Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Hemingway, the Eco-Feminist

Powerful Essays
2863 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Hemingway, the Eco-Feminist
Robin Allison
Professor Knight
ENG 113 OM4
1 December 2013
Hemingway, the Eco-Feminist
Ernest Hemingway, a world-renowned author considered by many to be a master of the short story, has been often criticized as being sexist, misogynistic, patriarchal, or anti-ecological in his mindset. In fact, although he probably did inherit many of these pervasive traits from the culture in which he was born, his writing taken at face value paints a picture of a man who, rather than enforce these ideologies, forced himself and his readers to examine and evaluate them. As a man born in the pre-dawn of the twentieth century, Hemingway grew up in a culture in which the superiority of men to women was generally accepted as a given fact. Also, the prevailing attitude regarding the natural world was that the products of the natural world were infinite, and their value was only that which could benefit mankind in terms of profit or possibly recreation. The natural world, the Earth, was not seen as having any inherent value as is. Rather than accept these beliefs as gospel, however, Hemingway’s work reveals a man who thought deeply about male/female power issues and the impending desecration of the natural world he loved so much.
Literature, like any other well-executed artistic medium, causes people to think, and therefore talk about, what they have seen, heard, or read. As Hemingway has clearly caused people to think about issues of gender and ecological sustainability, it begs the likelihood that he intentionally designed his work to have such an effect. One cannot logically say in one breath that Hemingway was a master of dialogue and a short story, and in the other that he was blind to the fact that some of his male characters came across as immature and insensitive toward women. If he wrote stories about immature males, the most obvious conclusion would be that he intended to write stories about immature males. He also made frequent references to the beauty and serenity of the natural landscape, and the reader can clearly see his sorrow as he relates the destruction of the forests and streams he once loved.
In a keynote address given by the novelist Andre Dubus III, Dubus recognizes Hemingway’s pioneering realistic style in the era of modernist and post-modernist writers. He goes on to appreciate Hemingway for his choice to dispense with excessive adjectives and descriptive phrases in favor of allowing room for the reader to use his or her life experience to interpret his writing. Instead of overburdening the reader with Hemingway’s own interpretation of Hemingway’s story, he chooses to pare down his story, as much as he is able, to allow the reader to see the story through his or her own eyes. According to Dubus, Hemingway’s “. . .sustained discipline to find and then convey those details which will then give the experience fully to the reader is one of the more generous and responsible creative acts in the history of American literature” (11).
Hemingway, though he has been criticized as being one-sided – a patriarch and misogynist – actually conveys quite a considerable insight into the nature of male-female relations for his time. In his writing, he relates his own concerns and inadequacies in his dealings with the women he loves – this is apparent after a cursory examination of “The End of Something,” or The Sun Also Rises, to name only two of his works. He chose to convey what he felt to be understandable to the average human; a difficult task to ask of any writer. His main characters, rather than the chauvinistic buffoons some critics might expect, display a great deal of compassion and inner turmoil.
Critics take issue with Hemingway’s notorious drinking and “womanizing.” However, the available data indicate that the only parties involved were consenting adults. Regardless of his aversion to sobriety and his overly romantic attitude toward the fairer sex, Hemingway continued to try his best to bring his authentic experience as a human to his writing. Rather than spell out in great detail his own interpretation of circumstances, he respectfully trusts the reader to come to his or her own conclusions. This is what set him apart from his peers. “His influence on public discourse was and still is considerable, and one of the aspects that have anchored his life and his fiction in our collective imagination is his search for an authentic life” (Müller 30-31). Müller, an author and genetic researcher, also believes that Hemingway wanted to feel he wrote well much more than he wanted to feel wealthy or famous. He cites Hemingway’s protagonist in The Snows of Kilimanjaro as antithesis to Hemingway’s core incentives:
If the reading public … is basically fickle and ungrateful, if it doesn’t appreciate authentic writing, then writers have to resort to inauthentic writing to sell their books and become famous. Harry is an example of this type of writer. Writing well is secondary for him, a vaguely desirable achievement postponed to old age; his primary motivations are fame and money. To please the masses, he has presumably resorted to ornamentation and embellishment, to hook and crook, to all the stylistic strategies Hemingway rejects as false. (Müller 39)
In essence, he is saying that Hemingway chose realism over sensationalism; chose free and authentic expression over market value; chose art over money.
Here are examples of literary critics showing that Hemingway chose to paint as realistic as possible a picture of life as he saw it; and that he wanted the reader to examine and assess their own reactions to his portrayals of life in his time.
Some contemporary critics, such as Yan Yu, have issues with Hemingway’s love of hunting, and some even go so far as to say that he disrespects the Earth simply by being a hunter. While some of his earlier writing does describe wanton slaughter of fish, most of his works show a great deal of inner consideration toward the life and attitude of the animal being hunted. As he explains in “The Shot,” “The author of this article . . . believes that it is a sin to kill any non-dangerous game animal except for meat” (Hemingway, qtd. by Douglas).
Carey Voeller, Ph.D, an assistant professor of English, saliently notes Hemingway’s attitude toward the death of the marauding lion in True at First Light “[I] then lay down by the lion and talked to him very softly in Spanish and begged his pardon for us having killed him...” (qtd. in Voeller 73). This is clearly not the voice of a man who is purely callous toward the animals he hunts – even though this particular animal was responsible for the deaths of many tribespeople, including children, who lived in the area where Hemingway was camped at the time. He goes on: “I was happy that before he died he had lain in the high yellow rounded mound with his tail down and his great paws forward and looked off across his country to the blue forest and the high white snows of the big Mountain” (qtd. in Voeller 73). Hemingway is telling us about the sorrow he faced when encountered with the death of an animal – but not just any animal but a lion, representative of the grandeur of the natural world at its wildest and most fecund.
In his essay “The Call of the Wild: an Ecocritical Reading of The Old Man and the Sea,” Yan Yu analyzes Hemingway’s The Old Man and the Sea from an ecocritical stance. It is clear that Yu is not a native speaker of English, but his assessment appears to be somewhat well thought out and fairly astute. However, as an ecologically-minded individual, the present author finds philosophical errors to be apparent throughout Yu’s text.
In order to define ecocriticism, Yu quotes Wang Nuo:
As a kind of literary and civilization criticism, ecocriticism has the primary task which can demonstrates (sic) its intrinsic trait and peculiar value, that is, reexamining the culture of human (sic) to carry on cultural criticism, namely, probing into the problem of how did human theology, culture and the code of social development influence, even determine human being's (sic) attitude and behavior toward nature, and how did they bring about the deterioration of environment and the crisis of ecology (qtd. in Yu 170).
By Yu’s own definition, Hemingway is an ecocritic: his work does indeed probe into the problem of how humanity’s behaviors bring about the deterioration of the environment – his work entices the reader to consider the impact that humanity’s short-sighted actions have had on the once-grand, but now denuded Earth.
In one of his examples, Yu claims that Hemingway’s prose shows that his “feeling about nature does not go beyond [his] needs” (171). He illustrates this with the following excerpt from The Old Man and the Sea:
He looked across the sea and knew how alone he was now. But he could see the prisms in the deep dark water, and the line stretching ahead and the strange undulation of the calm. The clouds were building up now for the trade wind and he looked ahead and saw a flight of wild ducks etching themselves against the sky over the water, then blurring, then etching again, and he knew no man was ever alone on the sea. (qtd. in Yu 171)
His evaluation of this passage is that Hemingway does not value the sea intrinsically; rather, he only appreciates it because it helps him feel that he is not alone. This seems like quite a stretch for the reader. Logically speaking, the fact that Hemingway’s character Santiago appreciated nature’s beauty and felt less lonely does not imply that he does not appreciate nature’s intrinsic value. It does not even necessarily mean that the realization was caused by the view of sea and birds. Indeed, the fact that Hemingway included the description at all could be construed to mean that he did in fact have a deep appreciation for nature and its intrinsic worth. Correlation cannot imply causation, in either direction.
In his short story “The End of Something,” Hemingway describes the decimation of his childhood virgin forests in Michigan, and draws a corollary to the ending of Nick Adams’s relationship with his girlfriend Marjorie. This tale describes a young man hopelessly lost in his understanding of male-female relationships, who through his emotional immaturity destroys what appears to be a promising companionship with a loving woman (Hemingway 79-82). As Lisa Tyler notes, “Hemingway judged Nick – and very likely himself, as Nick is autobiographical – much more harshly than some Hemingway critics would like” (65).
Ferrero makes an interesting point here by reversing the genders of the speakers:
Nikki looked at the moon, coming up over the hills.
"It isn't fun anymore."
She was afraid to look at Mark. Then she looked at him. He sat there with his back toward her. She looked at his back. "It isn't any fun anymore. Not any of it."
He didn't say anything. She went on. "I feel as though everything was gone to hell inside of me. I don't know Mark. I don't know what to say."
She looked on at his back.
"Isn't love any fun?" Mark said.
"No," Nikki said. Mark stood up. Nikki sat there with her head in her hands.
"I'm going to take the boat," Mark called out to her. "You can walk back to the point."
"All right," Nikki said. "I'll push the boat off for you." (Ferrero 20).
This short piece illustrates the intellectual disconnect that many well-intentioned feminists experience when trying to criticize Hemingway and other authors. It would be unlikely for anyone to describe Nikki as being chauvinistic to Mark, yet Nick, in the original text, is often criticized as acting insensitive or chauvinistic toward Marjorie.
In an essay by Margaret Bauer, a feminist author and professor of English, Bauer examines two more of his short stories: “Hills like White Elephants” and “Indian Camp.” She defends Hemingway against critics who pre-assume that he is no more than a chauvinist or misogynist.
In her assessment of “Indian Camp” she makes it clear that, while the woman in labor is indeed simply the author’s prop to propel the story, the story itself is about Nick Adams and his journey coming of age. It is not about the woman screaming in a difficult labor; it is about a boy whose tough and somewhat callous father opens his eyes to realities of life that are difficult to embrace, especially for one so young. This counters the arguments of critics who attest that Hemingway’s description of the woman are somehow misogynistic. Rather, the story logically leads to Nick Adams’s concern about his father’s callous treatment of, and lack of compassion for, this woman. Bauer also points out that the woman in labor survives a caesarean-section delivery without anesthesia, while her husband commits suicide “. . . because he can’t bear her pain” (Bauer’s emphasis) (127).
Concerning “Hills like White Elephants”, Bauer states that Hemingway’s depiction of the pregnant woman “. . . undermines his misogynistic reputation” (129). The man, referred to as “the American,” comes off as short-sighted and somewhat juvenile, while the woman is represented as much more intelligent, and somewhat sarcastic, by her dialogue. As a male feminist, the present author concedes that the use of the term ‘girl’ to describe a woman of child-bearing age (Hemingway 211-14) can be construed as a deprecation of women. This word choice may simply be a sign of the times in which this story was written; but considering Hemingway’s reputation as a master of the short story, it would seem more likely to have been a deliberate act by Hemingway to sarcastically illustrate the plain fact that the male in this story is the weaker of mind, while the female is more mature. Once again, this undermines the myth of Hemingway as a misogynist – he portrayed the woman as strong and kind, and the man as alcoholic and narcissistic.
Bauer quotes Stephen P. Clifford: “. . . the myth of Hemingway’s misogyny, at least in his fiction, is itself a construct created by his readers” (qtd. in Bauer 125). What she is saying, ultimately, is that Hemingway is a genius with a short story, and that his male characters sometimes come off as immature jerks. If an intelligent reader takes the two points as equally valid, he or she is left with the conclusion that Hemingway intended these characters to appear in exactly that way.
Most likely, Hemingway would indeed be considered misogynistic and to have little care for the environment – if he lived in our present-day culture. But in his time, he did the literary world justice by not being as conditioned as his peers; rather than accept gender biases as the norm, or regard the natural world as an infinite resource existing only to serve the needs of humankind, he wrote in such a way as to bring about questions in the reader’s mind. As shown in the abovementioned works, Hemingway wrote in such a way as to excite his readers about these topics and entice them to think and speak about them.
The intelligent reader is left with the conclusion that Hemingway was neither a saint nor a megalomaniac, but simply a human who somehow figured out how to write honestly and succinctly about the world as he experienced it. His influence on contemporary public discourse has been immense. Not only did he write well, but he wrote in such a way as to invoke controversy about which side he took on the social and environmental problems dearest to his heart. He did this so well that he was able to keep some four generations – and counting – talking about the issues he himself was thinking about when he was in his prime.

Works Cited
Bauer, Margaret D. "Forget the Legend and Read the Work: Teaching Two Stories by Ernest Hemingway." College Literature 30.3 (2003): 124. Academic Search Complete. Web. 27 Oct. 2013.
Dubus, III, Andre. "Ernest Hemingway: Why His Work Matters Now More Than Ever, A Love Letter From The Digital World." Hemingway Review 32.1 (2012): 7-15. Academic Search Complete. Web. 23 Oct. 2013.
Ferrero, David J. "Nikki Adams and the Limits of Gender Criticism." Hemingway Review 17.2 (1998): 18. Academic Search Complete. Web. 17 Nov. 2013.
Hemingway, Ernest. “Hills Like White Elephants” The Complete Short Stories of Ernest Hemingway. New York: Macmillan, 1987. Print.
Hemingway, Ernest. “The End of Something” The Complete Short Stories of Ernest Hemingway. New York: Macmillan, 1987. Print.
Hemingway, Ernest. "Tu Rex Gloriae, Christe." Weblog post. “The Shot”. Brian Stanley Douglas, 30 Sept. 2012. Web. 06 Dec. 2013. .
Müller, Timo. "The Uses Of Authenticity: Hemingway And The Literary Field, 1926-1936." Journal Of Modern Literature 33.1 (2009): 28-42. Academic Search Complete. Web. 23 Oct. 2013.
Tyler, Lisa. "How Beautiful The Virgin Forests Were Before The Loggers Came": An Ecofeminist Reading Of Hemingway's "The End Of Something." Hemingway Review 27.2 (2008): 60-73. Academic Search Complete. Web. 17 Nov. 2013.
Voeller, Carey. "He Only Looked Sad The Same Way I Felt": The Textual Confessions Of Hemingway's Hunters." Hemingway Review 25.1 (2005): 63-76. Academic Search Complete. Web. 16 Nov. 2013.
Yu, Yan. "The Call Of The Wild: An Eco-Critical Reading Of The Old Man And The Sea." Canadian Social Science 7.3 (2011): 167-175. Academic Search Complete. Web. 27 Oct. 2013.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    In the late 1920s, society drenched itself in the excess- the extravagant materialism, superfluous drinking, and lavish parties, which were held more often than not. Ernest Hemingway emphasizes this aspect of the era in his novel, The Sun Also Rises. There were two themes prevalent in this novel: the lost generation and the process of healing. At first glance, these two themes seem to have no mutual ground on which they stand. However, Hemingway makes sense of this in his novel, intertwining the two themes, whereas they work as one. In the midst of all this chaos, the main character makes a choice between excessive partying and drinking and a process of healing, which does not necessarily look productive on the outside. Hemingway’s genius portrayal of these themes and their relationship are worthy of discussion and an evaluation.…

    • 855 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Hemingway interestingly uses the character of Brett to reevaluate the gender roles of men and women in the early twentieth century that manly, alcoholic, and emotionally unstable women can still be loved, but by doing this Hemingway reinforces the gender stereotype that…

    • 930 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    It is his works, such as Hills like White Elephants, which subtly address modern issues that bring forth the question of morality and purpose to a general population (A Farewell to Arms, 3). It is his short, direct style, exemplified by his six word story “Baby shoes for sale, never worn.”, allows for a clear and deep expression of emotion (A Farewell to Arms, 4). His involvement of incorporating the reader through active reading breaks an emotional barrier set forth by usual text. This action allows for the reader to directly examine Hemingway’s characters, and thus reflect on their own behavior. Hemingway’s mastery of language, subsequent to his fluency in the Romantic languages, allows his works to be overall reflective of human behavior and relate to the reader in an emotional context (A Farewell To Arms,…

    • 797 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Hills Like White Elephants

    • 1849 Words
    • 8 Pages

    The way Hemingway introduces the main characters is rather unusual. For one, very little is revealed about the physical qualities of the two main characters, beyond their gender. In fact, the reader doesn 't even learn their names until later. This literary technique creates within the reader a unique sense of identification with the characters having the conversation. Rather than sympathizing with the emotional state of the characters, the reader more readily empathizes with the very heart of the argument itself.…

    • 1849 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    This literature was confusing however, conceptually understandable that even though this short story was written somewhere between the life-time of Ernest Hemingway. People can relate to it in someway and the style of how it is written is something it could be said to be artistic and educational that people can learn from. As this textbook was dedicated for the purpose of learning literature, it was appropriate for using this literature in the book; So that people could debate, discuss the very meaning of the contents and…

    • 466 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Earnest Hemingway demonstrates this side of the battle of the sexes in many different ways and in multiple pieces. Hemingway creates an image of a stereotypical woman who is seen, but not heard, and is dependent on the male figure. In “The Short Happy Life of Francis Macomber” the narration switches to multiple viewpoints, including a lion’s, but the woman never narrates the story. “Hills Like White Elephants” is just another example of a woman agreeing to a man’s wishes when it is clear that she does not want to do what he is asking of her. Also, Hemingway often uses hair color to represent the nature of the women he writes about. For example, the “dark women” are usually brunette, flawed human beings, but always pull through for the male character at the end, and the “light women” are typically blonde, angelic, but are deceptive.…

    • 551 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Hemingway led a difficult life full of martial affairs and misfortune. Some of these experiences have set the foundation for Hemingway's greatest works. This essay will analyze the influence that Hemingway's separation from Pauline and divorce from Hadley had on "Hills like White Elephants." Before writing "Hills like White Elephants," Hemingway had been residing in Paris with his wife Hadley and son, Bumby. During their stay in Paris, Hadley and Ernest Hemingway met a woman named Pauline Pfeiffer. Pauline was more of a friend to Hadley than Hemingway was. Pauline did not think much of Hemingway at first, she thought he was lazy and a no-doer. Later Pauline and Hemingway fell in love and had an affair. Once Hadley knew of their affair, Hemingway requested a divorce. Hadley agreed under one condition, Hemingway and Pfeiffer had to separate for 100 days. After the 100 days if they were still in love, then Hadley would grant the divorce (Baker 174). This separation period left an indelible effect on Hemingway's life and…

    • 2205 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Even though to be in conflict with society and especially its values and beliefs isn’t easy for many authors to do, Ernest Hemingway breaks out this idea in order to give the reader a deep and provoking novel, mixed with unusual themes for that time in the way they were depicted, like alcoholism and expatriation.…

    • 617 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    This essay will use new criticism to evaluate “Hills Like White Elephants” by Ernest Hemingway in the areas of characters, symbolism, and conflict. I will mainly focus on two of the three characters. There will be many opportunities to comment on symbolism. Consideration will also be paid to the ongoing conflict between the American and the girl, sometimes referred to as Jig.…

    • 466 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Lady Brett

    • 1225 Words
    • 5 Pages

    In the novel by Ernest Hemingway, The Sun Also Rises, the character named Lady Brett Ashley is assimilated in the words of another character, Mike, with the Greek Goddess Circe. This Goddess is known in Homer's Odyssey for luring men with her irresistible charms and transforming them into animals. If this myth was to partake in reality, it would be without doubt represented in this novel. The majority of men in the story are tormented and subject to Brett's physical and sexual assets. The first characterization we get from her is one of a selfish, alcoholic, manipulative, sexual and evil woman who emasculates her male partners. However, this superficial characterization would ignore the principle of the iceberg which resonates in many of Hemingway's characters, only one eighth of the meaning lies in the text. It is therefore correct to affirm that Lady Brett Ashley contains a deeper side in her personality that at first read we might not realize. Although, the question remains, can we affirm Brett as a passionate and positive character. In this essay we will discuss the characterization of Lady Brett Ashley, her pivotal role and her evolution at the end of the story.…

    • 1225 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Ernest Hemingway Misogyny

    • 997 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Ernest Hemingway is regarded as one of the greatest writers of his time; however, he was notorious for his misogyny (University of Alabama). His misogyny was seen prominent throughout many of his short stories such as “Hills Like White Elephants” and “Cat in the Rain.” Throughout Hemingway’s life, he published many short stories and novels that had a very strong influence on American literature in the 20th century. Within these pieces of work, many scholars have criticized Hemingway for his portrayal of women often as helpless, weak, and easily influenced. Specifically, Stanley Renner is well known for her criticism on his work “Hills Like White Elephants” in which she analyzes and concludes that Hemingway’s…

    • 997 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “Bartleby the Scrivener,” by Herman Melville, and “Hills Like White Elephants,” by Ernest Hemingway, both present entirely different stories about an isolated employee, and an awkward conversation between a young couple, but as we delve deeper into each story, we are presented with the theme of choice and gender. Bartleby is presented with a number of choices and opportunities to leave his place of work, and the woman, Jig, faces the choice of whether to get an abortion or not. This theme of decision making shows how gender roles play into our freedom of choice and our opportunities. In Bartleby’s case, he is able to ultimately decide his fate due to the fact he is male, but Jig’s future decision will be consciously or subconsciously influenced…

    • 879 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Many years ago our society was filled with moral and ethical values, unfortunately they have all but disappeared. Hemingway captures a moment in history when the tides were turning from an ethical and ordered society to a less ordered and much less ethical society. Using his ability to manipulate the readers' imagination, Hemingway creates a realistic setting that conveys powerful and raw-edged emotions. Through the use of various landscapes and structures he is able to give the reader insight into the human condition without actually telling what it is. A good example of this is the hot, dry atmospheric conditions that set the mood in the story and communicate a sense of tension to the reader. The expression "They look like white elephants"(23) is a metaphor used to imply the sacredness of white elephants in certain South American cultures in relation to Jig's unborn child.…

    • 760 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Until the age of six, Ernest Hemingway was dressed as a girl by his mother. The only time he was allowed to be a young boy was when he was hunting in the woods with his father. This affected Hemingway and shaped his views on masculinity. In many of his short stories there are the reoccurring themes of racism, sexism, and coming of age which can all be lead back to the idea of being masculine. What does it mean to be masculine? Hemingway used his view on these topics to create many short stories.Two of his short stories, “Indian Camp” and “The Doctor and the Doctor’s Wife”, explores the views of men, during this time, on racism and sexism. There are also aspects of coming of age that focus on the masculinity of a young boy. Indian Camp…

    • 410 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    A Street Car Named Desire

    • 1756 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Cited: Hemingway, Ernest. “The Snows of Kilimanjaro”, The Norton Anthology of American Literature. Ed. Nina Baym &Robert S. Levine. Shorter Eight Edition. W.W. Norton & Company. 1979-2013. 1021-1038. Print.…

    • 1756 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays

Related Topics