There are many strengths and limitations of participant observation for the study of gender relations in schools. Participant observation means that the sociologist or researcher does not simply observe a group, but is part of it as they play a role in it as well.
Participant observation has a wide range of advantages. When observing people, validity is a huge advantage as it can obtain huge amounts of rich, qualitative data. This also helps the observer the get an overview of how people really live. Some supporters of participant observation argue that this is the method’s main strength, however there are many more. The best way for someone to understand what something is like is to experience it first-hand themselves. Sociologists call this personal or subjective understanding, ‘verstehen’, which is a German word meaning ‘empathy’, or an understanding that comes from putting yourself into another person’s position.
Participant observation is more flexible than other methods as it allows the sociologist to enter the situation with a relatively open mind about what they will find. A survey method consists of a specific hypothesis which is set along with pre-set question’s, however with participant observations this is more flexible and researchers can ask appropriate questions and do not need to set a hypothesis before is they do not want to.
Item A suggests that how male and female pupils and teachers act towards each other has a major effect on pupils’ experiences of education. From my knowledge, I feel this is not true as pupils should take ownership of their own work, despite what teacher they have. On the other hand, a teacher may affect a pupils achievement in school as it is what the teacher teaches the children, and how they do this which refers back to how much the children in the class learn, meaning there are two sides to this argument.
On the other hand, participant observations also have many limitations. There are several practical disadvantages which researchers face when using this method. It is very time-consuming; researchers need to be trained to recognise aspects of a situation that are sociologically significant and worth further attention. If a researcher carries out an observation in ‘covert’, they may become personally stressed and may feel as though they are constantly being demanded by others. On the other hand, characteristics such as age, gender, race and ethnicity may restrict which groups can be studied. Lastly, many groups may wish not to be studied if they do not feel comfortable with what is going to happen. If an observer goes above a participator, then they are blocking the rights of the individual which is illegal, and consequences will be set.
Item A states that schools have gender equality policies which must be stuck to with no exceptions. It also states that pupils and teachers may disguise their real attitudes towards gender and this may make it difficult for the researcher to reach the truth. If people know they are being observed then their attitude may automatically change, this would then show The Hawthorne Effect, where individuals change to please the researcher.
In conclusion, there are many strengths and limitations to participant observation, and gender relations in schools do have an impact on a child’s achievement at school as discussed above.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Using material from Item A and elsewhere, assess the claim that gender differences in educational achievement are primarily the 'result of changes in society'…
- 1175 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
used by teachers were monitored for gender bias in order to ensure ‘girl friendly schooling’. The monitoring…
- 1690 Words
- 1 Page
Good Essays -
Participant observation is where a researcher will gain data from being in an open environment, wherever they are overt, meaning the participants being researched on know they are being researched, covert, meaning they do not know they are being researched and non-participating, where the researcher takes a step back and observes the situation rather than be involved. There is a clear gap between gender when it comes to attainment in school and exams, and there are many explanations for this gap forming. Most of these are very hard to be assessed within a school environment via participant observation, due to them being external factors outside of school life.…
- 891 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Another strength of using participant observation is that it allows the researcher to obtain more ‘truthful data’. When using questionnaires or interviews it easy for participants to lie. However, if the researcher is part of the situation i.e. another teacher or a classroom assistant it would make lying much more difficult. This means the study is much more valid. However, the mere presence of the observer may affect the behaviour of both the teachers and pupils. Teachers may associate any outside observers with Ofsted inspections. This may result in teachers putting on a show and not acting as they usually would. They may usually treat pupils from ethnic backgrounds differently on a normal everyday basis but the presence of the observer may put an end to this. This is called the Hawthorne effect. Ofcourse, this would depend on whether the researcher was covert or overt.…
- 957 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
In this classic piece of feminist research, Michelle Stanworth highlighted the way in which sexual divisions and gender discrimination were reproduced in the school environment. She carried out individual, in-depth interviews with teachers and pupils (both male and female) in seven A-level classes in the Humanities department of a sixth form college. Her aim was to explore the extent to which gender affected the way teachers thought about their pupils’ career prospects, and consequently how male and female pupils might have different experiences of classroom interaction. Stanworth concluded that boys demanded and received more of their teachers’ attention than girls, who felt that they were marginalized in classroom encounters. Teachers also had lower expectations of their female pupils’ career prospects, because they expected them to get married and adhere to traditional stereotypes of domestic femininity. We can classify this project as having a case study research design, in that Stanworth was focusing on the social processes at play in one specific setting and at one moment in time; she did not want to compare the school to any others or to measure any changes in her participants’ attitudes over time. This was a qualitative research strategy, which Stanworth employed by using her detailed observations of one case to develop a more general theory of gender and education. It is likely to have been high in trustworthiness (if not validity), because the researcher used quotations from the interviews to support her arguments, and so seems to offer a genuine insight into how teachers and pupils perceive classroom interaction. She also provides a clear account of her methodology, which means that it would be easy to replicate the study. However, the personal and subjective nature of Stanworth’s observations mean that this piece of research would be low in reliability and external validity, for if the study were…
- 359 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Weaver-Hightower , M. (2003). The "Boy Turn" in Research on Gender and Education. Review of Educational Research. Vol. 73, No. 4, pp. 471-498…
- 2442 Words
- 10 Pages
Best Essays -
Examine the problems that sociologist may face when using covert participant observation and covert non-participant observation in their research. (20 marks)…
- 1330 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
All sociological research methods involve observation, however, according to Hughes participant observations is defined by when the researcher themselves participates in the activities of those he or she is observing and studying. Participant observation is a primary research method in which a sociologist studies a group by taking a role within it and participating in its activities. There are two different types of participant observation. Overt where the participants are aware of the researcher's true identity, and there is covert which means undercover where the true identity of the researcher is a secret.…
- 909 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Participant observation is where the researcher joins the group or community they are studying, the researcher will participate in the activities over a period of time, to do this, the researcher attempts to become accepted in order to collect more valid research and to try and see the world in the way the group does. There are two types of participant observation, Covert and Overt. Covert participant observation is where the researcher will take an undercover role in order to do research into the group they wish to study, there is normally a ‘gate keeper’ within this group that knows the researcher is there to do research, the gate keeper helps get them into the group to do this research. Overt participant observation is where the researcher takes a more open role; they openly ask the group if they will allow the researcher to study them.…
- 676 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Qualitative observational research consists of over 30 different approaches which often overlap and whose distinctions are subtle. The type of approach used depends on the research question and/or the discipline the researcher belongs to. For instance, anthropologists commonly employ ethnomethodology and ethnography, while sociologists often use symbolic interaction and philosophers frequently use concept analysis (Atkinson and Hammersley, 2007).…
- 682 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Traditionally observational research has mainly been done on animal behavior in their natural environment, but it is now being used in many disciplines, such as, education, sociology, management, nursing, communications, and psychology. A main goal of observational research is to analyze participants’ actions in their everyday settings. Observational research can be carried out in order to familiarize a researcher with participants’ actions and their environmental settings. This allows the researcher to gain descriptive information about the subject and to get information about the relationship between variables.…
- 350 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
competency significantly for leadership ratings. The findings do not support the bulk of previous findings on…
- 6021 Words
- 25 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Assess the view that gender differences in achievement are largely the result of changes in the education system…
- 817 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
1. We are fairly familiar with the topic of gender issues in the classroom through the readings in the textbook as well as the assignments on the gender roles in Disney movies as well as going to the mall to see how gender oriented everything was.…
- 1845 Words
- 8 Pages
Powerful Essays -
c) Outline some of the factors outside the education system that have affected gender differences in school. (12 Marks)…
- 941 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays