Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Gender and Literature- Kindred

Powerful Essays
2238 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Gender and Literature- Kindred
Gender, Identity and Resistance in Postcolonial Literature
997309728
University of Toronto
Gender, Colonialism and Cultural Resistance – WGS 369
Professor Tahmasebi- Birgani

Literature has always been an outlet used by postcolonial societies and disadvantaged groups to address issues that were either frowned upon or disapproved of in the past. One such concern is that of slavery and how it was defined and accepted as a natural preordained act. The superiority of one group outweighed the other and left them in a position of lacking and belittlement. This is an ongoing physical, psychological and social constraint that all work together to keep one particular group in “their place” while creating a universal understanding that the other is intrinsically better. Kindred a novel by Octavia Butler, is one of the greatest works that gives voice to the position of reductionism that the African American community faced but from the removed position of a woman from our current time. This science fiction novel captures the heritage of Butler who has roots in a Grandmother who was a slave and a single parent mother who worked relentlessly as a maid to provide for her family’s needs. It is this rich legacy that gives birth to the interest and relevance of the issue her story tackles. This essay seeks to analyse how Octavia Butler’s Kindred uses characters such as Dana, Kevin and Rufus as tools to boldly speak to the issue of colonialism and slavery and how these acts affects identity and gender relations of both the enslaved and enslaver. The story begins with a happily married interracial couple who had just moved into a house of their own. The main protagonist Dana, is on the dawn of her twenty sixth birthday when her life is turned upside down in a strange change of events. Time travelling form her present 1976 life in California she is transferred into the deep South in the early 1800’s, a time when slavery was still prevalent. Dana’s world is now centered on these time travelling episodes that are all in an attempt of saving her white ancestor Rufus, while grappling with the 20th century reality and being perceived as a slave in her episodes. Though she is always returned to her present life every time she faces a dangerous or life threatening event, she is forced to continue this involuntary task to ensure her existence. It is these experiences that allow Dana to realize and understand her history and the challenges that ones skin color creates for them. Her present life may not be free from racism and discrimination, but the one that she is forced into in her time travelling, points out the differences and paints a clearer picture as to where she really stands in history as a black woman. One of the greatest issues that Kindred tackles is that of identity. Identity not only speaks to the way an individual may define themselves but also how society witnesses, perceives and understands that person. Factors such as status, skin color, economic standing etc may all come into play and have an impact on identity. Kindred presents the unique case of Dana. This is an independent strong black woman in the 20th century but a property and looked down upon in the 19th century, two opposing identities that she must balance. These two contrasting identities points out the difficulties in how context affects the lives we live and the paths we take, especially in the lives of women. Butler cleverly hides the race of both Kevin and Dana for the first chapters of the novel. The reader is only made aware of the fact that they were two lost souls who needed each other to feel complete. In her present life, Butler represents Dana as a modern, strong and compassionate character. She is a black woman who is educated and knows exactly what she wants. Being in an interracial relationship, though it was discouraged by their family and associates, had no direct effect on their lives, as by this century, marrying out of ones race was not necessarily a great taboo that could lead to death. Kevin, her husband, is represented as being unconditionally in love with Dana and as a result he appears to be blind towards her skin color. They seemed to work equally in all that they do and this ensured a balanced relationship free from inferior superior labelling roles. This was however not the case when Kevin was allowed to time travel with Dana. Immediately a change had to take place. Their identity as a couple had to be redefined in order to ensure their safety. Interracial relationships in the 1800s were simply forbidden. It was frowned upon as blacks were merely property and their bodies used for sexual pleasure nothing more. Love between a black slave and white slave owner almost never existed and society would not condone such behaviour. It is because of this reasoning that Dana had to take on the identity of Kevin’s slave. Her agency is stripped from her and she is reduced to the definition of her husband, as property. This is a prevalent feature of colonialism. No one but those who are in a position of control has an autonomous self. Property is the means that describes who has power and who does not, who is considered a full human and who is not. On one instance, Rufus outright asks Kevin about Dana’s relationship to him. He asks “does Dana belong to you now?”1 He is unable to fathom the idea that they could have an equal relationship. This was a completely new and revolutionary idea for a man that grew up with the idea that it was perfectly acceptable for blacks to be used and abused at the owners dispense. By reducing Dana to this level, Butler speaks directly to how the act of colonizing dismisses individuality and groups people together based solely on their race. Her identity is not conjured by her own existence but instead it is defined by relationships with the people in her life. Kevin, Dana’s white husband has to make little to no change when he is immersed in the past. The fact that he is a man and the colour of his skin creates a different experience for him. In a patriarchal society that values his race and existence, the task of integrating becomes almost intrinsic. While Dana is stripped of her personality and identity, he automatically picks up the role that is expected of him. The fact that he is from the future and knows that the imbalance is not reasonable makes him more lenient and likeable, yet he has to prove himself as a man that is in control in order to be taken seriously. Because of the advantage of his white skin color, he has the ability to help slaves escape even though he knows that this may cost him his very own life. He is trying to adjust to the times and still live up to his values of the 20th century. However this becomes even more complicated as the reader witnesses that he often times take Dana’s agency from her as he prefers to be in control. He is unable from the advantaged position to truly understand that it is not simple about the big picture of how slavery dehumanises African Americans, but about giving identity and a voice to the lives that he has direct contact with. From his removed perspective, he is unable to comprehend the difficulties and reality of being enslaved. Colonialism has the same effect. Octavia points out the fact that not everyone in the position of superiority may not have agreed with the practices that took place during slavery, yet society is structured in such a way that it becomes acceptable, and as a result individuals may become complacent and unwilling to change. Rufus, Dana’s white ancestor has the most complex identity in the text. Being raised in a time period where it is common knowledge that he is entitled to whatever he desires because of the color of his skin leaves him feeling invincible. His father, Tom Weylin, is a proud but harsh slave owner and as such, he has a sense of entitlement and power. While he has good intentions on many occasions, he still demonstrates atrocious behaviour in order to prove himself and his position. He fails to recognize that Dana is there to provide help to him and often times only see her on the surface as apart of an inferior group and nothing else. Her life saving acts often goes unwarranted and ends up in more repercussions rather than having good effects. His relationship with Alice, a free black girl is a intricate one. The reader is made aware that he has genuine feelings for her, yet the dichotomy that exists between them makes it acutely clear that he only desires her in the sense that he has total control and power over her, never an equal relationship. Rufus is thought to accept that he should have whatever he desired and he is unable to deal with the fact that Alice is in love with Isaac. He will stop at nothing, even inflicting pain on her to have her as his own. His overwhelming desire to have her as property leads to him buying her and making her a simple sex slave, later leading to her own downfall. Dana and Rufus’s relationship is a peculiar one. Once he realizes that Dana holds his future in her hands and can choose to either allow him to live or watch him die, he is both terrified and threatened by her which is a new experience for him because she is a black woman. It is out of this dilemma that he develops sexual attraction towards her in an attempt to fully control and reduce her as a woman. Her body is the site that he chooses to control and invoke ownership on in order to regain his patriarchal agency. He orders that she be whipped on more than one occasions to put her in her place and degrade her. This was a consistent feature of slavery and colonialism. The act of degrading a woman by using her body as their masters pleased was a way of proving that they were not valued or seen as humans who could either consent or refuse the act. Butler proves that fear and force were agents implemented in the society that kept the black community in their place and allowed for horrific acts to be repeated throughout history. Butler uses these three main characters in a unique way to explore how colonialism truly works by stripping or creating identities of people. For the white characters in the novel, their identity is based off of the fact that they are always in a position of control or power regardless of the situation they find themselves in. This is not the reality for the black characters, especially Dana. Her identity in her present life is juxtaposed to the one she takes on in the slavery invested society her time travelling episodes takes her. She suggests that “I don’t have a name for the thing that happened to me, but I don’t feel safe anymore”.2 At first she distances herself from the acts that are taking place with the comfort that she is from a different time, but as the time she spends in the past becomes longer, this is not possible anymore as she too takes on the characteristic of a slave. Dana witness how slaves can become a part of the regeneration of a cycle as she watches children play out the act of being auctioned out for sale.3 She becomes afraid of the possibility that the brutality that she experiences will strip her of all she has accomplished and knows in her present life, and in order to preserve her wellbeing and understanding of herself she kills Rufus. Butler represents this act as a trade which had to take place to ensure that her identity was secured. Dana is aware of the trauma she suffered as she had to live through being treated as an object, harsh whippings and abuse, witnessing sale of human beings and killings before her eyes, yet she is aware that the past is simply the past and it cannot be changed. Slavery and colonialism was a part of history which society may tend to want to forget, but this novel reminds us that “slavery is a long slow process of dulling”4, a history that has created the present world we encounter and still has its remnants on our lives.
Octavia Butlers Kindred not only forces its reader to go back into time and witness life in the antebellum South, but to realize how much slavery depending on the disfiguring of identities and gender relationships to ensure its continuity. The characters of Dana, Kevin and Rufus all suggests how slavery was not a simple issue that was only rooted in cruelty, but transcended and influenced by other factors. The book has made major accomplishments in identifying and dealing with an issue that is often swept under the rug and by having a female character as the narrator and protagonist; it gives agency to a group that was always undermined, black women.

Bibliography

Butler, Octavia. Kindred. Boston: Beacon Press, 1979.

Bibliography: Butler, Octavia. Kindred. Boston: Beacon Press, 1979.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    There are various connections that can be made between the characters within the novel “Kindred” written by Octavia Butler. The majority of these connections relate to four of the course themes we’ve visited in past few weeks: double consciousness, collective trauma, diaspora, and power relationships. The protagonist, Dana Franklin, traveled between the past and present and in her travels she met a variety of different people, including the enslaved African Americans and their White owners of the 19th century, as well as her ancestors, one in particular is the cause of her time travel. Alice Greenwood and Rufus Weylin both had a peculiar relationship with Dana, as well as with each other. The ties that…

    • 1467 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Octavia Butler’s Kindred was an astounding book written in 1979 about a character name Edana Franklin, who is simply called Dana, is pulled continuously back into the 19th century by a boy name Rufus every time his life is in danger. This book is an unconventional tail about slavery, sexism and racism. Not only is it entertaining but it stirs up deep emotions inside of you about your history. This story makes you feel love, compassion, hate, and sorrow all at once. Octavia Butler wrote this book to bring knowledge and emotion to our pass time, as well as showing the reader how the past should and does effect our present time.…

    • 823 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    kindred the novel

    • 1518 Words
    • 7 Pages

    In the novel Kindred Butler confronts us with differences of black and white and past and present. All of the issues in Kindred are derived from issues of black and white. Dana’s race and literacy is what defines her in the 1800’s in Maryland and in 1976 in California. As a reader I’m yanked between past and present as well as the characters Dana and Kevin. Dana and her husband are forced to experience slavery in Maryland and their home in California seems far gone. We are all affected by the legacy of slavery in one way or another, whether we know it or not. Whites and blacks are affected by the past and present types of racism. In some way we are all connected to slavery and Dana finds that out when she is taken back to the 1800’s. The past stereotypes of blacks in the 1800’s are still imbedded in our thoughts a hundred years later.…

    • 1518 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Up From Slavery

    • 1661 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Up from Slavery is the 1901 autobiography of Booker T. Washington chronicling over fifty years of his personal experiences. It starts from working to rise from the position of a slave child during the Civil War, to the difficulties and obstacles he overcame to get an education at the new Hampton University. It also explores his work establishing vocational schools—most notably the Tuskegee Institute in Alabama—to help black people and other disadvantaged minorities learn useful, marketable skills and work to pull themselves, as a race, up. He reflects on the generosity of both teachers and philanthropists who helped in educating blacks. In this text, Washington climbs the social ladder through hard, manual labor, a decent education, and relationships with great people. Booker tells the story from a different perspective - what life was like growing up as a free man. In this autobiography of his life, Washington’s generalizations and accommodations of the treatment and disregard for the African American by people of the White race was nonchalant, as though he felt that for some reason it was okay or necessary for African Americans to be treated as second-class.…

    • 1661 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Reyita Book Review

    • 1164 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The story begins with a recounting of the story of Tatica, Reyita’s grandmother, and her trial of being abducted from her native Africa and brought to Cuba to be sold into slavery. Tatica’s story sets a precedent that is upheld by the next generations of her family of racial discrimination, struggle for survival and equality, and political activism. Reyita explains that her grandmother’s love of Africa instilled in Reyita a passion for visiting her grandmother’s homeland that led her to join Marcus Garvey’s movement to send black people back to Africa, and her role in this movement inspires her desire for equality and social advancement, although she contradictorily advances her family through means of ‘whitening’.…

    • 1164 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    According to the narrative of Frederick Douglass, during the 19th Century, the conditions slaves experienced were not only cruel, but inhumane. It is a common perception that “cruelty” refers to the physical violence and torture that slaves endure. However, in this passage, Douglass conveys the degrading treatment towards young slaves in the plantation, as if they were domesticated animals. The slaves were deprived of freedom and basic human rights. They were not only denied of racial equality, they weren’t even recognized as actual human beings.…

    • 391 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Summon a vision of yourself in a crowded setting, surrounded by white men, women, children and seniors. With that image carved, draw yourself as a young African American in the 1960s, despised by the white man. Though you stick out like a sore thumb, eyes glance past you, blinded in your midst. An ‘outcast’ has now become your terminal label- segregated, judged, despised. Does this story sound familiar? Yes, it does, as millions of books in the 21st century alone, have exhibited these themes. While eloquently written, Melba Patillo Beals unoriginality in the subject of hardships in African American lives in the time of severe oppression makes this story a tale told too often, which should not be exposed to a classroom of easily distracted teenagers.…

    • 726 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “Let’s stop believing that our differences make us superior or inferior to one another”- Don Miguel Ruiz. The novel “The Help” by Kathryn Stockett is a controversial and heart-wrenching story that depicts the cruel brutality and inequality that African Americans faced in Jackson, Mississippi during the early 1960’s. In the novel, Stockett shows the inequality between races, how Caucasian Americans believed they were superior, and the bigotry between social classes through the characterization of the main characters and bringing forth facts from that time setting. These issues have changed over the years but are yet still here in a more subtle way.…

    • 102 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    violence in kindred

    • 1221 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In modern society, violence is unquestionably looked down upon. With any type of inhumane abuse, there is a strict set of laws in place to protect victims. However, this was not always the case. In Octavia Butler’s book Kindred, she does not hesitate in intensely describing the unjust and violent exploitation of power by white people against blacks within the 1800’s. Even more so, she uses violence as a dominant theme throughout the entire novel. As always, a sensitive topic like full out physical abuse is hard to handle for some readers, and that makes people question whether the prevalent violent theme in Kindred was truly necessary. Without violence, the novel would never of become such an accurate and view changing story. In fact, removing the violence in the book would of toned down reality and created a misrepresentation of historical fact. The necessity of violence in Kindred was to accurately educate the reader about the never ending abuse which blacks were forced to submit themselves too during the early 1800’s, and without it the novel would of been nothing more than pure fiction.…

    • 1221 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Writers utilize their literary abilities in order to create a piece of work that transmits a meaningful message to their audience and create an impact on them. This is the case of Octavia Butler’s Kindred, a historical science-fiction novel evolving around a twenty six year old woman named Dana living in 1976. What makes the story unique is the fact that the plot alternates between the past and the present as Dana travels through time from the commodity of her house in 1976 Los Angeles to Maryland during the antebellum period. The catalysts for these trips to the past are the near death experiences of the son of rich southern planter, a boy named Rufus, who is one of Dana’s ancestors. Every single time Rufus is put in a situation where he…

    • 776 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Consent is now, more than ever, a hot-button topic of conversation. The questions of what is consent, who can give it, and when is it necessary are being played out in courtrooms, the legislature, and the news. The cost of public opinion is loud, fractured, and far from the consensus needed to come reach a verdict. Part of the problem with discussions about topics like consent, are that they are spoken about in a vacuum. When consent is discussed, it is almost exclusively talked about in the context of sex and sexual assault, however, sex is not the only interpersonal interaction around which issues of consent exist.…

    • 1349 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Our generation is advancing day by day but we shouldn't forget our history. Kindred is not just a fiction novel. It is a great book that keeps the readers’ interest from page to page. Dana's time-travel reflects the world of slavery in Maryland, racial inequality and interaction between weakness and strength. A black woman Dana was intimately connected with the plantation community for a long time. She made hard compromises to survive in excruciating conditions and to provide her existence in her own time. This novel is not about the feminist movement. Kindred is a book about the desire to be a free human being. This novel is about a battle with injustice and interracial issues. Not in vain Dana returned back in her own time on the 4th of July and became free on the day of American…

    • 1187 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    "So it is naturally with the male and the female; the one is superior, the other inferior; the one governs, the other is governed; and the same rule must necessarily hold good with respect to all mankind." This quote, spoken by the famous Aristotle, proves to be timeless. The words express knowledge concerning gender that proves to be centuries ahead of its time. Aristotle however, may not have even realized the amount of truth expressed in these few, simple words. Men are commonly thought of as the dominant of the two sexes, but as we have seen through many of the literary works studied, this is most certainly not the case. In dealing with books such as Macbeth written by William Shakespeare and The Maltese Falcon by Dashiell Hammet, it becomes clear that this quote holds true in a much different way than originally intended. In both of these novels the women involved are anything but the innocent bystanders, but rather the manipulator and catalyst behind the scenes. Out of these two books, two strong and memorable female personas arise, that of Lady Macbeth, as well as that of Brigid O'Shaughnessy. Through both Macbeth as well as The Maltese Falcon women are portrayed in a rather manipulating manner, symbolic of both evil as well as deception.…

    • 526 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Octavia Butler’s novel, Kindred, the main character Dana and her husband, Kevin, time travel backwards from the year 1976 in California to the nineteenth century in the antebellum South. Both Dana and her husband are authors in their present time, but, because of gender, he is paid more. They faced the long-time issue of racism as Dana is African-American and Kevin is Caucasian, which contributed to Kevin’s success as well. Their relationship portrayed how far society had not come when it came to discrimination. Though race was still an issue, but accepted more in the modern day, their families did not agree upon their decision to marry one another. The two had been introduced to even harsher times as they time traveled to the days where whites were extremely superior to blacks and Kindred addresses the effects that slavery consumes.…

    • 798 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Octavia Butler Analysis

    • 952 Words
    • 4 Pages

    A notorious female writer of color who rose through her ranks being renowned as an science fiction writer. Her work is so out of this world that she captures her audience through her use of suspension of disbelief. Almost all of Butler’s work uses suspension of disbelief to grab the reader's attention. One of her well known works Kindred explores the idea of time travel. In Kindred we the readers experiences the harsh reality of slavery through Butler illustration and usage of characters not sugar coating anything. Butler compares and contrasts modern African Americans and Whites to African Americans and Whites in the antebellum south in the 1800s. Butler creates a fictional link to the past relating two times to one another; a time many seems not willing to forget or does not want to forget. Kindred is a fictional representation of history where the main character Dana is black and her husband Kevin a white. Butler presents a notion of two people marrying outside their races. Kevin’s sister would not have it, “she didn’t want to meet...wouldn’t...in her house or me either if I married you” as she told Kevin (Butler, 1978 page 110). This comparison shows the progress still needed as far as race; knowing how looked down upon an interracial marriage was view by both families. A unheard of though back in the 1800s. Throughout the novel Butler constantly display such relationships as the one with Dana and Rufus as blacks and whites struggle in both past and present. The relationship of the two consistently tested the racial and boundaries. Her having power over a young naive little white boy, him growing to see her as person with a name and not just some nigger. He found comfort in her and her him, at least that how it was during his childhood. Like many children the grow up and this where Butler uses transition of power and how power corrupts.…

    • 952 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays