Gettier Problems

Topics: Epistemology, Belief, Justified true belief Pages: 2 (463 words) Published: April 2, 2009
Knowledge is defined by the tripartite theory where it is defined as justified true belief. It generally means that in order to know something, we have to believe it that it is true and support it with justifications to prove that it is true. However, not all justified true beliefs can be knowledge as shown in the counter example - the Gettier problems by Edmund Gettier. The Gettier problems narrate a situation where a. justified true belief does not warrant as genuine knowledge. Here is one example of a Gettier problem:

Suppose that Jimmy is visiting at his friend, Tim. He wanted to make sure that Tim is in the study room and hence went to see for himself. In the study room, he sees a boy with the same build; same clothes and same face and concludes that Tim is indeed in the study room. However, unknown to Jimmy, he had seen Tim’s twin brother and Tim was indeed in the room, hiding behind the door. Hence, Jimmy’s belief is justified and true, yet he did not have knowledge of Tim’s presence in the room.

I feel that Gettier problems are generally made up of two unfortunate incidents. Firstly, there is this unlucky accident where the belief even though supported by strong justification, remains false (where the unlucky case that Tim have a twin brother.) Secondly, unknown to the observer, in some unfortunate twist, the belief happens to be true (Tim happens to be hiding behind the door.) There is this close but not inviolable relationship between truth and justification and when there is a difference between what is true and the evidence that the justification offer, a Gettier problem is thus formed.

Gettier problems argue that if knowledge is solely justified true belief, then there must not be any cases of justified true belief that are not knowledge. Yet, but Gettier problems are counterexamples of justified true belief without being knowledge. Hence, one is to either refuse that Gettier problems are justified true beliefs, or accept that Gettier...
Continue Reading

Please join StudyMode to read the full document

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Summary of Edmund Gettier Essay
  • Problems encountered by irregular students Essay
  • problems and prospects in tripur garment industry Essay
  • Essay about Problems Encountered by Students in Taking Up College Courses
  • Problems Facing Human Services Clients Essay
  • ACC 460 Week 3 Learning Team Ch 4 6 Textbook Problems Research Paper
  • The Problem of Evil Essay
  • Problem Solving Essay

Become a StudyMode Member

Sign Up - It's Free