George is NOT Guilty
He is about to make the hardest decision of his life. No matter what his decision is, his closest friend will die. Does he live with the fact that he let his best friend be killed by a mob of ruthless and unforgiving men? Or does he kill his own friend to save him from the incessant torture of a dozen angry men? George Milton, in the book Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck, has to decide the fate of his friend Lennie Small. He chooses to kill Lennie himself but it creates controversy among many readers. They all wonder, “Is George now guilty of murder or not?” In my opinion, he is not. One reason why George isn’t guilty is because he is responsible for Lennie and always does right by him. He also prevents Lennie from suffering a miserable fate. Considering these two statements, George Milton cannot be guilty of murder. When Aunt Clara dies, George promises her that he will take care of him. This now means that George is fully responsible for Lennie. Living up to that promise, George has always gotten Lennie out of trouble at any cost. Lennie is wrongly accused of rape when he feels a girl’s dress in Weed. George defends Lennie and it costs them their jobs. George also stands up for Lennie when he breaks Curley’s hand during their brawl in the bunkhouse, even though it could’ve cost them another job. This proves that George cares enough about Lennie to do right by him when he is in trouble, no matter the circumstances. It is right for George to kill Lennie because it is the only way he can get Lennie out of trouble and prevent him from receiving a more harsh punishment. As George is responsible for what happens to Lennie, he understands that he must do what is in his best friend’s interest, which is to take his life. This selfless act on behalf of George makes it impossible to label him as a murderer. George strives to give Lennie a decent life and always looks out for what is in Lennie’s best interest. He makes sure Lennie is fed and clothed...
Please join StudyMode to read the full document