Does Democracy Produce Worse Government Than Dictatorship Produce?

Only available on StudyMode
  • Download(s) : 295
  • Published : June 10, 2012
Open Document
Text Preview
Does democracy produce worse government than dictatorship produce?

Content
Introduction P. 3

Definition of democracy P.3-4

Definition of dictatorship P.4-5

Does democracy produce worse government than dictatorship produce? Efficiency P.6-7 Corruption P.7-9 Leadership P.9-11 Govern the interest of state P.11-12 Political participation P.12-14

The world trend of democracy P.14-15

Conclusion P.15-16

Appendixes P.17

Bibliography P.18

Introduction:
The controversy between democracy and dictatorship is a common topic in society. In order to find which one is better, I would like to give a brief definition about democracy and dictatorship. Then, I would like to use different criteria to show that democracy does not produce worse government than dictatorship, to a certain extent, democracy even produce better government than dictatorship. Different social, political and economic condition will lead the country to adopt different type of government, but democracy is a world trend. It also can be found that democracy does not produce worse government than dictatorship.

Definition of democracy

Democracy is come from two Greek words: demos and kratein. The meaning of demos means “the people”. Kratein means “to rule”, that means democracy is ruled by the people.[1] According to Lincoln’s words, democracy is the government of the people, by the people and for the people.[2] Democracy generally refers to a form of government which is formed by majority wish of people through an open and fair election of universal suffrage. Participatory democracy, Representative democracy and Economic democracy are three forms of democracy.

Participatory democracy (Direct democracy) is a form of government. Popular participation, majority rule and political equality are the main features in participatory democracy. [3] Participatory democracy creates chance for political group to contribute to decision-making and enlarge the range of people who can participate into such chance. In other words, it gives the greatest scope for citizen participation.[4]

Representative democracy (indirect democracy) is a system called “constitutionalism”. It based on free election and has limitations on state activity. [5]It is called indirect democracy because there is no direct role for citizens to play in making any law or policies. However, citizens still have power to elect their representatives. Also, even if the acts of government represent the majority of citizens’ wish, such acts are limited.

Economic democracy is a socioeconomic philosophy which suggests that distributes the material resources of society for maximizing equality and improving people’s quality of life, such as redistributing the wealthy from the rich to the poor. [6]

Definition of dictatorship
Dictatorship is defined as an autocratic form of government. The government is ruled by an individual or a small group of people. In other words, a dictator is not responsible to the people or their elected representatives constitutionally.[7] Authoritarian government and totalitarian government are the two forms of dictatorship.

Authoritarian government is opposite with any democratic government that there are no free election in state. It ruled by select few. The government absolutely controls the power in the state such as the army, decision-making and so forth....
tracking img