"More Testing, More Learning" Patrick O'Malley Critique

Only available on StudyMode
  • Download(s) : 1835
  • Published : December 6, 2006
Open Document
Text Preview
According to Patrick O'Malley's "More Testing, More Learning", the problem is that professors normally give less frequent exams that are counted the most against a student's grade. One of the effects he mentioned was that less frequent exams causes unnecessary amounts of stress on the student. Another one of the effects is that they don't encourage frequent study as well as fails to inspire students' best performance. O'Malley suggests that professors should give more frequent short exams to students. However, there are some objections to this suggestion. One is that such exams take up too much limited class time available to cover material in the course. Another objection is that short exams take too much time for professors to read and grade. Therefore, O'Malley suggested several alternatives to these objections. One of the alternatives is that the school should implement a program that would improve study skills. His second alternative is that professors should provide frequent study questions for students to answer. His final alternative is that the professors should provide frequent study questions from which the exam questions will be selected or announcing possible exam topics at the beginning of the course. However, O'Malley rejects these alternatives. He concludes that he sees frequent as well as brief exams as the only way to improve students' study habits and learning (352-355).

On the other hand, there are some weaknesses in O'Malley's argument towards more frequent exams. For example, frequent tests and exams may not have the same effect on all students. He mentions that by giving more frequent tests, "Students learn more in the course and perform better on major exams, projects, and papers" (353). However, all students have different learning capabilities. By giving frequent exams, one student may excel while another student may struggle due to the frequency of the exams. Also, O'Malley points out, "Greater frequency in test taking means greater...
tracking img