Harry Potter vs Frodo Baggins

Only available on StudyMode
  • Download(s) : 281
  • Published : March 30, 2005
Open Document
Text Preview
Lord of the Rings: Two Towers / Harry Potter: Prisoner of Azkaban Comparison

In the two novels, Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers, written by author and Harry Potter: The Prisoner of Azkaban, written by author, there is a distinct relationship that is created through the idea that there are the chosen individuals are the only ones that can save the world.

The first novel, Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers is a novel generally focusing on uniting ¡§Middle Earth¡¨, a term used to describe the human world, to defeat the enemy forces of evil controlled by a character described as pure evil named NAME. The actions of one small hobbit name Frodo Baggins, a race similar to humans, that will in fact determine the outcome of who is triumphant; not the actions of the hundreds of thousands of soldiers protecting the vast armies of Saruman.

Although author¡¦s style is completely different, considering the novels were written in separate generations, you could find many comparisons when relating back to the idea of ¡§good versus evil¡¨. In the second novel, Harry Potter: The Prisoner of Azkaban, there is a young boy named Harry Potter, whose parents were famous wizards but were allegedly murdered by an evil wizard named Sirius Black. His past is constantly being reminded to Harry, as news that Sirius Black has escaped from prison and is seeking out Harry. Harry and his close friends set out of an adventure to find the truth and lies of his past, only to uncover more treachery, lies, and deception.

These chosen heroes often follow a ¡§collective unconscious¡¨ [1], meaning that patterns emerge in all ¡§good versus bad¡¨ scenarios that are generally alike. There is the hero¡¦s beginning, where a character is destined to do great things but is constantly in a struggle for power, the call to adventure, where heroes become very important is given a chance to prove himself, and the reward, when a character successfully completes his quest, there is some form of gratification and celebration [2]. Regardless of overwhelming odds to defeat evil, the forces of good call for reprisal, uniting their forces to defeat the enemy.

In hero¡¦s beginning, the characters are introduced as very important and are going to serve a purpose, greater than him self which indefinitely will lead to the next stage of a hero¡¦s recognized stature. Although it may not be evident at a specific time, the heroes are aware, to some extent, the dangers they are going to be facing. They may or may not have been confronted as of yet, but their journey is unfolding and important information is revealed. A lot of the characters abilities still remain unknown as of yet, because their skills and knowledge have not been pushed to their limits for their true nature to be discovered.

In Lord of the Rings, the hero Frodo Baggins does not have any magical powers, or is well known at all except his outstanding ability to never give up, unlike in Harry Potter who is recognized and famous. Despite his lack of heroic stature, he is well liked [1] ¡V Archetype by Carl Jung

[2] ¡V The Characteristics of the Classical Hero and the Quest

by those who know him, especially his servant, Sam, who Frodo sees as an equal and best friend. This could be addressed as one of Frodo¡¦s most important qualities as a hero because without his ability to see all people as equals Sam would have never shown the dedication to Frodo that would have saved his life on countless occasions. For example, even when Frodo had turned his back on Sam for supposedly betraying him, Sam continued on his journey behind Frodo only to find Frodo in a horrible predicament that required Sam¡¦s courage and dedication to help Frodo be freed by a spiders cocoon. Without Frodo¡¦s growing sense of a community, and developing friendships, it is possible that Frodo would have been able to gather the courage, or perhaps turned back when the times were too tough for him to handle on his own. Frodo, who is...
tracking img