Peter Pan Movie vs Book

Only available on StudyMode
  • Topic: Hook, Peter and Wendy, Peter Pan
  • Pages : 3 (905 words )
  • Download(s) : 1276
  • Published : October 30, 2012
Open Document
Text Preview
The Barrie book and the Disney film present a big number of elements that match and of facets that are completely distinct. Firstly, the 1953 movie respects the narrative lines and the main personal characteristics. Peter Pan, for example, is as cocky, courageous and forgetful as he is in the book, just as Tinker Bell is as jealous, but possibly in a slightly less sexual way. The most important moral values followed by the book are also maintained by the Disney feature, such as the pricelessness of youth and the importance of family. In terms of the elements that separate the two art forms in their treatment of the story, two main kinds can be distinguished: those that are totally irrelevant for the narrative (and that only suit technical and prosaic impositions), and those that alter significantly the general purpose and aspect of the work. In the first group can be included changes in names or re- definitions of lesser physical and psychological features of some characteristics. The Disney producers, for example, changed the name of Neverland in NeverNeverland and, although in Barrie’s text Hook lost his right hand, the Disney artists relocated his hook to the left hand, because otherwise it would limit his actions too much. The bigger differences are more related to other kind of constrictions. In fact, two main reasons are behind the most significant variations between the film and the book. First, the Disney Studios had to deal with budget and time limitations, which were naturally absent from the creation of the novel. This impeded the adaptation of many elements that remain, to this day, exclusive to Barrie’s work. Secondly, the film producers had to ensure that the film could be seen by younger audiences, which evidently implied a reshaping of content of the text. Consequently, the most violent parts of the book are softened in the movie. For example, whereas in the play and the novel Tinker Bell gets knocked out by a poison, in the animated film she gets...
tracking img