Preview

Jared Diamond. “the Worst Mistake in the History of the Human Race” Review

Satisfactory Essays
Open Document
Open Document
358 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Jared Diamond. “the Worst Mistake in the History of the Human Race” Review
Jared Diamond. “The Worst Mistake in the History of the Human Race”
Jared Diamond writes about the consequences of agriculture on the human race. He suggests that the earliest farming societies did not have an easier more productive lifestyle than hunter-gatherer societies, contrary to popular belief. For example, the Kalahari Bushmen spend a mere average of 12 to 19 hours a week to getting food, and on average sleep a lot, work less hard, and have more free time than people in hunter-gatherer societies. Another consequence agriculture had on humans is their diets. Hunter-gatherers eat many various wild plants and animals; therefore, they have better nutrition than farmers who generally only eat the limited variety of crops they produce. For example, the Kalahari Bushmen’s daily intake was 2,140 calories and 93 grams of protein, whereas farmers gave up good nutritional crops for cheap calories found in their starchy crops.
In my own opinion, I believe that Diamond’s paper is for the most part skewed for the reason that he has a great anti-progressivist bias. Whenever Diamond makes a direct comparison between farming and hunter-gatherer societies, he shows all the positives for hunter-gatherer and the negatives for farmer societies. For example, when Diamond is comparing the nutrition of the two societies, he talks about the balance of nutrients and diet, he mentions that the Kalahari Bushmen eat a variety of over 75 different wild plants and receive more calories than needed. On the other hand, he mentions the fact that thousands of Irish farmers died during the potato famine during the 1840’s. Another example of how Diamond’s bias towards the gatherer side affects the paper is when he tries to compare the Bushmen to the Ethiopian farmers. The comparison is trying to show that being a gatherer is a better choice by comparing Kalahari Bushmen to the Ethiopian farmers. This is not an equal comparison because he uses the Kalahari Bushmen who are apparently above

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    1 Agricultural Revolution

    • 692 Words
    • 2 Pages

    It’s important to note that cultivation of crops seems to have arisen independently over the course of millennia; using crops that naturally grew nearby—_______ in Southeast Asia, _____________ in Mexico, _____________ in the Andes, _____________ in the Fertile Crescent, _____________ in West Africa —people around the world began to abandon their foraging for agriculture.…

    • 692 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    In almost every culture, one of the most cherished pass times is food. We eat to sustain or health, to celebrate, to morn, and sometimes just to do it. Yet, how often do we question were that food comes from? Most everyone purchases their meals from the grocery store or at a restaurant but have you ever wondered where that juicy steak grazed? How about how those crisp vegetables? Where were those grown? The Omnivore 's Dilemma, by Michael Pollan, analyzes the eating habits and food chains of modern America in an attempt to bring readers closer to the origin of their foods. Not only where it comes from, but where it all begins, as well as what it takes to keep all of those plants and animals in production. In part two of the Omnivore’s Dilemma: Pastoral: Grass, Pollan gives background on what all produce and livestock need to be the best it can be. As simple as it may sound, it starts with the grass. Yet, Pollan makes it very clear it’s not always as simple as it sounds. After starting The Omnivore’s Dilemma I had a few expectations. Firstly, I enjoy a blend of humor and philosophy; I want what I read to make me think, for the words to flow nicely from one completely thought to the next, and for the overall of the chapters to hold my attention.…

    • 1316 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Guns, Germs, and Steel, Jared Diamond opposed the idea that European civilizations have advanced further than their contemporaries in other continents because their inhabitants were intellectually superior. Instead, he supported the notion that some civilizations developed at a quicker pace than others because of the environmental differences that were present in the continents where they resided. Factors such as wildlife, climate, and the types of resources presented in an area have dramatically affected the growth and development of hunter-gatherer groups into villages, and eventually, nations. In places where the environmental conditions were not ideal, the inhabitants were not able to advance as far as other civilizations. Diamond disproved…

    • 1221 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Jared Diamond’s two most persuasive statements are that Hunter-gatherers were much healthier than those who practiced early agriculture and that there was less social conflict before the Neolithic Revolution. For example, hunter-gatherers had a longer life span, larger average height in both genders, as well as more varied and nutritional food. This is important because our health as a species had taken a dip, and even though it is slowly being built up again (in some areas), the nutrition intake of hunter-gatherers was significantly more beneficial. Next, evidence of more issues in society in the post-agricultural communities include that of a social class division along with more frequent pregnancies (which has led to more fatalities). The…

    • 166 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the text, An Edible History of Humanity, Tom Standage provides his take on how the past was so deeply affected by food throughout the generations. The book approaches history in a different way altogether: as a sequence of changes caused, influenced or enabled by food. Standage explains that throughout history, food has not only provided sustenance but has also acted as the catalyst of societal organization, social change, economic expansion, military conflict, geopolitical competition and industrial development. As Tom Standage explains, since the time of prehistory to present, the facts surrounding these changes form a documentary that encompasses the entire human history.…

    • 1136 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Suprising at it may seem, more people suffer from malnutrion now than they used to. Farmers tend to only plant and harvest high-carbohydrate crops such as rice and potatoes due to their ability to grow in large quanties. They can make a greater profit off of products like these. Since we all now depend upon these farmers to provide our societies with food, we do not have as varied a diet as previous hunter-gatherer societies. To qoute the article directly, "when they swtiched to farming, they traded quantity for quailtity." This is an evident fact. Crops which produce larger quantities of food are more likely to be planted than those which may be healthier options.…

    • 555 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    malnutritioned, growth stunted, has brevity of life and a number of other things; he says that…

    • 1069 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Jared Diamond based his argument around points such as studies on the welfare of current hunters and gatherers, the varying detriments of agriculture—as discovered by Paleopathologists in remains of ancient man—and their affects on the pioneers of agriculture, and the practice of making women “Beasts of Burden” to show inequality between the sexes. He began all his points by opening with a fact or question pro-agriculture then countering it with a fact of his own, grouping his information together to support his counter statements.…

    • 362 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Michael Pollan’s, The Omnivores Dilemma everything we eat is somehow derived from corn. Dating back to the day of the Mayans when they were sometimes referred to as “the corn people” (Pollan 19). Pollan takes us back to the “beginning” of the industrial food chain. In The Omnivores Dilemma historical context, ideology, and setting do not do the reader justice in opening their eyes to the harsh reality that without the corn industry eating as we know it today would cease to exist.…

    • 684 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Jared Diamond makes a compelling case for why “the adoption of agriculture was in many ways a catastrophe” in his 1987 Discover Magazine article “The Worst Mistake in the History of the Human Race,” however I am not convinced. An Agricultural Revolution is a “significant change in agriculture that occurs when there are discoveries, inventions, or new technologies that change production” (The Editors of Encyclopedia Britannica, 2015) and the development of agriculture has been a fundamental part of the march of civilization. The Agricultural Revolution was not a catastrophe from which we have never recovered, it was the groundwork for the rise of civilization. Cynthia Stokes Brown, author of Big History- From The Big Bang To The Present states…

    • 993 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The Worst Mistake

    • 450 Words
    • 2 Pages

    When people transitioned from hunter-gatherers to agriculturist, life became to change. Some people believe that transitioning from hunter-gatherers to agriculturists was one of the best decisions the human race has made. Jared Diamond the author of “The Worst Mistake in the History of the Human Race” believes that life changed for the worst. Diamond also believes we never recovered from the agriculturist mistake.…

    • 450 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In Hardin's " Tragedy of the Commons," and Diamonds, "The World as Polder: What Does it Mean to Us Today?," One can see how Hardin's main points relate to Diamonds, because both dissect the unsustainable aspects of our society. Both authors use different methods to get their point across, however their main points are very similar. Although Diamond closely looks at past societal collapses, and what aspects of their society caused their collapses, Hardin's current view of the modern worlds unsustainable population, has many characteristic to the older society's that Diamond discusses in his essay. For example Hardin look at our increasing population and how we are over indulging in our resources, that will soon run out if we're not careful. While on the other hand, Diamond describes how over population was a major reason for the Easter Islanders collapse.…

    • 200 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Best Essays

    Geoengineering paper

    • 2593 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Brown, R. Lester. 2009. “Could Food Shortages bring down Civilization?”. Scientific America. May 2009: 50)…

    • 2593 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    When I first heard about Diamond's theory It made perfect sense, maybe everything we have today in different parts of the world has to do with where our ancestors were before us. However, after reading some criticisms I realized that it’s much more complex than that and a larger scale some things don’t add up. Diamond claims that civilizations advancements were based entirely on geographic luck. He mainly focuses on the edge the East-West axis has on the North-South, but this is too simple, Professor J.R. Mcneill says that “different parts of Eurasia at similar latitudes have very different climates.” Yes, Latitude matters, but not just latitude, because climates have to come into play.…

    • 522 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Agriculture is the production of food and goods through farming and forestry . Agriculture was the key development that led to the rise of human civilization, with the husbandry of domesticated animals and plants creating food surpluses that enabled the development of more densely populated and stratified societies. The study of agriculture is known as agricultural science. Agriculture encompasses a wide variety of specialties and techniques, including ways to expand the lands suitable for plant raising, by digging water-channels and other forms of irrigation. Cultivation of crops on arable land and the pastoral herding of livestock on range land remain at the foundation of agriculture. In the past century there has been increasing concern to identify and quantify various forms of agriculture. In the developed world the range usually extends between sustainable agriculture (e.g. permaculture or organic agriculture) and intensive farming (e.g. industrial agriculture).Modern agronomy, plant breeding, pesticides and fertilizers, and technological improvements have sharply increased yields from cultivation, and at the same time have caused widespread ecological damage and negative human health effects. Selective breeding and modern practices in animal husbandry such as intensive pig farming (and similar practices applied to the chicken)have similarly increased the output of meat, but have raised concerns about animal cruelty and the health effects of the antibiotics, growth hormones, and other chemicals commonly used in industrial meat production.…

    • 372 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays