Dbq- Female Workers in England and Japan: How Similar Were Their Experiences?

Only available on StudyMode
  • Download(s) : 2040
  • Published : April 29, 2012
Open Document
Text Preview
DBQ- Female Workers in England and Japan: How Similar Were Their Experiences?

The experiences of female mill workers in Japan had different experiences from female mill workers in England. The industrial revolution happened in England around the 1800’s while in Japan, the industrial revolution happened around the 1900’s. There are multiple examples of difference between the different female mill workers. These can be categorized into four different groupings. These groups are Background, Salary/Wage, Gender/Age, and Working Conditions. The groups Salary/Wage, Gender/Age, and Working Conditions all show their differences. While the group of Background shows the resemblance of the two groups.

When looking at the difference at the backgrounds from female workers from Japan and England the show few similitarities between these two areas. In Document #1 England of Japan (Maps), the point of view of this document is that it shows a current map to compare the similar size of the two countries; they both are small island nations. Document #2 Mill Workers: Two Visuals, point of view from this document shows that the two pictures show that life in a factory or mill may seem all nice and clean, but as proof from the other documents shows this is not so. They give the deception of the mills and factories being too good to be true. These pictures also show the majority of female workers, with minimal male interaction. One can infer from the deception that these are advertisements for factories in different areas. A few additional documents that would help better explain the background of the experiences of female workers; One would be a bigger map that shows the entire world, and one that shows real photos of the factories that are not staged or propaganda. Through these two documents we can see that even though there are numerous differences between the female workers in the island nations of Japan and England, there are still a few similarities.

Even though there are some similitarities of the experiences between female workers of factories in both Japan and England. In the document group of Gender/Age, these show the difference in the number of older women to younger women, and the difference between the greater female workers to the fewer male workers. In document #3 Gender and Age in the English Mills, the point of view is that there are more women working in the mills than men and the women working are older than 20 years of age. This means that women who are working are capable of working longer hours and doing more work than the younger women who work in the mills. In Japan, as explained in document #4 Gender and Age in the Nagano Silk Factories, even though the female workers outnumber the amount of male workers, the amount of women workers in Japan, specifically in the city of Nagano are more below the age of 20. The pint of view from this document is almost the same as from document #3. The women outnumber the men, but this time there are younger than older women. Which means that because of the greater number of younger women working the hours of work should be less in Japan than in England. A few additional documents would be to have several writing experiences form both workers in Japan and England; and to have a document that shows better figures of the working population from the perspectives from the entirety of both nations. With the proof given from both documents there is a concurrent fact, there are younger workers in Japan and older workers in England, yet in both they have a greater proportion of feminine workers.

Not only are there differences between female mill workers in Japan and England in the areas of gender and age, but there are even more when considering their Salary/ Wage differences. As shown in document #5 Working Hours of Textile Workers in England and Japan, it gives two articles that were acquired through government research, one from Wigan, England in 1840 while the other is from Okaya,...
tracking img