Preview

people are not free to make moral decisions

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1582 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
people are not free to make moral decisions
People are not free to make moral decisions. Discuss [35]
Is it right to say that our actions are determined, or are they free? Hard determinists argue that when we make a moral decision, we have no free will. This is significant because if we do not choose our actions we cannot be held morally responsible. Given our experience of decision making this determinist position is hard to accept and perhaps the compatabilist approach of soft determinism is more valid. Soft Determinists recognise that we can make a decision freely that is coerced but the choices in themselves may be determined themselves. This contrasts with libertarianism, which states that we freely choose our actions and rejects determinism.
To fully examine whether we are in fact free or not to make moral decisions, we must first analyse what particular factors affect our decision making. When we debate over a decision we consider/ weigh up our options, we know that we have a choice and only we can make that choice, this is known as a libertarian view. Libertarians believe that we have full responsibility of our actions and nothing else affects our decision, however genes, environment, lifestyle and our upbringing affect or sometimes might determine our choices. Determinism objects libertarianism and believes that our choices are influenced by factors other than the will of the individual, events and actions are predetermined by other events therefore freedom of choice is an illusion.
Free will is the term made up of ‘autos’ meaning self and ‘nomos’ meaning rule. Many philosophers such as Kant say that you can only be responsible for actions that you undertake of your own will, this is opposed to Determinism.
Libertarianism is the belief that humans are free to make moral choices and therefore morally responsible. “By liberty we can only mean a power of acting of not acting according to the determinations of the will”. David Hume. In the definition of libertarianism a distinction between the

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Determinism is a controversial topic to free will with multiple theories proving and disproving it. As printed in The Collins Cobuild Learner's Dictionary, determinism is defined as “...the belief that all actions and events result from other actions, events, or situations, so people cannot in fact choose what to do.” Meaning, all life choices are predetermined from the minute we are born, to the minute we die. In contrast, “freewill is an individual taking control and responsibility for his/her actions according to his personal will” (Freewill Verses Determinism). People who believe in Free will, accept the idea that life is not predetermined, and they can independently act however they see fit. Free will and determinism can be further simplified and have multiple differences as well as similarities.…

    • 1475 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Gary Gutting, the author of the article, What Makes Free Will Free? deliberates that we do not have free choice as we assumed which a researcher confirmed. By free choice, this means the conviction that our conduct is dictated by our own unrestrained choice and that we have complete power over our activities. Also, Gary Gutting examined various thoughts on determinism as the researchers suggested. Determinism refers to the conviction that all human conduct or any other occurrences have a cause. This is opposed to a person's will to accomplish an action. Gary Gutting discussed what David Hume, a philosopher, believed and the belief of David Hume is that both determinism and free choice are possible, they are compatible with each…

    • 1857 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Free-Will Vs Determinism

    • 1491 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The debate between free will vs determinism is important because it reflects on actions and intentions of humans, but free will brings up strong valid points supported by evidence. Free will can be simplified as a human does what they ultimately and truly want in their mind, through their own beliefs and character. Determinism is about having strong influences in an environment, that the decisions of individuals reflect off their unconscious mind. Determinism can influence decisions, but the final decision and action is up to the individual. Through past experiences a person can learn and be influenced by everything in their surroundings, but it does not force a person to make a decision based on their past. I do not believe that anything is…

    • 1491 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Well, breaking it down that is not what free will defines. Free will is the ability to make his or her own decision. To some extent determinism (not to be confused with hard determinism) and free will can both collaborate together making our world. Yes, something had to create us, but when we are born we are born with a desire to follow our hearts. We are designed to have our own free will. Although it may seem like hard determinism derails free will's argument it is an incorrect accusation at a completely different topic not in relation to free will. If we used hard determinism, that would mean that no one is held accountable to their actions or morals. With their philosophy it would mean that everything was planned out and whatever happens was planned to happen. So with that in mind it does not matter if I steal because it was supposed to happen, etc. I believe God gave us free will to further the Kingdom of God, and because He wants us to choose Him, not be forced to love…

    • 951 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Phl458 Week 1

    • 536 Words
    • 3 Pages

    "Free will is the capacity to respond in ways that oppose even the strongest influences. Free will is itself a causative factor, and one that can trump all others" (Ruggiero, 2019, p. 37). We all have a choice in any situation, although one's ethics or morals can influence choices, nevertheless the choice to react in one way or another is one's free will.…

    • 536 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Libertarians support the view that people have free will and so we are free to make moral decisions. For a Libertarian, the key evidence for this is the act of decision making in our daily lives. Hume states that “experience is what we see to be true”, each human being experiences the feeling of being free to make a decision. If experiencing any other action constitutes it to be true, then why not the same for free will? Libertarians argue that we have awareness of the choices we make; we can choose to do anything that we are capable of. Though we are influenced by our environment and experiences, ultimately we can make our own decisions, nothing is inevitable or determined. Libertarians hold the belief of a moral self; humans want to want to do things. For example, a smoker may think it would be a good idea to give up smoking, but their addiction is too strong for them to think it possible or in any way likely; they want to want to give up smoking. Humans are unique in this way and it is this which is called the moral self. Libertarians are dualists believing that the human mind is separate from the physical world. It is because of this that our reason and autonomy, our moral self, can transcend over other causal determinants. Kant argues that by applying reason to decisions we can escape any authority from cause and effect or desires and emotions, we are the agents of our own decisions. Libertarians believe in a forking path of choices rather than the straight road of determinism.…

    • 956 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    I believe freedom to be the ability to make your own choices, which are not influenced by anyone else’s opinions or decisions, when faced with either a difficult or easy decision. Some philosophers believe that our ability to make free choices is an illusion which means that we are not free at all. Others state that there is something else beyond our understanding that may cause our actions to be determined. These theories can be linked to Determinism. Determinism says that there are laws that exist outside of our control that cause the things that happen-laws such as gravity. Scientific laws determine all our actions based on what has happened before. Previous events have consequences that may be determined and which in turn will cause more consequences. This can be linked to Aristotle’s teachings which stated that every action has some sort of cause and therefore an effect. Therefore we cannot help our actions when they have already been decided for us.…

    • 1786 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Theories Of Determinism

    • 740 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Like I said before freewill is a topic that philosophers have argued about over the years. Most times when the question ‘do you have freewill?’ is asked, a lot of individuals usually say they are free even without thinking twice. Although there are a lot of philosopher that believe we all have freewill and there are also other philosopher who have spoken up and tried to prove their point that humans have no freewill. Philosopher that argue that humans have no freewill are called the determinists. The determinists argue that previous events and the law of nature cause all human acts, so humans are not free or responsible for their acts. The determinist approach says that all behaviors are caused by preceding factors…

    • 740 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Three Types Of Determinism

    • 1618 Words
    • 7 Pages

    The first type is the hard determinist. The hard determinist believes that all actions are already determined from beforehand, which means we cannot control our actions. The hard determinist also believes that people do not have any moral responsibility; therefore, this type of belief there isn’t any rewards for doing something good or punishment for doing something bad since the individual couldn’t have acted differently this means the agent had no freedom. The next type of determinist is the soft determinist. Like the hard determinist, they believe that the individual couldn’t have acted (all actions are predetermined) differently but, the individual is held morally responsible. The soft determinist believes that the agent still has freedom if not constrained, in the situation of the bomb around your neck and you acted in harmony with your desire. The last philosophical view is libertarianism. The libertarianism believes that the agent could have acted differently, individuals do have freedom and they do hold complete moral responsibility. Ayer discusses moral responsibility by bringing an argument discussing hard determinism which is stated…

    • 1618 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Free will is the power, attributed to man making free choices that are unconstrained by external forces or by an agency such as destiny or gods will. This is a difficult subject for me as I have broken beliefs pertaining to both. I believe in divine will (if god said it then it shall be done) but I also believe in free will. As man was created in gods image and was given free will, hence my conflict. If it is Gods will for me to be teacher or dish washer in the church. Then avenues will open up for me in that direction I shall without question go that way. This implies determinism or predestines which is a direct contradiction to mans endowment with free…

    • 937 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Choice is “an act of selecting or making a decision when faced with two or more possibilities.” This is something that we deal with each and everyday of our lives. We react to things in different ways which determine what outcome that happens afterward. The choices we make are our own and play out to be good or bad. Free will not only result in whatever the outcome may be, but those choices determine how we deal with situations in our life based on our feelings and what we think is best; good or bad. For example, we choose whether or not to get up on time and get ready for our day. This is a choice that we make based on what we feel like doing. Life is full of choices and we deal with them everyday. If we did not make choices, everything would be perfect would it not? No one would do things that they…

    • 614 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    This means that the choices we make are those made by us alone, we determine the choices we make. We all think we make our own choices, and therefore we cannot all be wrong. This is different from Hard Determinism where freewill is supposedly an illusion and that we are wrong by thinking we have freewill, our choices are all determined. When we make a choice we acknowledge that: a) we do not already know what we are going to do and b) it is in our power to do what we are thinking of doing. However, although Libertarians would argue that we are making free moral choices, they would claim that we are completely free. For example Antony Worrall Thompson, who is a celebrity chef, who stole shopping from Tesco. He made the choice to steal from that shop because we make all our own decisions according to Libertarianism. Whereas the Hard Determinist’s would say that he had no choice because of what happened in his early life, his mother was an alcoholic, and he was abused by four people he also had a facial injury from rugby which left him needing plastic surgery when he turned 18 and therefore there was nothing he could do. A Libertarian would disagree with this and say that he made the choice with no prior causes, he was self determined in that situation, he decided to steal out of his own volition and he should have been punished for…

    • 1258 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    “Good and evil, reward and punishment, are the only motives to a rational creature: these are the spur and reins whereby all mankind are set on work, and guided.”…

    • 326 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    course work

    • 3414 Words
    • 10 Pages

    You also need to understand that philosophers distinguish between two different definitions of freedom. This will invariably influence one’s views on free will and determinism:…

    • 3414 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    freedom and resentment

    • 337 Words
    • 2 Pages

    people and their actions, which means if people act freely because they are not determined to act as they do. The person could have done the complete opposite, which makes determinism false. But if determinism is true, both obligation and responsibility have no application to anything. Justified application of the concepts of moral obligation and responsibility requires freedom, and freedom implies the falsity of determinism. In conclusion, a pessimist believe determinism is true.…

    • 337 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays