Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Perspectives of War: Ancient Greece and Today

Powerful Essays
1057 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Perspectives of War: Ancient Greece and Today
“Everlasting peace is a dream, and not even a pleasant one; and war is a necessary part of God’s arrangement of the world.” Count Helmuth von Moltke wrote these words in a letter to Dr. J.K. Bluntschli in December of 1880. Von Moltke’s words, spoken from his experience in the Franco-Prussian War, portray an unusual philosophy. Instead of debating on the ethics of war, he speaks of its continuity and necessity to man. His reasoning has inspired an uncommon belief that it is not whether war is right or wrong that holds importance, but its inevitability. War is a perpetual and endless occurrence of strength, dominance, and destruction that is motivated by the debated morality of violence, the destructive instinct of man, and the inevitable acceptance of war. Despite the vast difference in culture and time of the ancient Greeks and that of today’s society, scholars have found that the views of war are still quite similar on both sides, and such is an issue both societies must contend with in order to survive . The Iliad, an epic by Homer that describes the war between the ancient cultures of Greece and the city of Troy, is one such document that helps to provide this insight. The most common and most debated issue of war is the morality of violence. Being an almost expected component of war, it is difficult to advocate war without advocating violence. In The Iliad, violence seems to be a necessary factor for the purpose of the tale: to describe the brutal battle that was the Trojan War. However, violence was still seen as controversial. For example, in Book I, line 187, King Agamemnon says to the war hero Achilles, “You actually like fighting and war…”, showing that violence and war are not common place pleasures. Thomas Palaima, a professor of classical studies at the University of Austin-Texas, performed a study and found that the views of violence in soldiers from Vietnam and soldiers from Troy were in fact very similar. In today’s society, many scholars believe in the “just-war principles,” a collection of principles that justify whether or not a war is ethical, but many organized religions, such as Christianity, believe violence to be wrong. Such a viewpoint is shared by characters of the Iliad like Briseis, the priestess held captive by Achilles. However, violence becomes moral conditional upon its purpose in religions such as Islam and Judaism. Consequently, scholars today are at odds with the major religions of the world, which have opposing views. Even if it were possible then and now, war cannot be stopped because of the controversy of violence. War also cannot be stopped due to the destructive instinct of man. Albert Einstein once wrote in a letter to Sigmund Freud, that man must have a “lust for hatred and destruction,” which is why he is so easily incited to war. The Ilian character Menelaus wants to wage war with Troy because his wife ran away with a Trojan prince. His brother Agamemnon simply wants to defeat city that has never before been conquered. Even Achillies, said to be half-man, half-god, calls himself a man made for war. According to a paper written by Peter Manicas, “In ancient Greece one could war for booty-slaves, gold, or riches--or one could war to alleviate a scarcity of domestic necessaries- timber, iron, or grain--or one could war to ensure the supply of such necessaries. And finally, one could go to war to establish a tribute-paying empire.” Looking at the crime rate in present America, one would be hard-pressed to deny this characteristic of mankind even today. As stated by Einstein, man has a destructive instinct that is as natural as breathing, making war an essentially innate part of man. In addition to the morality of violence and man’s destructive instinct, the most important illustration of the endlessness of war in history is its inevitable acceptance by man. Manicas quotes, “the Greeks came to accept war as a natural fact like birth and death about which nothing could be done.” In his letter entitled “Why War?” Sigmund Freud states that man is “another of the painful calamities of life” which must be accepted. By simply accepting war, man would be accepting that it is neither right nor wrong. In Book XII of the Iliad, lines 374-381, Sarpedon, a defender of Troy, tells one of his comrades that he wishes he could escape the war, but the battle was going to happen anyway, so he might as well fight for glory and Troy. As Freud predicted, mankind need not worry about the ethics of war, only its eventual acceptance. Such a perspective has obviously been noted both in ancient Greece and today’s society. In conclusion, the issue of war and its inescapability has been dealt with by both the classical culture of ancient Greece, as portrayed in the epic The Iliad, and the culture of the more contemporary generations. Both societies have determined that war will continue until the end of human existence, when its only motivation is gone. In ancient Greece and the present time, war was and is a perpetual and continuous occurrence of strength, dominance, and destruction driven by the human condition and insured by the debated morality of violence, the destructive instinct of man, and the inevitable acceptance of war. Indeed, Helmuth von Moltke was right. “Everlasting peace” is, and must be, a dream because everlasting war is a reality.

Works Cited

Manicas, Peter T. "War, Stasis, and Greek Political Thought." Comparative Studies in Society and History, Vol. 2. Comparative Studies in Society and History. October 1982. University of Hawai 'i at Manoa. 17 pp. 20 September 2008. http://www.libstudy.hawaii.edu/manicas/pdf_files/pub/WarStasis.pdf.

Porter, Sara. "Palaima Speaks on Ancient Greece 's Wars." 11 November 2002. University of Missouri-St. Louis. 20 September 2008. http://media.www.thecurrentonline.com/media/storage/paper304/news/2002/11/11/Features/Palaima.Speaks.On.Ancient.Greeces.Wars-320197.shtml.

Lawall, Thalmann, Patterson, James, Spacks. _The Norton Anthology Western Literature_. Lawall, Sarah. Eighth edition. New York, London: W.W. Norton & Company, Inc., 2006.

Einstein, Albert and Sigmund Freud. Why War?. Letters of Correspondence. N.p.: n.p., n.d. N. pag.

Cited: Manicas, Peter T. "War, Stasis, and Greek Political Thought." Comparative Studies in Society and History, Vol. 2. Comparative Studies in Society and History. October 1982. University of Hawai 'i at Manoa. 17 pp. 20 September 2008. http://www.libstudy.hawaii.edu/manicas/pdf_files/pub/WarStasis.pdf. Porter, Sara. "Palaima Speaks on Ancient Greece 's Wars." 11 November 2002. University of Missouri-St. Louis. 20 September 2008. http://media.www.thecurrentonline.com/media/storage/paper304/news/2002/11/11/Features/Palaima.Speaks.On.Ancient.Greeces.Wars-320197.shtml. Lawall, Thalmann, Patterson, James, Spacks. _The Norton Anthology Western Literature_. Lawall, Sarah. Eighth edition. New York, London: W.W. Norton & Company, Inc., 2006. Einstein, Albert and Sigmund Freud. Why War?. Letters of Correspondence. N.p.: n.p., n.d. N. pag.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    By the middle of the 5th century B.C. Athens and Sparta, the two most powerful Greek city-states, found themselves on the brink of a full-scale war. According to Thucydides, at the beginning of the war both Athens and Sparta were at the pick of their might and flourishing and could trade and cooperate to each other’s benefit; instead, they got involved into an armed confrontation, in which the rest of the Greek cities participated, on one side or on the other.…

    • 814 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    MLA Worksheet 1

    • 428 Words
    • 3 Pages

    7. An article/chapter by Joshua Smith, Ph. D. called “Those Insufferable Greeks” on page 201-247 of the book/collection called Infamous World Empires. The collection was edited by James Wygonik and published by Colonial Press of Denver in 1983.…

    • 428 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Trojan War Analysis

    • 1042 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The epic story told in Trojan War is considered by many to be a starting foundation of Greek mythology and to other modern stories we still tell today. It is a story of envy, disloyalty, cleverness, and persistence that few stories can challenge. Greek myths such as The War on Troy tell of epic tales of gods and goddesses working together and even feuding among each other in order to create a more desirable world for themselves. They are the stories of people dealing with and overcoming personal and cultural issues as represented by the gods in a society where history and storytelling go hand in hand. These so called myths…

    • 1042 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Can you imagine four-thousand spartans charging down a hill while three-thousand Athenians ready their bows and release them all simultaneously while the string whips in the hard rain? The Peloponnesian War was one of the most fierce wars in Greece because many people fell in battle. From the South were the Spartans. Their forces had never been stronger with a reformed, military-based government. From the North was the Athenians who had just been through a war that had been won, and were still armed and battle ready, holding fortresses across Greece. The interactions that these two city states made against, with, and without them were so intense that even the fierce kings, Leonidas of Sparta and King Pericles Cleon Nicias of Athens, fell to each other's armies.…

    • 1309 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    To conclude, there is no doubt that the conflict of war is a useless encounter that affects many innocent people’s lives, the economic stability and physiological wellbeing of soldiers. It is evident that in some circumstances society makes war to ensure peace, and on the surface this seems rational, even plausible. However, in reality throughout the journey there is a great human and economic cost…

    • 66 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Book 11, Vergil's Aeneid

    • 553 Words
    • 2 Pages

    What happened to disturb your quiet life and make you rouse the unknown that is war…Invite me to no warfare such as this. Troy fallen, I have no quarrel with Trojans. No delight in calling up evil days” (XI, 345,46, 379-81).…

    • 553 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Undeniably, the ancient Greek society places a heavy emphasis on values and traditions. The two texts of the “Clouds” by Aristophanes and “History of the Peloponnesian war” by Thucydides, although contextually divergent, are actually conceptually convergent. Both texts are built around the central theme of the collapse of conventional values. While the breakdown of traditional values in the “History of the Peloponnesian war” is presented in a more metaphorical and symbolical manner, the downfall of conventional values in the “Clouds” is on a more direct basis. Although both texts essentially convey across the same solemn message that the relinquishment of traditional values leads to dire consequences, Aristophanes also implicitly challenges the authority of old values, and hopes to improve upon these traditions.…

    • 1936 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    persian war

    • 327 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The Persian war was remarkable not only for its ferocious battles, which showcased the superiority of Greek military methods, but also for the striking personalities involved, the democratic character of the military command, and…

    • 327 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Hanson, V. D., & Keegan, J. 2000. The wars of the ancient Greeks: and their invention of western military culture. London, Cassell. 61-2.…

    • 3453 Words
    • 14 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    “They were beaten at all points and altogether; all that they suffered was great; they were destroyed as the saying is with total destruction, their fleet, their army; everything was destroyed and few out of many returned home.” (Thucydides, Peloponnesian War, 481) The Sicilian military campaign of Athens proved to be one of the most disastrous military campaigns in ancient times. The loss of thousands of soldiers and sailors, hundreds of vessels and vast amounts of money from the treasury reduced tremendously the Athenian ability to wage war; however, even in spite of such a loss, Athens was still able to prolong the war for nine more years until the Spartans defeated Athens in 404 B.C. The downfall of Athens came as a result of Spartan military operations, which destroyed the Athenian navy and cut off Athens from the supply of grain from Ionia. The decisive battle at Aegospotami in 405 B.C put an end to the Athenian empire and Athenian military power. There were many reasons for the demise of Athens, ranging from bad leadership and preparation for war to a lack of overall strategic concept for conducting the war against Sparta and its allies. All of these reasons contributed to the downfall of Athens in the Peloponnesian War; however, this paper will focus only on the failure of Athens to execute Pericles’s strategy. Athens lost the Peloponnesian War because of a failure to follow the strategy of Pericles, which ultimately led to reckless expeditions, ill-advised war decisions and loss of allies.…

    • 1838 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Best Essays

    Bibliography: Cartledge, Paul. Sparta and Lakonia: A Regional History 1300-362 BC. New York, NY: Routledge, 2002 Cartledge, Paul. Spartan Reflections. London, UK: University of California Press, 2003 Dictionary.com. Dictionary.com Unabridged. Random House, Inc. http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/lacedaemonian (accessed: October 11, 2012) McKay, John, Hill, Bennet, Buckler, John, Beck, Roger, Crowston, Clare, Ebrey, Patricia, and Wiesner-Hanks, Merry. A History of World Societies. Boston, MA: Bedford St. Martins, 2009 Neil, Jenifer, and John H. Oakley. Coming of Age in Ancient Greece: Images of Childhood from the Classical Past. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 2003 Pomeroy, Sarah B. Spartan women . Oxford, New York : Oxford University Press, 2002. http://apus.aquabrowser.com.ezproxy2.apus.edu/ (accessed October 14, 2012) Powell, Anton. Athens and Sparta: Constructing Greek Political and Social History from 478 BC. London, UK: Reutledge, 1988. http://web.ebscohost.com.ezproxy2.apus.edu/ehost/ebookviewer/ebook/nlebk_77284_AN ?sid=394711ef-1adc-43f9-8622-2db87fd942b7@sessionmgr111&vid=1 (accessed October 14, 2012)…

    • 1946 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    The book “On justice, power and human nature” by the athenian general, philosopher and general known as Thucydides, examines the history of the Peloponnesian war as well as exploring the actions of the political government. His analysis carries various speeches from important figures that were present during the war. In the speech of Archidamus, Thucydides expresses what the king conveyed to the attendees in the congress of Sparta. This essay will argue how the speech of Archidamus expresses that being unprepared and to charge against the high resourceful Athenian population would be unwise, harmful and dangerous. His decision for expressing these words is mainly based on historical facts. King Archidamus claims that if their unprepared population decides to ignore these facts, it will bring a greater harm to their population. In contrast, their foe, the Athenians have access to a variety of essential resources such as, “a strong navy and their numerous tax-paying allies allows them to achieve a higher chance of victory at war.” (1.80). Therefrom, due to these important facts, the wise king Archidamus strongly encourages their population to postpone their attack and to prepare their army instead. In preparation for their postponed war, the Spartans must gather new allies and new resources. By doing so, they will establish a “better position in countering their Athenians foes.”(1.82). Moreover, King Archidamus argues that to abstain their attack and act cautious is not an act of cowardice, but an act of bravery. He agrees that they’re indeed slow, but their action is nothing but self control. He says “This slowness of ours is really nothing but a clear headed self control.” (1.84). This expressive statement from the wise king means that by taking their time is not because they’re cowards, rather they’re controlling themselves from making an irrational action due…

    • 1209 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Peloponnesian War

    • 1003 Words
    • 5 Pages

    While the story of Athens is not necessarily one to be cheered, it is one to be remembered and critically dissected. Thucydides, a native of Athens who greatly appreciated all that it encompassed, looked on the city as an evolving monster. He watched as a once affluent and thriving state became suffocated with greed and power, until it eventually destroyed the Greek world. An important lesson in Thucydides’ The History of the Peloponnesian War is that whatever starts a war can be very different from what causes it, and by providing enough perspective learning the different between the two is…

    • 1003 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the Iliad, the author, Homer, displays how war can affect individuals physically and mentally. This results in the individuals becoming more barbaric and hindering their true identities. Throughout the Iliad, the author shows the effects of war on specific characters.…

    • 716 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In this essay, based on the definition of necessity that I have given in the introduction, I have tried to incorporate the different sections in Thucydides History to justify my arguments of what is a war of necessity and in what circumstances would it be necessary for states to go to war with each other. By incorporating different sections into my arguments, I try to ensure that I have a more well-rounded understanding of Thucydides viewpoints and not take any of his viewpoints out of context. With the above in mind, I have put forth two arguments in this essay regarding what is a war of necessity and in my opinion, a war of necessity is one where the citizens of a state go all out to protect their own way of life from an external threat.…

    • 281 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays