Page 1 of 4

Mr Lawrence Summers's Memo Analysis

Continues for 3 more pages »
Read full document

Mr Lawrence Summers's Memo Analysis

  • By
  • October 30, 2010
  • 1341 Words
  • 369 Views
Page 1 of 4
On February 8, 1992, portion of Mr Lawrence Summers’s internal memorandum of his viewpoint on the environment that was published in The Economist, a British publication, created a huge debate in the print media and disapprovals from the environmentalists. Three main reasons were given by Mr Summers in the encouragement for migration of the toxic wastes to the less developed countries. Hence, we shall now look in depth into these reasons given.

According to Mr Summers’s first point, the costs for being sick and dead due to pollution can be easily computed by the earnings forgone. From this point of view, the opportunity cost of a sick or dead individual is the wage he or she receives from working. As such, the opportunity costs will be lower in countries with lower wages, which are the less developed countries. With lower opportunity costs, the costs of pollution will thus be reduced. On the developing and developed countries side of argument, higher standards of living and technological advances lead to much higher opportunity costs, as their wages are much higher. This thus, results in higher costs of pollution. In comparison, if were to inject certain quantity to the environment, it will be more cost-effective to pollute in the less developed countries. Hence, a certain quantity of pollution should be created in the country with the lowest cost, in terms of lowest wage. Therefore, in the economic point, it is acceptable to dump loads of harmful waste in the lowest wage country.

In his second point, the equation for the costs of pollution is expected to be non-linear due to the likelihood of extremely low cost for the initial increment. With pollution in the environment usually at above satisfactory level in the short-run, there is no need to control it at high incremental cost. However, pollution in the environment eventually reaches an unsatisfactory high level with the increase in amount of toxic wastes produced in the long-run due to the flexibility of...