Preview

Mona Lisa Smile

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
827 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Mona Lisa Smile
Mona Lisa Smile

The movie "Mona Lisa Smile" is set in the 1950s and deals with the starting feminist's movement against traditional roles.
The main character, "History of Art" teacher Katherine Watson, arrives at the conservative all-women college of Wellesley and tries to teach her really smart students not only art history but also independence. She also wants her students to know that their aim, namely getting married, does not have to be their only purpose of life, but that it is also possible to be married and have a job.
In the following I will compare the attitudes towards the role of women of three female characters from the movie. I will also take developments of their attitude during the movie into consideration.
I want to start with a very forward thinking woman, Amanda Armstrong. She is the school nurse and lives together with Katherine Watson and Nancy Abbey. Although it is forbidden, she distributes contraception within the students of Wellesley. As it turns out during the movie, she is lesbian and had a relationship with a deceased teacher of Wellesley. She gets fired when the student Betty Warren writes an article about her in which Betty reveals Amanda's illegal distribution of contraception.
Amanda is a very independent and liberal woman who gets punished for being a forward thinker. She gives contraception to the girls because she wants them to get the freedom of making their own decisions. With the contraception they can decide if they want to have a baby or if they just want to have fun. The fact that some girls accept Amanda's offer shows that she is not the only one who wants to change something.
Amanda Armstrong's biggest opponent is Betty Warren, a young and smart student who follows the traditional way she should follow. She does not like Katherine Watson's way of teaching and thinking. Because of that, she writes not only an article about Amanda but also a very critical one about Katherine. She can not wait to marry her fiancé

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    However, Tina represents a society of the woman who are pursued by men at an early age with empty promises! At first, the film compromised women regarding their reputations. Nevertheless, concerning the times, women were required to spend their time performing their maternal duties. The resentment of these stereotypical female roles matches the quality, or lack thereof, male trustworthiness and loyalty.…

    • 425 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In contrast to Elizabeth, Mary is not as opinionated and doesn’t know how to speak her opinion…

    • 330 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Also in this movie sexism and gender roles happened in it. Just like during the times before this women had to stay in the house all the time. And they couldn’t get jobs…

    • 383 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Is it true to say that the representation of women and femininity has had limited development over the last 25 years… or would it be more accurate to say that these representations have dramatically changed? Has stereotyping become less accurate and more common or has the Romantic Comedy genre developed its representations to break female stereotypes? This investigation aims to explore these questions and, ultimately, to evaluate if the representation of femininity has developed over the last 25 years. Also, to find out to what extent the female role within Romantic Comedy has changed. Exploring the representations of female characters by comparing and contrasting the representation of femininity in the chosen texts; Pretty Woman (1990) directed…

    • 1764 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Susan B. Anthony

    • 581 Words
    • 3 Pages

    a teacher in the home school, offered a new and daring image of womanhood to Susan and her…

    • 581 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Amanda exemplifies how vital it is that a family unit stay loyal. After Mr. Wingfield disappeared her life has become a constant struggle in order to survive, a far cry from the Blue Mountain setting she idolizes in her past. Amanda symbolizes a downfall, but she also symbolizes drive for her children, encouraging Laura to blossom into something that they can both be proud of and encouraging Tom to keep his job and support his family until they can fend for themselves at least. Laura symbolizes fear and instability through the first five acts. She failed out of her class, that was a hope for a better future, because of her fear and doesn’t let herself actually try to engage in social interactions for fear that she will be inadequate in another’s eyes. Without Laura to feel sorry for and take care of Tom most likely would have left Amanda on her own in Mr. Wingfield’s footsteps a long time ago.…

    • 428 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    A woman back in the nineteenth century was to be in the home all day cleaning, taking care of the children, and tending to their husband. At least that is what tradition told us. Never would one imagine a married woman in front of a class teaching, typically teaching was done by the men when farming season was done. Teaching was seen as a way to show wisdom and respect, but once a woman stood in front of that blackboard the views had changed. When a woman did teach it was viewed as untraditional and disrespectful, if one was married the female teacher was to either resign from marriage and leave the family or to resign from teaching. If a married woman chose to continue teaching, there was to be no life outside of the school and that female would receive little to no pay. Not paying the female teachers helped the countries when it came to filling teaching occupations, little did these men know, the women were using teaching as a way to have their voice heard and to show self-confidence.…

    • 603 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Tom and Laura's father had left the family years ago and Tom fears that he is becoming just like his father because he is also going to leave. Amanda is constantly criticizing and nagging her two adult children Laura and Tom. Amanda nags Tom about his eating habits “Chew, Chew, chew…we are not animals…” about how he sits “Sit up straight…” and she censors what he reads by confiscating his books and returning them to the library “that insane Mr. Lawrence and his filth..” This characteristic definitely makes her the antagonist. Amanda suggests to Tom that his frequent trips to the movies are not at all as wholesome as he would like everyone to believe. She accuses Tom of doing things that are causing him shame. Tom tries to explain to Amanda that his frequent trips to the movies provide him with the adventure that he lacks in real life. Amanda harasses Tom about being restless and sullen and begrudges him the only source of pleasure he has like drinking and going to the movie theatre. Amanda implies that he is selfish because he is only concerned for his own happiness and wants to leave the family “Selfish dreamer….” Amanda has seen and read…

    • 599 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    However in the years to come many in the film industry would begin to challenge these guidelines starting with films such as 1960’s Mary Poppins. Anne Mcleer in her essay makes clear that although not radical ,”Mary Poppins” would begin to have us question our traditional roles. Films like such challenged the idea of the stay at home mother, and the father being the bread winner, even questioning the role of the father in their children’s lives, encouraging men to be more involved. Yet even as we began to progress, giving women larger roles in film with films such as Julie Andrews in “Victoria, Victor Victoria”, and Tracy Turnlab in “Hairspray” many in the film industry still encouraged traditional ideals. This was espeacially prevalent in the 1980’s, in Elaine Berland , and Marilyn Wetcher’s research they give us the example of the film “Fatal Attraction” this film shows us an stay at home mother with a husband who is cheating on her with a career driven women, and all of the problems that come with this…

    • 1334 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    b. Based on the positive quality of life aimed for by teenage Katharine, I feel it stands to reason she was brought up with an abundance of positive regard. She recalls her then ambitious intentions for her adult life, even stating she “had always thought she would be one of those women who had it all”. Using Rogers’ theory of positive self-regard as well as his theory of conditions of worth, we can understand how the years of her marriage brought about an steady increase of incongruity for Katharine. Having been forbid to earn her own money or even further her education, Katharine soon consciously forgot these were tangible desires which, when coupled with the conditional positive regard shown by her husband, left her only her once much desired marriage to express herself with and grow by.…

    • 590 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The movie showed instances of gender stereotyping most strongly. Starting with the women characters, there is a laundry list of notable instances, but I will only name a few. We can start with Azteca, Z's friend and fellow "worker". While Z is a typical male who is competitive and wants to move up in the world, Azteca maintains a somewhat "typical" female response. Instead of encouraging him, she tells Z to just smile, and happily accept his place, even if it is an awful life where he is to literally digging ditches his whole life. This example simply highlight the stereotype that women can, in effect, be "yes men", the phrase further illustrating the perception of weakness in females. Another time when this theme appeared was when the Queen was talking to her daughter, who was, in an old-school sort of way, betrothed to a man not of her choosing, the general. While the daughter complained, the Queen simply urged her to be complacent, and accept her fate, because it is "the best thing for everyone". Another instance, and one which I found particularly hilarious, was the woman wasp(no coincidence there, of course). When Z and the princess were in trouble, she insisted to her husband that he help them, because it was the humanitarian thing to do. It was presented in such a way that harkened to the proverbial housewife image, whereby the…

    • 469 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The dream Amanda has for her daughter contrasts with the reality of the Wingfield’s existence, because Amanda is not accepting the reality of her own existence, she is constantly referring to her past life; a Southern belle with many Gentlemen callers. She convinces herself that Laura can live the life she expected to continue for herself, not realizing her daughter does not share her dream.…

    • 393 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Jamaica Kincaid Girl

    • 1230 Words
    • 5 Pages

    In this analysis of "Girl" I wanted to look at the way women are portrayed by their class and how it affect their gendered actions. In doing this I wanted to look at what these women do professionally. By doing this I want to look at how Kincaid uses the words slut and lady. In this analysis I wanted to reflect on education and how it could potentially play into this story by looking at the different types of education the different classes receive. I also want to look at how this all plays into girlhood. When looking at this story after just reading it for the first time you see how the narrator is most likely a teacher or mother who is telling a young girl how to cook and clean. Throughout this I mainly just want to look at the two different types of classes Kincaid presents in this short story and why she chose what she did to perceive these two classes.…

    • 1230 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The first segment of the movie deals with a women called Claire Donnelly, a widowed nurse that lives in the suburbs of Chicago. Claire became pregnant by her brother in law, and she decides to do an abortion for the purpose of not hurting her late husband’s family. But abortion at the currently time, which is 1952, abortion was strictly illegal. Claire goes out searching for another somebody to help, and she finds a nurse that can help her. She calls a number she received from the nurse, and she calls the women, but the abortion place she was directed to Puerto Rico. Claire couldn’t afford the trip over there. She tries to do abortion by herself with a knitting needle, but failed. She finds another person, a man who will preform the abortion aat her house. Abortion is done and she dies shortly afterwards because of a hemorrhage.…

    • 621 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The movie tackles the tricky subject of stereotypes assigned to women, and how much they can be damaging to a woman’s pride, career and life. People love the movie for Reese Witherspoon’s portrayal of a young woman trying to impress a man, by getting into and succeeding at Harvard Law. The main character struggles the entire movie with the assumptions people make of her, writing her off as some blonde joke, yet she works to overcome these stereotypes and find out what really makes her happy. While this movie is wonderful for its character development, I find the main character to be too much of a Mary Sue, as they make her a little too perfect, and while she struggles, the idea that she might prove everyone wrong and succeed at everything is a little too unrealistic for some…

    • 1384 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays