CHECK-UP
1. The old man is a farmer. F
2. The narrator is a Fascist who is in revolt against the republic. F
3. The old man wishes to go in the direction of Barcelona. F
4. The old man is in favor of the Loyalist forces. F
5. The old man was the last one to leave his native town. T
FOR DISCUSSION
1. In this story the old man represents the innocent people who are the victims of war. How does Hemingway convey the sadness of the old man´s situation? By showing his story, how he lost everything and had no idea of his future. Victims of war stay with nothing and do not have nothing to go. Also by demonstrating how vulnerable is, he does not have a voice to opinion and does what he is told.
2. The old man is worried about what will happen to the animals. In what way is his own fate mirrored in that of the animals he can no longer care for? When he tries to find a solution or response to the future of the animals. Even though he can't care of them anymore, he still is thinking about them and how they could survive.
3. How does the old man´s statement “ I am without politics” emphasize the central meaning of the story? That he has nothing. He does not fight for anything and does not have a reason to be involved in war. He is just a victim and is lost for not having a side.
4. What ironic significance is there to this action taking place on Easter Sunday? Easter is the celebration of liberty, and he is not free at all. He is a victim of something he does not even care of. How would anyone by free if he/she is a victim?
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
In Pinckney Benedict’s 2008 short story “Mercy,” the narrator and his father both take pride in their family’s ranch. The narrator works hard for his father each day, taking breaks only to sneak treats to the miniature horses being kept on the neighbor’s ranch nearby. The narrator’s father; however, does not show the same compassion for the animals as his son. He is adamant about keeping the horses off of his land and warns his son that he will shoot to first to intrude. The narrator views his father in a very austere manner.…
- 1152 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
make moral choices for himself and doing the right thing. Plus he sees how the people act in British Burma, the things they have to go through thanks to…
- 704 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
He tells the story of a young girl and boy in trying situations and persuades his audience to feel sorry for them. The boy lives in a bad area. His father is “jobless” and his mother is a “sleep-in domestic.” The girl must take on the “role of [a] mother” because her “mother died.” What reader can help but feeling sorry for a young child who has no hope? They still live in fear and desolation and have no hope, for their race is sinking. Once, their people worked with “George Washington” and “shed blood in the revolution.” But, they fell from higher hopes and were put on “slave ships... in chains.” The reader can’t help but feel sorry for a race that has been so abused and taken advantage of.…
- 484 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Young people often do not know what to expect of the future. They do not know how to act when something unexpected comes along, and their actions are based on what they do know; usually limited, biased information. This idea is central to the short story, ʺWar,ʺ by Timothy Findley. The young boy, Neil Cable, narrates the day he found out his father had joined the army. He speaks of his actions, feelings, and confusion surrounding that day. At first glance, his actions are all too often misinterpreted as violence and hatred, but after careful consideration, one can see that they are merely his way of dealing with the troubling news. He has not experienced enough in his lifetime to have a true understanding of war, and acts upon what he does know. In the short story, ʺWarʺ, by Timothy Findley, the young boy’s image of war and actions throughout are explained through the use of symbolism.…
- 1367 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
boy he was before the war, but a strong man who has to care for his family. As another example,…
- 1352 Words
- 4 Pages
Powerful Essays -
He sees himself as a rough, baboon soldier, this is evident when he apologises for his speech…
- 355 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
He experienced firsthand the brutal casualties that wars brought on, much like soldiers today, and he embodies the type of person that people can visualize as being determined to make it out alive and return…
- 602 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
4. When Old Major addresses the animals, what emotions is Orwell trying to arouse in the reader?…
- 2049 Words
- 9 Pages
Good Essays -
Every bit of his support falls through in one way or another, from his friends to the law to his employers to his romantic love, except for the horses. The horses stay pure and give him the strength, after all that’s happened, to ride away into the sunset again on the last page of the…
- 969 Words
- 4 Pages
Better Essays -
3) What do we know about the old man in the story? What motivates the narrator to kill him?…
- 499 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
In 1971, veteran John Kerry stands for himself and many other veterans in a speech opposing the Vietnam War. Relaying how the veterans feel after coming back from such a horrific war, the audience is sympathetic with those who return with such terrible memories that they must bare for the rest of their lives. For John Kerry, it may be hard for him to describe such atrocities to his audience, and it may be even harder for the audience to believe that what he is saying is truthful, because what was going on in Vietnam at the time was much different than what the citizens of the USA believed it to be. For them, knowing the truths of the Vietnam War may simply put them in denial, however I believe Kerry’s descriptions were effective in convincing the audience of the truths of the war, because he conveys his truths by appealing to the audience’s pathos.…
- 818 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Little did he know he would also be part of the war, first running away from the rebels to becoming a soldier and fighting against them relentlessly. The world he once knew was gone. The world where he didn’t have to worry about walking out of his…
- 459 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
process of aging which he has undergone. In doing so, he reflects on time, death, and the nature of life itself.…
- 2524 Words
- 9 Pages
Powerful Essays -
that no ordinary people benefit from a war. No matter what side a man is on, he…
- 666 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
And in this chapter we met an old man who used to come to the author’s club, as many of men did. But he was not the ordinary man, so that is why the author told us about him.…
- 1988 Words
- 8 Pages
Powerful Essays