The Euthanasia Debate,
The Thomas Theorem
Topic: Euthanasia related to the Thomas Theorem
Browser Used: Microsoft Explorer
Search Engines Used: Google, Dogpile, MSN Search
In The Unadjusted Girl W.I.Thomas wrote, "Preliminary to any self-determined act of behavior there is always a stage of examination and deliberation which we may call the definition of the situation. And actually not only concrete acts are dependent on the definition of the situation, but gradually a whole life-policy and the personality of the individual himself follow from a series of such definitions." (University of Missouri St Louis web site. W. I. Thomas Definition of the Situation.)
Merriam-Webster Online Dictionary defines euthanasia as "follows: "eu·tha·na·sia Pronunciation: "yü-th&-'nA-zh(E-)&
Etymology: Greek, easy death, from euthanatos, from eu- + thanatos death: the act or practice of killing or permitting the death of hopelessly sick or injured individuals (as persons or domestic animals) in a relatively painless way for reasons of mercy." (Merriam-Webster Online Dictionary 2004.)
B. A. Robinson says that most people in North America die a bad death. He cites a study which found that often people die in pain, with their wants and wishes ignored, and spending days and weeks in an intensive care unit. He goes on to define various forms of euthanasia.
Passive Euthanasia is basically letting a person die. This is the case that is pretty much legal and has little argument in today's society. It covers the Do Not Resuscitate' orders and the withdrawal of heroic measures, along with pulling the plug' on respirators, stopping medications, up to and including in many cases withdrawing food and water, which lets the person die of starvation and dehydration. Robinson says that one of the most common forms of passive euthanasia is to give large quantities of morphine or similar medications ostensibly to reduce pain, but with the knowledge that this kind of dosage can shorten life. This is called a dual effect; pain is eased, and life is shortened. This is considered ethical in most political jurisdictions and medical societies. These procedures, or withholding of procedures, sometimes are performed on people in persistent vegetative states in which they cannot give consent or give instructions regarding their desires.
The main controversy, surrounds more emotionally charged definitions of more active forms of euthanasia. Robinson defines these as follows. Active Euthanasia involves the causing of death of a person through direct action, at the request of that person. Dr. J. Kevorkian is serving a prison sentence for 2nd degree murder for causing the death of an ALS patient in Michigan who feared dying a horrible death. If the active euthanasia is assisted by a physician who supplies or prescribes the lethal dose, then it is called Physician Assisted Suicide (PAS). "Voluntary Passive Euthanasia" (VPE) has found favor as a term to define this form of suicide. The difference between PAS and VPE is the activity level of the physician. In PAS the doctor administers the lethal dose at the request of the patient, while with VPE the doctor provides the instruments of death, which the patient then actively uses to cause death of self.
Non-Voluntary Euthanasia, or involuntary euthanasia, is the causing of death of another without that person's consent, instruction, or known desire. It is considered passive if ventilation, feeding, hydration, or lifeprolonging treatment such as CPR is withheld, thus letting the person die through non-intervention. This is the classic Karen Ann Quinlan kind of situation. It is considered active if someone does something that causes death, such as a lethal dose of medication, strangling, or otherwise taking an action to cause the death.
Robinson then states many of the reasons people might want to end their lives, such as terminal illness, slow...
Please join StudyMode to read the full document