Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Critique of “What Should a Billionaire Give – and What Should You?” by Peter Singer

Better Essays
1161 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Critique of “What Should a Billionaire Give – and What Should You?” by Peter Singer
Critique of “What Should a Billionaire Give – and What Should You?” by Peter Singer

“All human beings are born free and equal in dignity and rights. They are endowed with reason and conscience and should act towards one another in a spirit of brotherhood”. This extract represents the first article of the declaration of human rights which states that people from all over the world should gain the same benefits of life and struggle hand in hand to reduce imbalances and disparity between them. However, our world is far from being perfect and inequalities are easily identified within a region, country or even a city.
Life is priceless. It is God’s greatest gift and should be returned to the Creator throughout good actions and charity .From this perspective rose philanthropy with the aim of improving human life quality. Many attempts to “fight global poverty” were led during this century by some individuals but the core of the solution lies , according to Peter Singer in his article “What Should a Billionaire Give – and What Should You?” , in the collaboration between all classes of people. Singer dissects through his persuasive essay the different reasons that led to disparity and philanthropy in addition to the exposure of various strategies in order to combat poverty in developing countries.
History of developing countries has always been marked with poverty. The origins of scarcity may lie in the field of colonization and the exploitation of people, lands and resources by the European empire-building in the nineteenth century. As a fact, poor people had less access to health, education and other services. Therefore, the percentage of disease, ignorance and wars increased dramatically thus worsening the situation and dragging poor countries into even deeper problems. Then with the twentieth century rose globalization and the promise held by developed countries to help inferior countries escape poverty by elaborating strong bonds between nations and offering poor countries broader access to important roles on the international scene. However, the massive external influence by the rich and controlling governments or multinational firms leaves the governments of poor countries and its people powerless, in a dark abyss deprived of all rights of humanities. The hypocrisy of rich towards poor people can be observed throughout Singer’s article when he mentions the outrageous and immoral practices made by corporations which buy “stolen goods” from any legal or illegal government. (Singer 5). This sets a motive for some rebellious groups to lead a revolution against the government in order to take control of the nation’s resources. Congo -for example- being one of the resources richest countries of the world, has witnessed several coups and clashes over gold, diamonds and other “valuable” matter leaving behind destruction and chaos, thus weakening the economic activity of the nation (Tabb). In brief, the author did a good job exposing the historical and environmental contexts that led to disparity.
Singer exposes the reasons that led Bill Gates to become a philanthropist and donate part of his fortune to help people in need. He placed Gates in a category conform to Kant’s theory that states that charity action motives relies on a “sense of duty”. However, this verdict is paradoxical compared to what Singer said in the opening of the article. In fact, he affirms that Gates, shocked to hear about the lethal disease caused by rotavirus, decided to contribute to The Global Alliance for Vaccines and Immunization (GAVI) and support “purchasing millions of doses of vaccines” (Singer 2) to avoid several diseases. This according to Hobbes is defined by “own interest” charity. Thus, the author based his own assumption, on Gate’s motive to donate, simply on a Website slogan “To whom much has been given, much is expected” (Singer 3).
According to my own beliefs, somehow consistent with those of the African-American cab driver mentioned in the article, a self- made billionaire is a person who has struggled day and night to build his fortune and has experienced the difficulties and obstacles of life. Therefore, no one should “tell him what to do with it” ( Singer 4) neither evaluate whether the donation was fair or not comparing to the resources the Billionaire still holds after his contribution . I personally think that Gates’ $30 billion donation is high enough. Therefore, the author should have focused on obvious examples of philanthropy skepticism rather than criticizing and analyzing the intentions of Gate, who has given a fair share to the world. Carlos Slim, the actual richest man in the world, believes that “poverty is not fought with donations, charity or even public spending”. This “frugal” Billionaire, despite being raised in a country where 50% of the population is living in poverty, has not done enough to help Mexican people and resolve the nation’s complex economics issues.
Returning to Bill Gate, his quote -“All lives — no matter where they are being led — have equal value.” (Singer 2) - was refuted by Singer by opposing it to the actions of Zell Kravinsky, who has gone beyond the imaginable to help humanity. However, this extreme case is rarely observed among humans, thus we should not expect every philanthropist to behave this way. A scandalous quote by John Bolton could relieve the accusation held by Singer against Bill Gate. In fact, the former US ambassador to the United Nations, John Bolton, stated that the ‘civilian victims of Israelis airstrikes in Lebanon were not “morally equal” to those who die because of “terrorist attacks” (Fernandez). In other words, for Bolton, innocent life does not equal innocent life. But the controversial thing is that he has been nominated for Nobel Peace Prize 2006. This shows that the problem of inequalities in the perception of human life lies in the heart of the nations. Thus, instead of scrutinizing every sentence Gates said, efforts like those of the Billionaire should be met with acclamation.
The author reaches the purpose of his article in his last two pages. In fact, he suggests a strategy to reduce poverty by inciting rich people to “share the burden of relieving global poverty” (Singer 8) via donating a percentage of their fortune. While this approach can be effective to reduce poverty, I personally think that the solution it engenders is temporary. If rich countries really want to improve the world and help restore equality between all the nations, pressure should be exerted by people on governments. Therefore, they must incite their political leaders to get rid of the competitiveness and selfishness on the international scene and take crucial measures to ensure stability for underdeveloped nations.

Works Cited
Fernandez, Yusuf. "The July War Series - Part I." (2009): n. pag. Web. 2 Nov 2010. <http://www.almanar.com.lb>.
Tabb, William. "Resource Wars." (2007): n. pag. Web. 3 Nov 2010. <http://www.monthlyreview.org/>.
Singer, Peter. "What Should a Billionaire Give – and What Should You?." (2006): 1-12. Web. 3 Nov 2010. <http://www.nytimes.com>.

Cited: Fernandez, Yusuf. "The July War Series - Part I." (2009): n. pag. Web. 2 Nov 2010. &lt;http://www.almanar.com.lb&gt;. Tabb, William. "Resource Wars." (2007): n. pag. Web. 3 Nov 2010. &lt;http://www.monthlyreview.org/&gt;. Singer, Peter. "What Should a Billionaire Give – and What Should You?." (2006): 1-12. Web. 3 Nov 2010. &lt;http://www.nytimes.com&gt;.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    Based on the article by Peter Singer entitled Famine, Affluence, and Morality, he attempts to move us to do more for charities and gives one astounding example. He uses starving children in Bengali and a drowning child.…

    • 1156 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Singer calculates that “$200 in donations would help a sickly 2-year-old transform into a healthy 6-year-old” (Singer 2). No one would say that spending money to help a child in need is wasteful; however, preserving the child’s life would not save it from poverty. The child would be alive, but it would still grow up poor and uneducated, and, in all likelihood, its children would be the same. Singer’s solution for poverty is, in all actuality, not a solution at all. His ideas would be great for lowering the fatality rate due to malnourishment or diseases, but he gives no solution to adequately deliver the world from poverty. Donating to children-saving charities, while honorable, does not do much in fixing the problem at hand, worldwide…

    • 861 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In his article “Famine, Affluence, and Morality,” Peter Singer outlines his argument for helping those in need in the global community. His main argument is that humans can stop suffering based on our moral decisions.1 Singer calls for the definition of ‘charity’ in our society to have moral implications. People should give governmental and privately. all need to give to charity and all at the same time.…

    • 662 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Gospel of Wealth: Carnegie’s philosophy that the millionaire had a duty to distribute wealth while still alive.…

    • 347 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Billionaire Sacrifice

    • 821 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Singer begins his essay with a simple question, “What is a human life worth?” (578). “Singer suggests that most people would be unwilling to a value on the life another human”. Singer continues the topic by writing about some of the charitable beliefs of Bill Gates and how it was that Gates developed some of those values over time, which was in part due to hearing about a viral infection that kills around five hundred million children each year. Singer then goes on to give a statistic that around a billion people must survive on the equivalent of “less than one U.S. dollar per day” and that “more than ten million children die every year . . . from avoidable, poverty-related…

    • 821 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The issue of moral obligations towards the global poor has always been a contentious affair to be discussed for fear of problematic resolutions that may affect academia on a personal level. Peter Singer, most notable for his authorship of “Famine, Affluence, and Morality” and the drowning child analogy, presents the rather uncommon normative view that affluent persons are morally obligated to donate more resources to humanitarian causes than the present standard. Singer’s perspective on these seemingly radical moral ideals are confronted by many a pragmatic objection, ranging from entitlement principles to moral inequalities. Nevertheless, Singer builds his argumentative framework in regards to moral obligations to the global poor on solid…

    • 1239 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Peter Singer

    • 1227 Words
    • 5 Pages

    In Singer’s third chapter of his book he goes on to show us the common objections to giving. The opinion that I felt was the strongest argument was Lucy’s from Glennview High, “ If someone wants to buy a new car, they should. If someone wants to redecorate their house, they should, and if they need a suit, get it. They work for their money and they have the right to spend it on themselves.” ³…

    • 1227 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Americans and their lack of donations. Singer concludes with comparing income and how much a person should give away based on that number. He suggests all Americans have the choice to give up all luxuries because these sacrifices could better a child’s life.…

    • 703 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Examples Of Inequality

    • 1210 Words
    • 5 Pages

    “Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere.” An act of inequity for some could result in inequality for all, unless citizens of the world do something about it. A current example of inequality for one would be how females are being treated compared to males in a variety of settings. People of color and different races are another example of people receiving unequal treatment. Throughout the world, inequality can be seen through those who are less fortunate than others. Every individual regardless of gender, race, and socioeconomic status deserves the right of freedom and justice.…

    • 1210 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In our definition of human rights, we use an approach more closely related to the Declaration of the Rights of Man. In the sense, that we define it more as they did in terms of equality and fairness as stated by the UN: "We are all equally entitled to our human rights without discrimination. These rights are all interrelated, interdependent and indivisible." (United Nations, 2018). When we begin discussing universal human rights, the debates become more difficult to put to rest. When it comes to universal human rights we adopt more of a style as they used in the Declaration of Independence. It inevitably becomes a discussion more on the structure and legality of our systems. Rather than discussing equalities for individuals, you must discuss issues for humanity as a whole. This is why I do believe that we use these Declarations as a foundation for our modern-day definition of human rights, but have adopted different aspects from each…

    • 956 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    I was first introduced to Peter Singer’s idea of altruistic poverty at Governor’s School. It suggests that to achieve social and economic equality, individuals have to give away all they have until they reach the poverty line. While trying to wrap my mind around this questionable solution to such a complex issue, I realize that my previous way of thinking had been so egocentric. If I gave everything unnecessary for my survival what would my life look like? However, as this idea unveiled my own inadequacies as an altruistic individual, I began to wonder why capitalism does not encourage this altruism from all economic classes.…

    • 105 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Aliens deserve the same right as humans because they have reason and a conscious. Although maybe not literal, Orson Scott Key uses aliens as a tool to project a powerful message in his novel Ender’s Game. The novel depicts that misunderstanding of the aliens leads to their destruction, and the author uses to symbolize the current real world situation of discrimination, which tips the balance of equality infringing on our basic human rights here in the United States and in many other countries such as Egypt. In the effort to understand the basic rights that every human is supposed to have, the United Nations created The Universal Declaration of Human rights.…

    • 862 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    You would think that based on what I have heard from my peers that they are very uncomfortable with the Peter Singers ideas on donating all money beyond what they need to charity. Although they did think that it was a good idea, they didn’t necessarily believe that it was a moral decision. Of the arguments that I heard against Singer, and I did hear many, I don’t think that they are created equal. I’ll mention three in detail and some justifications that I heard that aren’t as relevant.…

    • 1329 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    His book seems to be more so like a call to action for us to increase our sharing. He challenges many likely doubts and difficulties to his writing. Singer deems that a majority of Americans are not too bleakly mired down in the self-indulgent pursuit of selfishness. Continually, the study on happiness constantly comes to that those who are generous givers have seem to be happier. However, his iconoclasm appears when he confronts the common view that your family should always come first, but Singer sensibly concludes that this value should not be a problem towards…

    • 567 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Peter Singers Solution

    • 341 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In the Singer solution, Peter Singer talks about how it is wrong to live in luxury and watch someone else struggle for the basic things to survive. He argues that instead of going out spending money on necessities, help someone. He also tries to prove a point where as if you have something valuable to you, would you risk savings? Or would you help an innocent person in need?…

    • 341 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays