Fadiman

Only available on StudyMode
  • Download(s) : 48
  • Published : March 18, 2013
Open Document
Text Preview
1. In her critique of The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down, Janelle Taylor argues that Anne Fadiman’s portrayal of Hmong culture is problematic. Please explain how Fadiman’s story is problematic. In your discussion, be sure to consider: • How is the story set up as a tragedy? That is, if both the parents and the doctors are uncompromising in their quest for Lia’s well-being, how do they wind up colliding so tragically? • How are Hmong culture and Western medicine used as explanations for the tragedy? Are they similarly responsible, or does each play a different role? Why? • What do these differing explanations tell us about Fadiman’s views of Western medicine? The story is set up as a tragedy because both sides are doing what they believe is best for Lia. There isn’t a bad side or a good side, which makes it that much more difficult to comprehend. As one reads the book, there is a need to look for the black and white, when in fact, it’s all grey. That’s what makes it tragic; there’s no one to blame. Taylor, when discussing the meaning of tragedy, writes that, “the same quality…that allows us to take right action can also blind us to our own error and lead us into disaster.”(Taylor, P. 163). This is what happened with the two sides. Each one had its own idea of what would it would take to “pursue the good” (P. 163), and it that pursuit they ended up in disaster. For example, Neil was exhibiting this quality when he reported Lia’s parents to child protective services. If he had not done so, it would have been, in his mind, wrong. However, as it was shown later, he was in a way “wrong” about Lia’s parents being neglectful. The understanding of Lia’s illness was a very important part of the tragedy. Her doctors viewed it in terms of biology; as a disease that needed to be treated and cured. The Hmong view the illness as serious, but also as “an illness of some distinction.” (Fadiman, P. 21) The seizures are thought to facilitate trances and help...
tracking img