Dystopia vs Utopia ( a Clockwork Orange vs. Player Piano

Only available on StudyMode
  • Download(s) : 137
  • Published : February 27, 2005
Open Document
Text Preview
Utopia can be defined as a place immune from inhumane treatment and absent of the hardships of society , where the population is blindfolded from fear, anxiety, and general negative aspects of human nature. A utopia can be generalized as that perfect society. This is one type of a drastic society. There is another, more appalling type of society, that of a dystopia. A Dystopia is nor a fairyland or the promised-land like the utopia is, it looks at the chaos, anarchy, rebellion and disorder of a society. As we compare these two opposite society types, there are two books that are the poster child of utopia and dystopia. Those two books are Kurt Vonnegut's "Player Piano", and Anthony Burgess's "A Clockwork Orange". In Kurt Vonnegut's "Player Piano" we follow the hero Paul Protues through his utopian society. Where in his society they have just recovered from a ten year war and now has been built up and ran completely by machines. Furthermore a super computer always controls the populations actions, it acts as a shepherd leading the sheep. However where there are sheep there is always a ever lurking black sheep, Paul is that of a black sheep. Through his journey in this utopian society we follow his rebellion against the super computer and machines. As Paul progresses in his society it becomes less and less of a utopia on more and more of a force fed, totally governed society where there is little freewill. As we follow his expedition we can see the changing society from a utopia to what Paul perceives as a dystopia. In Anthony Burgess's "A Clockwork Orange" we observe the antagonist Alex in his blatant dystopia society. Where in his society they have high criminal activity and few police. We follow Alex and his "droogs" as they acts like Vikings, raping, pillaging, and burning. Alex has no respect for law and order he rebels in part one of the novel . However Alex is eventually caught by the police and put in jail. In jail he is tricked to being rehabilitated to becoming a productive member of society. After this forced rehabilitation Alex is then to perceive society as a utopian society and stop being so violent. He has lost his own freewill and his identity. When ever Alex thinks of violent images he then gets sick to his stomach. When Alex is released back into society he is no longer the victimized but rather the victim of society. Alex becomes unhappy and has no choice in what he does. In further examination we can see in both novels that when there is a dystopia society there is freewill, no one to rule you, however the more you move towards a utopian society you become the ruled and freewill is compromised severely. In both novels you must ask yourself, Do you want to choice goodness or have goodness imposed on you? Is a man who chooses to be bad perhaps in some way better than a man who has the good imposed upon him? In both society types we can undeniably perceive that both the hero and the antagonist face a horror show of dilemmas, and trying times. The society has a direct association with the hero and antagonist emotions. As we can see the more the society leans towards utopia, they both become less satisfied and become hungry for freewill . However they more the society is a dystopia there craving for freewill is satisfied and they are happy-go-lucky. In Kurt Vonnegut's "Player Piano" we can see that his world has just recovered from a long and grueling ten year war. Many men and women lost their lives in this horrible war. His world was in ruins and was built back up by technology and was once again a "normal" society. The government kept on introducing new machines to make their world easier to live in and try to make it a generally happier place. However the government did not stop there, they kept on introducing newer and newer equipment. The government deceived the population by creating the illusion that technology was the only way to restore order. This was not so,...
tracking img