If Hitler Asked You to Electrocute a Stranger

Topics: Stanford prison experiment, Milgram experiment, Electric shock Pages: 19 (6499 words) Published: October 31, 2011
if Hitler asked You to Electrocute a Stranger

would you?
In the beginning, Stanley Milgram was worried about the Nazi problem. He doesn’t worry much about the Nazis anymore. He worries about you and me, and, perhaps, himself a little bit too. Stanley Milgram is a social psychologist, and when he began his career at Yale University in 1960 he had a plan to prove, scientifically, that Germans

Philip Meyer

© Philip Meyer. Originally published in Esquire, February 1970. artwork © Michael Leonard, courtesy of Forum Gallery, New York

are different. The Germans-aredifferent hypothesis has been used by historians, such as William L. Shirer, to explain the systematic destruction of the Jews by the Third Reich. One madman could decide to destroy the Jews and even create a master plan for getting it done. But to implement it on the scale that Hitler did meant that thousands of other people had to go along with the scheme and help to do the work. The Shirer thesis, which Milgram set out to test, is that Germans have a basic character flaw which explains the whole thing, and this flaw is a readiness to obey authority without question, no matter what outrageous acts the authority commands. The appealing thing about this theory is that it makes those of us who are not Germans feel better about the whole business. Obviously, you and I are not Hitler, and it seems equally obvious that we would never do Hitler's dirty work for him. But now, because of Stanley Milgram, we are compelled to wonder. Milgram developed a laboratory experiment which provided a systematic way to measure obedience. His plan was to try it out in New Haven on Americans and then go to Germany and try it out on Germans. He was strongly motivated by scientific curiosity, but there was also some moral content in his decision to pursue this line of research, which was, in turn, colored by his own Jewish background. If he could show that

Germans are more obedient than Americans, he could then vary the conditions of the experiment and try to find out just what it is that makes some people more obedient than others. With this understanding, the world might, conceivably, be just a little bit better. But he never took his experiment to Germany. He never took it any farther than Bridgeport. The first finding, also the most unexpected and disturbing finding, was that we Americans are an obedient people: not blindly obedient, and not blissfully obedient, just obedient. “I found so much obedience,” says Milgram softly, a little sadly, “I hardly saw the need for taking the experiment to Germany.”

a lot of the script just to get people to stop obeying. They were obeying so much, the experiment wasn’t working - it was like trying to measure oven temperature with a freezer thermometer. The experiment worked like

The experimenter, as though he were God, can change a prop here, vary a line there, and see how the subject responds.

here is something of the theatre director in Milgram, and his technique, which he learned from one of the old masters in experimental psychology, Solomon Asch, is to stage a play with every line rehearsed, every prop carefully selected, and everybody an actor except one person. That one person is the subject of the experiment. The subject, of course, does not know he is in a play. He thinks he is in real life. The value of this technique is that the experimenter, as though he were God, can change a prop here, vary a line there, and see how the subject responds. Milgram eventually had to change


this: If you were an innocent subject in Milgram’s melodrama, you read an ad in the newspaper or received one in the mail asking for volunteers for an educational experiment. The job would take about an hour and pay $4.50. So you make an appointment and go to an old Romanesque stone structure on High Street with the imposing name of The Yale Interaction Laboratory. It looks something like a broadcasting studio. Inside, you meet a young,...
Continue Reading

Please join StudyMode to read the full document

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Hitler Asked You to Electrocute a Stranger, Would You? Probably Research Paper
  • If Hitler Asked You to Electrocute a Stranger, Would You? Probably Essay
  • The Stranger Essay
  • the stranger Essay
  • The Stranger Essay
  • Strangers Essay
  • The Stranger Essay
  • Stranger Essay

Become a StudyMode Member

Sign Up - It's Free