Joy Luck Club Novel vs Movie

Only available on StudyMode
  • Download(s) : 389
  • Published : October 17, 2008
Open Document
Text Preview
The Joy Luck Club; an intriguing novel and movie about the hardships about being a Chinese

immigrant to America soon after the immigration ban was lifted. A challenging story that forced the

reader to try to understand that certain customs and traditions that were seen as 'usual' can be very

unlike the ones we as Americans are used to. A story where, even though it lacked a lot of violence,

action, or suspense it still was able to grab its readers and viewers.

With a little bit of her own experiences tied into the story, we learn the 'fictional' story of four

Chinese mothers (Lindo Jong, Suyuan Woo, Ying-ying St. Clair, An-Mei Hsu) and their daughters, all

American born (Rose Hsu Jordan, Jing-mei Woo, Waverly Jong, Lena St. Clair). In a feudal China, the

four mothers decided to avoid having their future children live in such a traumatic country and thus

decide to move to San Francisco's China Town. Yet, as similar as the stories should be, small

differences between novel and movie can always be found.

The main difference between the novel and the movie is the overall feel for it. If you watched the

movie and then read the book you might have seen how the book was able to keep an intriguing, and

even 'dark' feel as we can feel the words jumping out at us as a tense moment arises. While in the

movie, these 'moments of despair' seemed to arise quickly and pass over just as fast. We saw that in

most detail when it came to death.

In the novel, we are told a story of anger, of hate, a woman scorned. We are told a story of a

cheating husband and a feeling of having absolutely no way out. We can feel how her walls were

closing in all around her as she desperately searched for a way out. Can you imagine how far gone

your mindset has to be where the only escape is to kill your own child? How something so cruel and

inhumane is treated as a way out? In the novel we can feel the decline of happiness until she ultimately

performs a makeshift abortion. While in the movie we see signs of trouble, but not captured as well as

it could've been that ultimately ended with a babies last bath.

Another case of where the novel vividly describes certain things that the movie just can't do is the story of An-Mei's scar. In the novel we figure out early on that An-Mei's mother who is to remain

nameless decided to run off and be with a man and become one of his concubines. This act is seen as

dishonorable by the family and they run her off. One night during dinner An-Mei's mother returns

looking to see her daughter. Tempers fly, words are shouted, tables are overturned and with that

scalding hot soup covers An-Mei's neck.

In the movie however, it is a simple argument between An-Mei's Uncle and Aunt. Yet, as different as

it was it was still effective in showing that customs in China are very different than what 'we' as

Americans see as customary and what is pushing boundaries. The scene in the movie, complete with

abuse, shows how feudal and violent China could be even under peacetime. In that sense, the scene

served its purpose, but still could've been elaborated on a little bit more.

Yet, sometimes a few changes to a novel has to be made to be sure the movie covers as much as

possible without going over the alloted time. Especially when dealing with a segment that can take a

few minutes to fully describe. Such as the significance of a 'red candle.' This is apart of Lindo's story

that revolves around her 'first' marriage. A burning red candle that can last a whole night without

extinguishing before it was supposed to was to signify eternal happiness and bliss. A servant that was

ordered to watch the candle throughout the night had to leave the room because of a misunderstanding

between a thunderstorm and an attack by the Japanese. After all, the roar of thunder sounds like...
tracking img