to 'save' Greece from communism. The saving was to be done through helping Britain with military and financial aid to fight communism in Greece. But the policy was extended to aid any country under the threat of communism. The Truman doctrine was effective considering that much of the eastern block had already fallen to communism by the time it was implemented. Furthermore it did prevent Greece form falling to…
- 245 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
Was an economic aid program developed right after the Truman doctrine to help European countries recover from WWII and resist Soviet expansion.…
- 2250 Words
- 9 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Once allies in the WWII against Germany, the United States and Soviet Union became enemies very quickly. The Soviet Union was flexing its muscles setting up pro communist regimes throughout Eastern Europe. America then had to reluctantly reverse its stance of not getting involved in European affairs and introduced the Truman Doctrine. The Truman Doctrine pledged to aid European countries be threatened by communist subversion. Whole soldiers of these two super powers (Soviet Union and the United States) did not battle each other directly.…
- 447 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
The presidents during this time were Dwight D. Eisenhower and Harry S Truman. Both of which passed the Eisenhower doctrine and the Truman Doctrine. The Truman Doctrine was passed through congress to supply aid and military supplies to Greece and Turkey. During this time, Russia had been attempting to spread communism around the globe creating the Second Red Scare. In fear that this would spread to Turkey and Greece, Truman used a bribe-like method in order to stop the spread of communism into the two countries. Eisenhower's Doctrine was an attempt for congress to give him military and financial aid to help those fighting communism in the middle east. This again is because of Russia in their attempt to spread communism. Both of these attempts were used for the benefit of not only the United States but for other countries around the…
- 697 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Truman asked for $400 million in military and economic expenses for Greece and Turkey and to establish a doctrine. The Truman administration believed that both Turkey and Greece were both threatened by communism. The Truman Doctrine had been providing and helping Greece and Turkey since the end of World War II. President Truman declared, "It must be the policy of the United States to support free peoples who are resisting attempted subjugation by armed minorities or by outside pressures." The Truman Doctrine was ¨a promise that the United States would do whatever was necessary both economically and militarily to contain the spread of communism around the…
- 280 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays