Do You Really Love Me?

Only available on StudyMode
  • Download(s) : 582
  • Published : October 18, 2011
Open Document
Text Preview
What if somebody you always thought you loved turned out to be someone they were not? In the short story, “Brigid” by Mary Lavin, Owen’s wife is trying to convince Owen to put his sister, Brigid, in a nursing home. This story is set in Ireland during the 1930s. At this time, you were known as a terrible person if you put a relative in a nursing home. When the couple gets in a fight over this debate, Owen storms to Brigid’s house. When Owen’s wife begins to worry about Owen, she goes to search for Owen. When she reaches Brigid’s house, she finds Owen on the ground burnt to death after a stroke. Because Brigid is mentally retarded, Brigid was unable to save the helpless Owen. Owen’s wife then realizes she never loved Owen and pretended to be someone she wasn’t. Love sustains with a challenge is the most significant theme in “Brigid”, because Owen’s wife realizes she wasn’t as loving as she could have been, had no compassion for Brigid, and made herself out to be someone she was not. When true loves comes to mind, you usually think of that elderly couple that goes for a morning stroll in the park, holding hands. You infer they have been through hard times, but they had each other. The theme, love sustains with a challenge is a key factor to the story, “Brigid”. Throughout the story, Owen and his wife are fighting over whether they should put Brigid in a nursing home. Owen then storms out of the house with rage (Lavin 318-321). You can assume that they have had this discussion many times before, with no avail. This shows the hopelessness Owen has for retaining their love. He seems to have given up on trying to make it work because Owen’s wife is being stubborn and not allowing him to keep Brigid on their property. Owen displays his pessimistic attitude toward his wife when he pronounces, “In the town? And why didn’t somebody go to town, might I ask?” (Lavin 318). This excerpt is taken when Owen’s wife does not get meat for their dinner. This creates a tense...
tracking img