Pereboom Argument

Only available on StudyMode
  • Download(s) : 85
  • Published : May 22, 2013
Open Document
Text Preview
Two thumbs up for Hard Incompatabilism
Through Perebooms arguments we see how he argues against compatibilism, and how he presents to us four cases that will support his rejection against compatibilism. We will see how he delivers a way in which the agents will not be morally responsible for their actions, and succeeds in planting that seed of dought in us. Summary:

In Pereboom’s argument, he discusses that it is because casual determinism is true that we lack this sort of free will that is required for moral responsibility, leading to him calling this hard incompatabilism. In Pereboom’s case for hard incompatibilism, it involves arguing against two competing positions. The first would be “Compatibilism which claims that free will of the type required for moral responsibility is compatible with determinism” (456).Which means that we do not have free will because it is something that is determined already which means we cannot be morally responsible for it. And we have the second position which is Libertarianism. “Libertarianism contends that although the sort of free will required for moral responsibility is not compatible with determinism, it turns out that determinism is false, and we do have the kind of free will” (456-457). Pereboom then gives us four different cases where Professor Plum participates in the cases where we get to see how the actions of an agent are being manipulated, in which indicates that it is possible for the agent not to be morally responsible even if they meet the compatibilist conditions. The first case tells us about Professor Plum and how he was created by neuroscientist, and how they can manipulate him to undertake the process of reasoning. So forth that because his actions is determined by the neuroscientist his first desire to kill White conforms to his second order of desire. In case number two, Plum is an ordinary human being in which he has been programmed by the neuroscientist in the beginning of his life to weigh...
tracking img