Credit creation and control: an unresolved issue in Islamic banking Zubair Hasan
Department of Economics, Faculty of Economics and Management Sciences, International Islamic University Malaysia, Selangor, Malaysia Abstract
Purpose – To reopen for discussion the issue of credit creation and control in the area of Islamic banking. Design/methodology/approach – In view of a rapid expansion of Islamic banking in recent decades, the answer to questions whether Islamic banks can create credit like mainstream banks and, if yes, what methods central banks could use to control it in their case is of paramount importance. An overview of the literature on the subject is provided and credit creation process is explained as background material for the discussion. Findings – The literature on the subject is scanty, controversial and inconclusive. One reason seems to be the mismatch between structural design of Islamic banks and the objectives they are supposed to meet. It is concluded that Islamic banks can create credit in the usual manner but central banks will have to design new tools for credit control applicable to Islamic banks. Research limitations/implications – It is not a rigorous analytical exercise as the main purpose of the paper is to reopen an important issue for discussion. It is an opinioned work and presents rather tentative answers to the questions raised. Practical implications – The ﬁndings of the paper may have serious implications for the current structure of Islamic banks and the legal framework for regulating their credit creation activities. Originality/value – The paper draws attention to a rather neglected issue in Islamic banking and offers guidelines to resolve it. Keywords Islam, Banking, Credit control, Fiscal policy Paper type Conceptual paper
Credit creation and control
1. Introduction Commercial banks are essentially dealers in credit. Interest is the price that guides them in making business decision. They were initially started as institutions for meeting the short-term credit requirements of trade industry and commerce and it remains their primary function even today. In view of that requirement, the legal framework never put restrictions on the credit creation power of these banks. However, legislation did require the central bank of each country to oversee and control that power so that it may not be used to the detriment of social well-being. Islamic banks were conceived of to be organized on the same structural pattern as conventional banks. The use of interest alone was to be eliminated from their operations (Siddiqi, 1983). The choice unwittingly became source of much confusion at the conceptual level and led the progress of these banks in some wrong directions The author is grateful to his Research Assistant Ms Sarabdeen Masahina, a post-graduate student in the faculty, for her valuable help in the writing of this paper.
International Journal of Islamic and Middle Eastern Finance and Management Vol. 1 No. 1, 2008 pp. 69-81 q Emerald Group Publishing Limited 1753-8394 DOI 10.1108/17538390810864269
(Hasan, 2005, p. 22). In Islamic banking the abolition of interest, the insistence on sharing business risks with the owners, the longer lock-in of investment funds and the social responsibilities the system is supposed to shoulder raise some ticklish issues that its structural constraints could rarely help resolve. The misdoing raises many puzzling questions relating to credit creation. Can Islamic banks in the ﬁrst place create credit like the conventional banks to enhance their earnings? If yes, what must replace interest as price for the funds they would provide to their customers? How would the central bank put, if need be, a tab on their credit creation activities from a social viewpoint? Shall it be using the same weapons for the purpose in...