I like that we are allowed to have some land still but that’s about it. They are trying to take most of our land away and sell it to their people. The European Americans are trying to break up our tribes, encourage individual initiatives, further the progress of native farmers, reduce the cost of our labor, and Euro Americanize us. We have traditional beliefs and ideologies about our land and our existence and their trying to change everything about us. I don’t think it should pass, because it will destroy our culture that we know, and change us into something we are not. Our people will ultimately suffer because the whites will be quick to say one thing and next thing you know we’ve been lied too. They want us to shed and exchange everything we know and become industrialized self supporting farmers and citizens just like the Euro Americans, and that’s not who we are. I hope this Act does not pass.
Situation #2:
As an Indian Reformer I think the Dawes Act is a great thing. I do not believe it is a product of greed because we are friends with the Indians and I believe it is a step toward the Indians into Euro American culture. I don’t think Indians would ever bridge between their ways and Euro American civilization if they maintained their tribal unity and traditional ways. With this act they will get to learn better ways to survive, farm the proper way, improve livelihood, become educated and learn Christianity. It may take some time for the Indians to adjust to the new ways but it’s for the better. This will help us as reformers because we are friends with the Indians and we only want to see the best for them.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
The Dawes Act was intended to be done in a reasonable and humane way. If the Dawes program was not corrupt by its Agents, it may have been successful. Native Americans would have kept a substantial amount of their land along with having the right to be…
- 340 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Question 2 (Worth 5 points) How could the federal government have made the Dawes Act more successful? by refusing to allow Native Americans to assimilate by making it illegal for Native Americans to sell their land to speculators by providing larger land parcels so the Native Americans could grow more crops by using land speculators as brokers between the government and Native Americans Points earned on this question: 5 Question 3 (Worth 5 points) What was the goal of the Dawes Act?…
- 331 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
When the Native Americans and the girls from “St. Lucy’s” adapted to the European way of life, they both gained the ability to speak and read English. When the girls first came to “St. Lucy’s” they only knew how to speak in their native tongue, but with time, learned how to fluently speak and read English. One example of this is when the girls are at the ball with the “brothers” they were speaking in English to them. The Indians also gained this ability by getting educated by people from the English culture. Elected in office during this time Grover Cleveland, who was president in 1887, put the Dawes Act in action which converted them to Christianity, teached them to speak English, and let them live self-sufficient and independent. The girls…
- 203 Words
- 1 Page
Good Essays -
The Dawes Act had some consequences that evolved from trying to move the Indians from their lands. The Act severally reduced Indian holdings and was not even worth it because on the long run the Dawes Act failed in all respects to its intentions. Many people believed it was just a lead to the loss of a lot of tribal land and the erosion of Indians cultural decisions. It also failed account to Indians who could not afford to the cost of farming supplies such ass seeds and tools. But when the Indian Reorganization Act overturned the Dawes Act in 1934 by making a shift to allow the managing their own affairs.…
- 451 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
John L. O’Sullivan had said, “‘... our manifest destiny to overspread the continent allotted by Providence for the free development of our yearly multiplying millions.’” (www.britanica.com) During Andrew Jackson’s term, America had set its sights on the untamed West - which, inconveniently, happened to be the Indians’ territory. President Jackson decided to create a controversial treaty that would allow America to exchange the Indians’ land for a large piece of land in the Louisiana Territory. It was created on May 28, 1830 and sparked much criticism and support throughout the nation. The Indian Removal Act of 1830 was justified because the Indians were enemies of America, they were given good land, and they were offered the government’s protection.…
- 809 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
The Edmund-Tucker Act was push through Congress in order to end Polygamy in the Utah Territory. Although, Utah had enough residents to become a state and had tried numerous times, it had failed because the Church of the Latter-Day Saints refused to end polygamy. President Author signed the bill to protect the institute of marriage. This new movement would outlaw cohabitation, if a man lived with two or more women, who are not his mother or his daughters, he could be charged with polygamy, even if there was no marriage license, with more than the first wife .…
- 98 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
In America there were many reasons that colonists on both sides of the issue of taxation had for whether taxes on the American people were necessary and justified. In the reading about the colonist’s responses to the stamp act of 1765, both sides were represented. The people who were in favor of the stamp act felt that America had created a burden on the British government and that they needed to help lessen that burden on England. They also felt that since the government had protected the colonists from Native Americans that America owed them for maintain peace and their freedom. By continuing with the negative reactions the colonists were giving it would result in the loss of America and in by doing so would allow for other countries to use the opportunity to become stronger and challenge the authority of the English government. While some people were for taxation others were not as willing. They thought that since they were British citizens and they came to the colonies that they deserved the same rights as the people back Britain. Placing a tax on the colonist, they felt, was also in conflict with previous rulings of other decrees like the Manga Charta. They also placed an emphasis on how laws in England may…
- 346 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
The Dawes Act was a document that authorized the President of the United States to assess American Indian land and divide it into allotments for individual Indians. Those who agreed to allotments would then be granted United States citizenship. During this time in the mid 1800s the United States and its citizens had their hearts set on Westward expansion. Americans were strongly encouraged by the belief of the “Manifest Destiny”, a widely held belief that settlers were destined by God to expand throughout the continent. Though this expansion proved to be essential in the construction of today’s United States of America, the forceful removal of these Native people became a major issue.…
- 692 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The Dawes Act was also known as the General Allotment Act of 1887. The purpose of the act was to treat the Native Americans as individuals rather than members of their tribes. The Dawes act was created to encourage the Native American tribes to split up. The Native Americans would be given the land and tools they needed if they became farmers. The Act would teach the Native Americans to be equal like the rest of the American population. For example, children of the Native American ethnicity were sent to boarding school where they would be taught to be like a white person. The Dawes act was a way for the individuals of the Native American tribes to receive citizenship. Once an individual received his or her allotment, it meant that they were…
- 345 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Unfortunately, despite how precisely Indians followed white men’s laws and requirements, the Indian Removal would have eventually transpired. The Five Civilized Tribes shed their Indian traditions and culture to take on the Americans way of life. Indians not only adopted principles in government and agriculture, but also religiously. Despite all of this, whites still wanted to kick Indians out of their lands in order to bring profit to themselves. Even the national government could not terminate the Indian Removal. Through both the United States Constitution and Worcester v. Georgia, the national government declared that states could not operate the removal of Indians. All of this, illustrates the inhumanity and lack of compassion whites had…
- 147 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
Dealing with the Dawes Act, was important towards the Native Americans and life itself. The Dawes Act was a succeeding policy by breaking up reservations by granting land allotments to individual Native Americans. The President broke up reservation land that was held in common by the members of the tribe. Native Americans registering a tribal “roll” were granted allotments to be parceled out to individuals. The Dawes Act was purportedly to protect Indian property rights.…
- 330 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
In conclusion, the Indian Removal Act of 1830 should not be justified because the Americans broke treaties and cheated the Indians in deals, the Americans gave the Indians bad land, and the Indians were there first. The had a peaceful life, then the Americans came in and messed it…
- 344 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
On the website “American Expansion | Indians of the Midwest”, it states that the act was originally passed to encourage Native Americans to farm with the settlers. Due to being separated from the buffalo, the natives no longer had to tools or equipment, and if they did it wasn’t the right kind that the settlers used. Not only did the U.S. government pass the Dawes act, but they also made the Native American children go to boarding school, dress in European style clothing, and learn English. In document six, the change is clearly showed through the pictures. Going to school changed their culture because the new generation of Native Americans were learning new traditions, languages, and wore new clothes. This was very different compared to how the original Native Americans dressed, talked, and…
- 853 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
One major event that reveals insight on the cause of the American Revolution was the passing of the Stamp Act by the British Parliament on March 22, 1765. It required the colonists to pay a tax for stamped paper that all legal documents including marriage licenses, diplomas, newspapers and even playing cards were to be printed on. Prime Minister George Grenville proposed that a tax should be imposed among the colonies to help offset the costs of sending troops needed for their own protection and maintenance. The revenue that would then generate from this act was to be used solely for this purpose. In addition to this, the Stamp Act would not only make money for Britain, but Grenville intended for this tax to demonstrate…
- 775 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
The majority of Native people reject the proposal because they are holding out for the return of Hawaiian sovereignty, which I do not support. I am on the other side of the opposition and believe that preferential treatment for a small group of people on a very racially and ethnically diverse land may not be wise. What happened to the Native Hawaiians was terrible, there is no denying that, but countless people have been through similar tribulations all throughout history. The world is built on the back of conquest, and though such things may not have a place in this more civilized time, it proves that people can persevere through such…
- 1624 Words
- 7 Pages
Better Essays