Jury of One Peers

Only available on StudyMode
  • Topic: Jury, Judge, Jury trial
  • Pages : 2 (670 words )
  • Download(s) : 109
  • Published : June 30, 2011
Open Document
Text Preview
I can see pros and cons to having a “jury of one’s peers. The term "peers" is often interpreted to mean people of approximately your age, with similar religious beliefs, earning about the same income and having been born in a similar society. One that is of equal standing with another: EQUAL However, the jury pool from which jurors are selected for a criminal trial isn't selected from a database using those types of demographic filters. Rather, the jury pool is selected randomly from the local community. A jury of your peers means a random selection of the people who live in and around the community where the trial will be held. The final jury may consist of people much older or younger than you; people of very diverse religious beliefs; people earning below the poverty level, as well as those earning in the millions, and all income brackets in between. And now there is a very strong concern about having professionals serving on juries because of what outside expertise they may bring to the table during deliberations. This means that both the prosecutions and the defense attorneys who screen potential jurors are adverse to having one of these career people serve. The jury member’s might look like you, talk like you, but it doesn't mean they came through with the same point of view that you do. I should indeed be judged by peers who can understand my life experiences and who can adequately pass a verdict in keeping with the severity or depravity of my alleged crime. And here I respectfully disagree. I don't want my jury to be a bunch of people just like me I want a jury of people who will listen to and evaluate the evidence, deliberate with the other jurors, find out points of view that differ from their own by virtue of other people's life experiences, and come to an agreement on the verdict. Now, imagine the practical problems of this in the typical American city. Imagine what the polling would have to be like to find all of the very basic requirements. And...
tracking img