Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Introduction

Good Essays
2116 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Introduction
INTRODUCTION
The economic contraction in the 1930s, propelled by the collapse of the economies in industrialised states, had a ripple effect on the small vulnerable economies of the Caribbean. During the 1930s, the region started to experience economic recessions due to a decline in exports. The repercussions were even greater for those countries locked into monocrop production and dependent on the trade relations that existed between them and the developed countries of Europe and the U.S. The Caribbean countries had become so dependent on the foreign markets that from the onset of the Depression they suffered many of the symptoms experienced by industrialised countries. Between 1928 and 1933 the prices of West Indian exports were on average almost halved, which contributed to; forced wage reductions, increased taxation and unemployment.
A general understanding of the severity of the impact of the Great Depression on Caribbean territories may be illustrated through a description of the conditions in Jamaica. During the 1930s Jamaica was undoubtedly the most economically developed of all the English-speaking Caribbean countries. Its geographical layout covered 4,450 square miles, and a comparative assessment with other countries in the region placed Jamaica among the largest and most affluent with its bountiful resources. While other territories depended exclusively on sugar, cocoa or citrus, whose prices had dwindled considerably during the late 1920s, Jamaica could count also on her bananas. Arthur Lewis states that bananas accounted for 55 per cent of the value of domestic exports, while sugar accounted for 18 per cent. Jamaica was able to combat the impact of falling sugar prices due to the cushioning effect the export of bananas had on the economy. Nonetheless, the sugar industry, though not the highest earner, was the greatest employer, and the problems of the industry affected the entire country.
The general consensus is that the Great Depression was very pronounced and affected every member of the Jamaican society. A considerable amount of literature about the 1930s has consistently shown that the decade was a defining period in the history of Jamaica. However, most scholars, including Richard Hart and Arthur Lewis have only focused on the labour rebellions and their impact on the social and political transformations in Jamaica, with little reference to women. Furthermore, they have tended to over-generalize, and the social disequilibrium in the country shows that the experiences of various groups were not uniform. There were great variations. Those who belonged in the upper echelon of society continued to engage in their ‘high society’ activities while the middle and lower-classes struggled to achieve bargaining rights along with political and economic enfranchisement. The situation of the lower-class remained constant and deteriorated as the government did little to remedy their situation. Limited access to social mobility, restricted emigration along with unemployment and underemployment, which resulted in widespread poverty, further exacerbated the plight of the lower-class. According to the Royal Commission Report, “The position of women [however, was] more unfortunate.” They were no doubt the first to be targeted once the economy started to feel the strain of the Depression. Moreover, women’s roles continued to depend on the Victorian ideals which restricted them to certain types of occupations such as domestic servant or agricultural labourer, which Barry Chevannes classifies as “female work.”
So far, little attention has been paid to women’s experiences and their responses during this period in Jamaica. In fact, no single study exists which adequately covers the experience of women in Jamaica during that period. To date, scholars who have conducted studies on women (and have taken this time period into their study) often refer to them as one group and their diverse experiences are not always emphasized. Although women in general were subjected to underemployment and unemployment, little is known about the effects of the Depression on lower-class women.
Far too little is known about the ways women responded to the economic crisis. Even though the focus of their work is not specific to the effects of the Depression on women, historians such as Barry Higman, Michelle Johnson and Brian Moore reveal that the educational level of black, lower-class women restricted them to low paying and intermittent occupations including agricultural labour and domestic service. In their independent research on domestic service in Jamaica, Higman and Johnson show that between 1921 and 1943 there was a significant increase in female domestic servants, especially in Kingston. However, a detailed explanation for the reasons many women relocated to occupy work in domestic service in Kingston was not given. The focus is mainly on the pull factors including better wages and a demand for domestic servants rather than push factors such as irregular employment in the agricultural sector. Ken Post and Gisela Eisner, however highlight that irregular employment in agriculture along modernisation of the sugar industry forced many to the towns.
Migration has been generally viewed as a strategy used to adjust to periods of crisis. In The Population of Jamaica, George Roberts shows that between 1921 and 1943 a significant number of women migrated from one parish to another. Still, the historiography remains silent about the class to which those women belonged. Although Roberts’ work does not reveal the class females belonged to, the works of Eisner and Post, on aspects of the 1930s suggest that a significant number of them belonged to the lower-class.
Joan French and Honor Ford-Smith however, show that lower-class women established a variety of coping mechanisms in order to overcome the economic conditions. Interviews conducted by French and Ford-Smith illustrate that these strategies ranged from extending work obligations to children, to higglering. According to Gisela Eisner there was a preponderance of female higglers. Despite the number of women who were concentrated in this area it is difficult to state whether or not it was a coping mechanism as higglering had always been common source of revenue that emerged during slavery.
In recent years there has been an increasing interest in the contribution of women in protests during the period. However, when the 1930s is revisited, the focus is particularly on the 1938 Frome Riot. Although Ahmed Reid shows the presence of women in the labour rebellions in 1938, his focus was only on their militancy – throwing stones and marching with sticks. French and Ford-Smith however, show that many women also went on strike and demanded more pay. And, although Reid shows that the historiography has consistently placed men as the emerging figures, he also followed the historiographic trend by focussing on prominent women including Lady Gladys Bustamante and Agnes ‘Aggie’ Bernard. He also failed to state that although the names of other women were not identified, they too played a role by supplying food and water to the strikers at the waterfront.

Purpose of the Study
Comparisons are being inevitably made between today and the 1930s. During the 1930s Jamaica was in social and economic turmoil. The turmoil was caused by a world-wide economic depression, the ruin of the banana industry, falling sugar prices, growing unemployment aggravated by the restriction of migration opportunities and a steeply rising population. The situation therefore presented challenges to Jamaican people, especially women.
Today, there is a similar picture as women are being faced with the challenge of overcoming the economic and social deterioration of Jamaica. Women’s resourcefulness in times of crisis has been part of the history of Caribbean people. To continue to rely on the exploitation of women in this way is to perpetuate the conditions which have prevented the full development of the country. In order to understand the problems which we are currently facing it is imperative that we highlight the strategies which were employed in the past. In fact,
“Studies of women in society are needed to help women […] to understand and clarify their past and present situations as well as to lead to a more balanced equation of the roles of women in their societies.”
There is a gap in the history of women in Jamaica due to little research done on the 1930s. It is most appropriate to focus on women as they played a vital role in the historical development of Jamaica. Focussing on women’s experiences during this period helps to provide answers that we not only want to know but also profit from knowing by giving us a better perspective of the present situation. And, it is this which has prompted the researcher to focus on the 1930s crisis and the impact it had on women in Jamaica.
This research seeks to investigate the extent to which the economic crisis contributed to the changing role of women during the 1930s. The particular focus of this study is on lower-class women in the Jamaican labour force and the strategies they employed to cope with the economic crisis during the 1930s. The aim of the study is to determine whether or not their status deteriorated and to see if the economic crisis significantly altered the roles of lower-class women.

Sources and Methodology
The reader should bear in mind that this research is interpretive and exploratory in nature. As such, a variety of primary and secondary sources including reports, journals, newspapers, and books were used to examine the effects of the Great Depression on women.
This study relies heavily on labour statistics. However, due to practical constraints, the paper cannot provide a comprehensive interpretation of statistics for the 1930s. This is due to the fact that no census was taken during the decade. As a result, I have had to rely on the censuses of 1921 and 1943 to interpret statistics for the 1930s. Even so, the imprecise categorisation of females in employment appears to be underestimated. Despite the problem of categorisation, the Census reports are used to show the changing role of females in the workforce over time.
Note also that two unemployment surveys conducted during the 1930s focused only on Kingston and St. Andrew and reveal that the ‘genuinely’ unemployed were males. Officials claim that these statistics were limited to the city due to the fact that collecting data for the whole island was too challenging a proposition. In addition, the Blue Book for the Island of Jamaica (1930 – 1935) provides a wide range of data on the population, employment, wages and criminal statistics. Nonetheless, there is an issue of reliability as the statistics remained unchanged for some categories over a six year period. These statistics are used in this study, however, to compare with other sources to determine if they provide the same information that will aid in our understanding of the effects of the economic crisis on women.
Surveys conducted by H. P. Jacobs and E. P. Carter are also used also give an insight on lower-class women and the economic conditions. However, these statistics were specific to 1938. Despite this shortfall, the authors show that wages were not sufficient to purchase basic foodstuffs during the 1930s. The surveys also reveal that women, particularly banana carriers, were employed part-time and had to supplement their income. Consequently, a qualitative approach has to be taken to supplement the gaps in female labour statistics for the 1930s.
Various newspapers of the time including the Gleaner, Plain Talk, Public Opinion and the Jamaica Standard are utilized in the study to ascertain the ways women responded to the economic crisis. It should be noted however, that it was the experience of working-class women that was aired. Moreover, the writers tend to address women in general although there is evidence that their focus was rarely on the plight of the lower-class. Despite class biases, newspaper accounts, particularly letters to the editor, help to give the opinion of persons of the time while at the same time preserving some truth based on the frequency of similar concerns in numerous articles. These accounts provide a vast amount of information which is unattainable in any other source.
Oral history has also proved beneficial in filling the gap. Newspaper accounts and official government statistics are juxtaposed with the eye-witness accounts given in interviews presented in Not for Wages Alone. Although the interviews were specific to 1938, they give additional perspective on the conditions in the decade as some interviewees extended their recounts to the entire decade. These stories corroborate those presented in newspapers.
The aim of this study is not to criticise the validity of labour force statistics. The use of the statistics is imperative to the study as they help to fill the gap and add to the historiography. As such, they provide the basis to investigate whether or not the economic crisis affected the role of women, particularly those in the lower-class.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    This paper I am writing is concerned with the economic considerations of a South American country and shall analyze the impact of an economic concern as followed on this particular South American country that I have chosen and I will identify the trend of the economic concern with the specified region and basis of data sets that accumulated from the source. The South American countries have a major impact on the American Economy and the concern of one particular country raised our bodies of knowledge regarding the economic trend involved in the particular country and was found to have its impact on overall economy as well.…

    • 1412 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Summary Of Life And Debt

    • 718 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Film brought up different sceneries of the how did the Jamaican economic was destroyed by foreign products of rich country when the out of desperate, former prime minister was in signed a loan agreement to International monetary fund (IMF) that led Jamaica to billions of dollars in debt. Under loan agreement, there was no tax on foreign products; so massive flooding of cheap foreign products dominated the Jamaican local business. This led to increased unemployment, dependency on other countries for basic foods and Jamaican was fallen even worse…

    • 718 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The businesses of British manufacturers also declined because the taxes minimized the colonists’ purchasing power. The Sugar Act ruined the economy of Britain and the colonies. It significantly reduced foreign trade and distorted the stability of colonial currencies. Since money was not being exchanged, the currency value deflated. The decrease in value meant colonies had to spend more money to buy goods. This influenced the loss of island trade partners such as Haiti and the Canary Islands, causing a global economic recession (“The Sugar Act”). Not only did the instability of the colonial currencies affect foreign countries, it also had a negative impact on British sellers because the colonists had to pay more for their goods. In addition, buyers from outside Britain had no motivation to purchase their goods since the colonists were not trading with them. The Sugar Act ultimately hindered the financial recovery of…

    • 1415 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    After recovering from World War One which had ended in 1918, America was enjoying the wealth and prosperity achieved through the economic boom. People greatly valued materialism, hedonism and partying. This period of time is most commonly known as ‘The Roaring Twenties’. But with the prosperity of the 1920s came the downfall of the American economy, the Wall Street Crash of 1929. There were many causes for the stock market crash but some of the main causes were people buying stocks through loans which caused the value of the stocks to decrease and overproduction of goods which lead to a loss of profit. Overproduction heavily influenced the farming industry as there were too many crops to sell which had decreased its value. The situation had gotten worst when America was hit by a drought which resulted in many farmers migrating to find work.…

    • 1828 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Great Depression In Canada

    • 1689 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Canada’s dependence on the sale of exports and natural resources in the 1920s was another underlying cause of the Great Depression. Due to their optimism of the future many businesses had overproduced their goods and began to stockpile them in warehouses. In the late 1920s they realized that there was not enough demand for their products. Suddenly, there was less demand for Canadian natural resources because factories in other countries using those resources had huge stockpiles of goods and started producing less. Since these foreign factories had huge stockpiles of goods they no longer needed to purchase natural resources from Canada until they had sold all of their stockpiled goods. The government soon raised tariffs on foreign imported goods to protect Canadian businesses and their workers. They did this so that imported products would cost more than domestic goods, causing Canadian consumers to buy domestic goods over the foreign goods due to the price difference,…

    • 1689 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    -Major ports in Caribbean, but it became colonial backwater until sugar and slaves allowed resurgence…

    • 3240 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Life and Debt analysis

    • 476 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Life and Debt is a very insightful and revealing documentary about the economy woes of Jamaica and the possible causes of its economic down turn. Watching this documentary, I was in shock because I have always known Jamaica had economic issues, but I never knew how bad they were. Jamaica suffers from poverty, a struggling economy, inflation and interference from outside investors like the United States of America and Latin America despite being richly blessed with natural resources and agriculture. Jamaica got their independence in 1962 from the United Kingdom, it has always struggled with its economy and even tried to use its agricultural resources to boost the economy, but to no avail. As the economy became more and more severely immersed in financial problems, the then Prime Minister Michael Manley struck a deal in 1977 with a group of economic institutions like World Bank and IMF to loan money to Jamaica in exchange for removal of trade restrictions and subsidized exports. Twenty five years down the line, it is sad to see that Jamaica is in debt to the tune of seven billion dollars to the IMF. The deal ruined Jamaica’s economy, and Stanley Fischer (second in command at IMF) is interviewed throughout the documentary and he defends the deal, with reasons why it was a good idea at the time and how beneficial the deal was to the Jamaican economy, even though we can see different in the documentary. The deal with the IMF disrupted the Islands agricultural and industrial economy, thereby causing the economy to nose-dive. Farming, agriculture, cultivation and dairy production has become almost non-existent. Markets have being seized and policies put in places which are extremely unfavorably to the locals. There is mass interference from growers and merchants in the US and Latin America over the growth of fruits and vegetables, which are now imported by the aforementioned. This makes imports more expensive than the local produce (if any), the country has become a…

    • 476 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    To begin with, the Great Depression of 1929, mainly impacted our economy. The main product our country produced was coffee, and the economy mainly depended on the exports of that. Coffee was 70% of the country’s revenue, and once…

    • 383 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Life And Debt Summary

    • 653 Words
    • 3 Pages

    This paper aims to explore the elements as shown in the documentary Life and Debt. The core theme of this documentary is to point out and highlight the impacts of globalization, international lending, and free trade, implication of different policies as doctored by various powerful institutions such as the international monetary fund together with superpower nations such as the USA, on minor and underdeveloped nations such as Jamaica. The documentary has been finely directed and in my perception is an excellent medium to depict how the strategies adopted by the Jamaican people for survival in their daily lives are actually influenced by the US and the other economic institutions.…

    • 653 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    During the Great Depression of the 1930's, Canada's Prairie provinces suffered more than any other area in Canada. This time frame brought for the farmers many years of droughts and grasshopper plagues, as each year got worse without any rainfall whatsoever. The impact of the Great Depression on the Prairie provinces was devastating and it's impact on the region was social, political and economical. During this period unemployment reached high levels, prices of products were falling and purchasing power was getting very weak. To try to help out unemployed people, mostly men, the government introduced relief camps. During the 1930's in Prairie Canada, the Great Depression created harsh conditions and it was a struggle until it ended. The event which triggered the Great Depression was the Stock Market crash of October 24, 1929 in New York. Another important cause was that: Later in the 1930's, the wide adoption of the gold exchange in many countries was widely criticized as a great mistake which greatly contributed to the severity and length of the Great Depression. 1 In Canada, wheat, the most important export, was being over-produced around the world, despite the fact that the 1928 supply of wheat was still available in 1929. A good reason for the stock market crash in 1929 was that, the values of stocks of the New York Stock Exchange were grossly over-valued, but government and business appeared to ignore the signs. 2 Canadian revenues that came in from export sales were dependent largely upon the United States who had the money for growth; the commodities were grain, pulp and paper and metals. Then when the New York crashed on October 1929, stock prices fell dramatically. When the stock market crashed, the Canadian economy suffered after the United States invoked high tariffs to shut out Canadian goods. In the Prairie provinces of Canada, in addition to economic depression was the effect of the nine years of drought and crop failures. When the Great Depression…

    • 2887 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    With millions unemployed, thousands on the verge of suicide and many resorting to crime for sustenance, surely the effects of the recessions were more pronounced on African Americans. The recession (a) of the early 1930’s started in late 1929 (October) and lasted till 1941. It had such huge repercussions on the daily life in general and on the field of Economics in particular that it came to be known as The Great Depression later on. The current recession started in 2007 and matches the great depression in magnanimity. The recessions adversely affected people from all walks of life and ethnic orientations, making the survival of the masses, African Americans in particular, extremely difficult if not impossible. Even though both recessions were similar in terms of high unemployment, the reasons for this high unemployment in Africans Americans and the way government dealt with their hardships in both eras differed substantially.…

    • 1374 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    “Canada was especially hit hard by the Depression because its economy had developed very quickly between 1900 and 1929 causing it to have a certain weakness that made it vulnerable to any sudden downturn in the world economy.” The Great Depression lasted ten gruesome years,1929 to 1939, during which time, counties all over the world, including Canada, experienced job loss,…

    • 1214 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Best Essays

    Wallich, Henry Christopher. Monetary problems of an export economy; the Cuban experience, 1914-1947.. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1950. Print.…

    • 2598 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    Gross domestic product fell by 27 percent from 1929 to 1933. Simultaneously, prices fell about one-quarter. Gross investment fell by 98 percent. “The impact of this depression was not confined to the United States, although it took the brunt of the effects” (“Great Depression,” 2005). Trade also dropped with an even greater magnitude (“Great Depression,” 2005).…

    • 756 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Leading up to the riots Barbados’ economy was in a dreadful state due to many different factors, both internal and external. One of the more substantial external factors was The Great Depression of the 1930’s which originated in the United States of America but affected all the countries of the world. On October 29, 1929 the American stock market crashed and officially started The Great Depression. This had a kind of domino effect across the world. Firstly, the collapse of the stock market caused a significant drop in the value of stock which caused many businesses to go bankrupt since no one would buy the stock. Since banks had invested most of their clients’ money in the stock market, when it crashed many banks were forced to close. This threw the masses into a frenzy in which those lucky enough to reach their bank before it closed withdrew all their money. This massive cash withdrawal from the banks caused the banks to close. Those who didn’t make it in time went bankrupt. The next place affected by the economic turmoil was the working sector. In an attempt to make up for the lost capital as a result of the stock market crash businesses started to cut wages, which were already low to begin with. Even with these new wage cuts some businesses still ended up having to close and layoff their workers. Unemployment saw a surge due to this and also made existing conditions such as malnutrition. Overall The Great Depression set the scene for the black populous of Barbados who was ready to do whatever it took to improve their situation.…

    • 2884 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays