As of November 7, 2012, gay marriage has been legalized in nine U.S. states (Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, Connecticut, Iowa, Vermont, New Hampshire, and Washington) including the District of Columbia. However, thirty-one states have constitutional amendments banning gay marriage and six states have laws banning gay marriage. There are many arguments surrounding this controversy that express extremely different opinions regarding supposed outcomes and benefits that would come along with legalizing gay marriage.
Opponents argue that legalizing gay marriage will only whither traditional marriage. According to the Constitution and the Bible, the institution of marriage has been defined as between one man and one woman. In the 1971 decision of Baker v Nelson, the Supreme Court ruled that “The institution of marriage as a union of man and woman, uniquely involving the procreation and rearing of children within a family, is as old as the book of Genesis.”
In a religious point of view, gay marriage is not compatible with the beliefs and traditions of many religious groups. Despite teaching that homosexuals deserve respect, the Catholic Church opposes gay marriage and the social acceptance of homosexuality and same-sex relationships. As the pope said, "No other form of relationship between persons can be considered as an equivalent to this natural relationship between a man and a woman out of whose love children are born." In an economic point of view, gay marriage would entitle gay couples to typical marriage benefits including claiming a tax exemption for a spouse, receiving social security payments from a deceased spouse, and coverage by a spouse’s health insurance policy.
Supporters argue that legalizing gay marriage is, in fact, protected by the Constitution’s commitment to liberty and equality. In the 1974 decision of Cleveland Board of Education v LaFleur, the Supreme Court ruled that “freedom of personal choice in matters of marriage and family life is one of the liberties protected by the Due Process Clause.” On August 4, 2010, US District Judge Vaughn Walker states that Prop 8 in California was “unconstitutional under both the Due Process and Equal Protection Clauses.”
From an economic point of view, the economy can benefit from gay marriage because gay marriages can bring financial gain to state and local governments. For example, the Comptroller for New York City found that legalizing gay marriage would bring $142 million to the City’s economy and $184 million to the State’s economy over three years. From a religious point of view, even though the Bible does address homosexuality, it never explicitly mentions gay marriage. Reverend Susan Russell says, “Jesus never said a single word about anything even remotely connected to homosexuality.” Also, one of the arguments on the opposition side is that same-sex marriage is not allowed because there is no way for reproduction. If that were the case, then infertile couples should not be allowed to be married. Ability or desire to create offspring has never been a qualification for marriage.
Same-sex marriage is a civil right. The 1967 Supreme Court case Loving v. Virginia confirmed that marriage is "one of the basic civil rights of man," and same-sex marriages should receive the same protections given to interracial marriages by that ruling. And honestly, it should not be anyone’s concern if a same-sex couple is married; two people who love each other should be allowed to publicly celebrate their commitment.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
After the legalizations in Massachusetts and, most recently, California, gay marriage has been a growing trend in the United States. In the 8 months since the legalization, more and more gay couples have been rushing to California to tie the knot. However, California and Massachusetts are not the first to make an effort to strengthen the bonds of homosexual couples some European countries including Denmark, Holland, some Scandinavian countries, and others have legalized same-sex marriage and have found the results positive. Gay marriage has been a contradictory issue since gay men and women began requesting marriage licenses. However, gays are denied their rights to marriage licenses, which is denying then their rights as American citizens. Gays should be treated equally to heterosexuals and granted their rights to marry the person they love, whether they are the same or opposite gender.…
- 849 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
The debate between whether gay marriage should be legalized or not has been a controversial topic recently. In the past twelve years, equal marriage rights have been legalized in 6 states of the U.S.. Eighteen states do not allow gay marriage and do not recognize civil unions. The other twenty six states allow civil unions, and some are debating legalizing gay marriage. Gay marriage should be legal across the United States.…
- 1663 Words
- 7 Pages
Better Essays -
In the United States, there are 64 million couple(“YourOUTsource:YOurLGBT”). Of those couples, 1% is made of same sex couples ("YourOUTsource:YourLGBT").Of the 50 states, only six states allow gay marriage while the other states ban gay marriage due to religious, legislative, family, and cultural beliefs issues ("YourOUTsource:YourLGTB").These issues are why people believe that people of the same sex should not be together. Although traditional marriages have many positive attributes, gay marriage should be legalized because it has brought equality to those that are involved in a same sex relationship, a lower divorce rate, and a higher adoption rate.…
- 847 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Two definitions from two different dictionaries are as follows: "The legal union of a man and woman as husband and wife", "The state of being united to a person of the opposite sex as husband or wife in a legal, consensual and contractual relationship recognized and sanctioned by and dissolvable only by law." It is quite ironic how it is stated, " union of a man and woman " and does not say nor hint at "man and man" or "woman and woman". These definitions were derived from mankind, mankind that put an effort in building as what we all know as America. America 's government was established with the belief in God, and therefore allowing same sex marriage is a contradiction to our founding fathers and the government we are sanctioned upon. This paper will discuss and analyze same sex "marriage" through the foundation of our government, moral views, homosexual views, and holy matrimony verses a union of two persons.…
- 2075 Words
- 9 Pages
Powerful Essays -
But while the gay marriage debate continued throughout the country, many states began to legalize civil unions, which guaranteed domestic partners in homosexual relationships access to many of the benefits that partners in a heterosexual relationship were allowed. But it wasn’t until 2013 that the supreme court ruled that homosexual couples could be entitled to the same federal benefits as other married couples. By 2015, the supreme court required all states to issue marriage licenses to same sex couples. Supreme Court Justice Anthony Kennedy wrote that “under..fourteenth amendment couples of the same sex may not be deprived of that right and that liberty.” (Gay Marriage p.7). In fact, most supporters of gay rights argue that gay people should have all the same rights that other people have, including the right to…
- 1046 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Marriage is the ceremonial binding of two people, male and female, into one couple. Historically, marriage has been the institution when a man and a woman join together with the promise of love, devotion, to always stay together, to be there for each other, to take care of one another and to start a family together. Biblically, marriage has been all the aspects above, but including honoring, loving and growing closer to God and raising their family in ways that the Lord would have them, by abiding to the Word of God. Now days the traditional view of marriage is being changed by gay and lesbian couples demanding the same right to love, honor and cherish each other. This argumentative essay on gay marriage will explore both sides on the debate of gay and lesbian marriages.…
- 842 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
For years people have questioned and judged each other’s life styles whether it was a teen pregnancy, drug abuse, and especially a person’s sexuality. Everyone is entitled to an opinion but at what cost? Many people believe it’s wrong to be with someone of the opposite sex but many polls and statistics show that over the years, society has grown accustomed to different life style choices including marriages involving people of the same sex. Now it is time for politicians and the law to catch up with society. Since the 90s the community of homosexuals has stood up and raised their voices about the possibility of legalizing gay marriages. It all started with a lawsuit in Hawaii that made the issue of same sex marriages a major debate in the nation.…
- 1227 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Gay couples, however, do not have children, and therefore do not need any of these benefits. If homosexual marriage were legalized, they would yet collect these reimbursements that were actually supposed to go to helping children. It is unfair, therefore, to legalize marriage for this reason. Granted, elderly and infertile couples will also not produce children but will receive money; instead of messing with the definition of marriage and the rights of couples, however, it is clear that some form of “tax reform is an effective way to remove” this discrepancy (741). Though outlawing gay marriage has been called a “monstrous injustice,” it is in fact the legalization of gay marriage that would be a clear injustice to the heterosexual families with children…
- 774 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
ay marriage is a contentious issue in the US today. Currently, only fifteen states have legalized gay marriage, and even then it has been a long and tough fight to get to this point. In California, Proposition 8 won by a majority in 2008 when same sex marriage proponents sought to prevent gay couples from accessing marriage licences. On June 2013, gay couples in California could once again acquire marriage licences after Proposition 8 was deemed unconstitutional (Mears para. 2). This trend has been observed in most of the fifteen states where the constitutional provisions of equality and civil rights have been used to defend gay marriage. The principles that guide the legalization of gay marriage are ingrained in the very heart of the…
- 125 Words
- 1 Page
Good Essays -
Gay marriage is one of the, if not the most, discussed topic in today’s society. Like every subculture, gays have their distinctive norms, social practices, and, vocabulary. Thus as caused them to be subject of discrimination throughout history. Conservatives and religious people who don’t believe that homosexual couples should be allowed to be united by law or any other institution have been putting pressure in on the government to prevent the creation of laws in favor of same sex couples.…
- 1257 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
The debate over whether same-sex marriage should be legalized has focused on the infringement of civil rights. State recognition of marriages is not a common right. States control marriages in many ways, not just by denying same sex gender the right to marry. Approximately half of all states deny first cousins from marrying and all deny marriage of closer blood relatives, even if the couple is sterile. In all fifty two states, it is illegal to try to marry more than one person. Some states may even deny a person who is suffering from venereal diseases the right to marriage. Gays and lesbians are not the only people to be denied the right to marry the person of their choosing.…
- 865 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
People have been fighting for the rights of gays and lesbians for decades. The gay rights…
- 1492 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
Employers offer access to health insurance, bereavement leave if a spouse dies, and pension benefits to the surviving spouse. Gay couples are not entitled to these rights in most cases.…
- 1078 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
Same-sex marriage is not marriage. It offends God and denies a child a mother or a father. Same-sex marriage also turns a moral wrong into a civil right.When someone violates the natural sexuality Established by God, it offends God. Gay marriage eliminates the chance of a child having either a mother or a father. Marriage has always been between one man and one woman. Gay marriage proposes two women or two man. It is in the child’s best interest to be raised his/her natural mother and father instead of by someone that has no blood relationship with him/her. Same-sex marriage is not a civil…
- 951 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Gay Marriage is the new “it” topic for all highly religious people to begin discussing as ultimately the “demise” of our nation. While many opposed feel it is against their religious beliefs others are simply not comfortable with the relationship. However, in an ever-changing world, it is something that while some may try and prevent it, is not going to disappear.…
- 2640 Words
- 11 Pages
Better Essays