Karl Popper and Thomas Kuhn 2

Topics: Scientific method, Science, Falsifiability Pages: 4 (1480 words) Published: October 8, 1999
Popper and Kuhn: Two Views of Science
In this essay I attempt to answer the following two questions: What is Karl Popper's view of science? Do I feel that Thomas Kuhn makes important points against it? The two articles that I make reference to are "Science: Conjectures and Refutations" by Karl Popper and "Logic of Discovery or Psychology of Research?" by Thomas Kuhn. Both articles appear in the textbook to this class. In the article, "Science: Conjectures and Refutations", Karl Popper attempts to describe the criteria that a theory must meet for it to be considered scientific. He calls this puzzle the problem of demarcation. Popper summarizes his arguments by saying, "the criterion of the scientific status of a theory is its falsifiability, or refutability, or testability." Kuhn says that he and Popper often agree as to what constitutes science and non-science. He claims that he differs with Popper in the methods that he uses to arrive at his conclusions. Kuhn says that if a line of demarcation is to be sought between science and non-science, we shouldn't look for a "sharp or decisive" one, because science is not objective, as Popper would have us believe, but subjective. Popper claims that the common answer to the problem of delineating between science and pseudo-science is that science uses an empirical method, deriving from observations and experiments. This explanation does not satisfy Popper. He has a gut feeling that areas of study like astrology are not science, and he attempts to come up with a theory to prove it. One of the problems I have with Popper is that instead of looking at a concrete problem and trying to come up with an explanation, Popper first made up his mind that astrology is not science, and then set out to prove it. By Popper's own admissions, confirming evidence is everywhere, but means little. This could be applied all of Popper's examples. Popper is "dissatisfied" with the Marxist theory of history, psychoanalysis, and...
Continue Reading

Please join StudyMode to read the full document

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Karl Popper and Thomas Kuhn Essay
  • Karl Popper Essay
  • Karl Popper Essay
  • kuhn vs. popper Essay
  • Essay on Philosophy of Science
  • Scientific Method and Sir Karl Popper Essay
  • Popper Essay
  • Kuhn vs. Popper vs. Lakatos Essay

Become a StudyMode Member

Sign Up - It's Free