Preview

Conflict: Halogen Lamp and Jamie Turner

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
2132 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Conflict: Halogen Lamp and Jamie Turner
Jamie Turner Case

Case 2: Jamie Turner at MLI, Inc

Hilary Kuykendall Ya Liang

1. How did Turner get himself into this predicament? What is going on for Cardullo? Many reasons contribute to the situation Turner’s currently in, first of all being his abrupt decision of taking the job. The job offer by MLI is very appealing, though, Turner isn’t thinking thoroughly about whether or not he is capable of doing industrial marketing,which is different from what he really likes and is expert in. Making a pros/cons list like the chart below is a great way to evaluate if you will be successful in a new position [4]. The risk is even higher as MLI is struggling financially and still in the transition of a merger.The unstable environment has left him little time to adapt to the new job though time is promised by Cardullo. So this is not a wise career choice in the first place.

Secondly, Turner is trusted with too many responsibilities too early in his job. Turner doesn’t really know how to cope with the situation because it’s quite different from what he had in Wolf River. He really needs time to absorb all the information and get an understanding of both internal and external circumstances. Now he has no choice but to make quick calls based on a superficial observation, as well as instincts and past experience which could prove to be very wrong and dangerous. The same is true with the full autonomy over pricing. Turner never has a safe chance to prove his worth before being handed so many responsibilities, so once he fails, he will lose it all. Thirdly, things going on with Cardullo is making it worse. From the case, Cardullo can be described as being extremely judgemental and strongly opinionated. He abruptly sees people as either competent or incompetent and has, from what Turner sees, undermined the value of Kelly, a dependable sales veteran. His

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    In this scenario, InterClean, had a plan in place that would assist the sanitation company in increasing its profitability. In doing so, there was a possibility of having to completely restructure the sales teams and marketing strategies that were already in place. The CEO of InterClean, David Spencer, is a middle aged businessman, who remains focused, and is completely driven in his efforts to ensure that this cleaning company increases its growth to become a leader within the sanitation industry. Initially, David and his team proposed a new service focus that entailed being the first within the industry to expand their cleaning company by introducing an all-inclusive service. While this is a great opportunity for growth, a huge concern is that the current sales team at InterClean is not knowledgeable on the current sanitation regulations, based on legal and environmental requirements. Because of this, Janet in HR began to work on screening new sales hires that had existing sales experience, which caused the existing employees to feel threatened for their job security. However, with the company headed in this new direction, mandatory training would take place for all employees, in hopes for boosting morale. As employees began to start rumors about the changes, the morale began to drop and they felt there was no long time employee loyalty.…

    • 1035 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Carter Mario was one of the worst violators. He was the one who initiated offering the kickback to the customer and bribing him with three neon beer signs. Previous to this situation, Patton had already suspected that he was stealing from the company. Carter Mario also persuaded his sales manager, George Pavlov, to go through with the deal to bribe the customer to buy the beer, even though Pavlov was uncomfortable with the situation. Lastly, Joe Roberts, the V.P. of Administration, handled the situation incorrectly by attempting to settle the issue himself without talking to Elizabeth Jones and Vince Patton. While I believe that Mario should be fired, this is not quite feasible for the company. Unfortunately, if Patton fires Mario, the whole company would suffer. Due to the ABC regulations, if Mario were to report what happened, “Westchester would be closed down for 45 days and Carter Mario would get away scot-free”. Therefore, Patton should keep Mario in the company but demote him to a driver. Being a driver is an extremely tough job, but it keeps Mario in the company while teaching him to be humble. On the other hand, I believe that Patton should decrease George Pavlov’s salary. Since Pavlov felt uncomfortable with the situation and turned to Joe Roberts for help, Pavlov should not have as serious consequences as Mario. By decreasing his salary, it shows that Patton is taking his actions seriously. Pavlov is still a key sales manager so keeping him in this position is the best move for the company. Unfortunately, Pavlov’s actions do violate ABC regulations so by simply decreasing his salary, it does not send a strong message to other employees that a violation of regulations is not a severe and punishable action. In regards to Joe Roberts, I believe that Patton should set up a weekly meeting with Roberts to…

    • 882 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In hind sight the issue that this hits most if that a ship’s direction is mostly impacted not by where it is going; but first mostly the very most important aspect of the situation is who is on the ship and what are the people like and how they work together to bring the ship in the direction of the goal desired by the CEO. It is not too important at first where the ship is heading; the most important is to get the right team on board and then after every one has taken the position of leadership; then it is the time for the ship to start of the desired journey. Brock Wagner stated that now that his company has become so successful and with some competitors trying to buy out the company from under him, the thought of running for office has crossed his mind and one day he might decide to run for mayor of…

    • 608 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Kelownacase

    • 665 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The critical problem in the case is that the Kelowna Store has become unsuccessful in sales due to the lack of incentive for employees and the lack of management within the store. Nathan Edwards, the store manager of Kelowna is holding the store together while working with inexperienced workers whom Edwards has no time to teach. Edward is also receiving limited bonus and appreciation while he continues to stay with the company even though he wants to leave. The current state of affairs is problematic because if Edward decides to leave which he can with a two weeks’ notice at any time, then the Ruffian will have no one too successfully manage the Kelowna Store unless they want to hire someone who may not be the best candidate for the job.…

    • 665 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The major issue that is concerning Monarch Supply Company is that seems to be a rather large disconnect between the employees working in the field sales department and the inside sales department which is causing a number of problems for the company, and jeopardizing their sustainable competitive advantage of other firms. The field sales department is regarded by most as being the backbone of the company due to the vast engineering background all employees are required to have and the extensive interactions they have with the customers. The field sales department are all paid strictly on a commission basis with the salary ranging anywhere from $50,000 to $95,000. The inside sales department is responsible for supporting the field sales department by doing tasks such as, ordering equipment, expediting orders and quoting prices. In addition the inside sales department are responsible for handling all direct phone calls from customers interested about the prices of certain pieces of equipment. The inside sales representatives are paid on a salary basis with annual raises being based on the scores each employee receives on company performance appraisals. If an inside sales representative is performing their job to a high degree, they may in turn be asked to become a field sales department if the opportunity arises. In the midst of certain mistakes occurring, which have the potential to ruin Monarch’s credibility with customers if it continues; interviews with company employees have been conducted in which employees talk about their jobs and “point the finger” as to whom they deem responsible for the screw ups that have been occurring in the company.…

    • 3031 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The first problem I noticed with the highland Financial Services is, the Manager. Why did it have to take him up till two years to look back and realize there was a problem with the pattern of demand of their services from the previous years?…

    • 526 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Al Dunlap and Sunbeam

    • 888 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Dunlap is famous for his ruthless but seemingly successful turnaround techniques that he has employed: “For much of his career before coming to Sunbeam, Al Dunlap was known as the poster child of corporate restructuring.” Given that the Board was familiar with Dunlap – his reputation and employment history, hiring Dunlap clearly showed they needed a fast and powerful turnaround and Sunbeam was becoming helpless in the struggle to protect its market share in an increasingly competitive industry. Also, Dunlap’s priority focuses largely and explicitly on stockholders and virtually no regards for other stakeholders. Hiring Dunlap meant that Sunbeam’s goals are limited to just maximizing stockholders’ wealth and all other important aspects of the existence of corporation such as ethics, product quality, employee and customer satisfaction are severely impaired. A corporation is not solely an instrument of stockholders, built to cater to stockholders’ wealth, but a coalition between many resource suppliers with a view to increasing their common wealth: supplying goods and services to customers with efficiency (at relatively lower costs or with high quality), providing jobs to employees with suitable skill sets and so on. Thus, Al Dunlap’s shareholder primacy is unreasonable and contradictory to the essential objectives of the corporation. Flawed perspectives led to wrong decisions. In an effort to create the “fast turnaround,” Dunlap fired many employees and shut down many factories to cut costs…

    • 888 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Kudler Organization

    • 1204 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Now let’s look at some of the weaknesses that may have led to the continually developing problems that cost the company to notice that some things in daily operations needed to be change. High wages provided to specialty positions with Kudler require individual analysis to…

    • 1204 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    While Nardelli was still in charge he implemented management changes that didn’t sit well with board members and workers. There was no longer a strong bond of the stockholders anymore and the rival of other companies such as Lowes etc were beginning to take its effects on the company.…

    • 808 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Finn’s willingness to go along with the actions of Monus made an already bad situation worse. Finn as the CFO should not have allowed himself to be involved in financial frauds of any sort just to show a profit. Finn should taken control of the situation right then and told Monus what he was doing was wrong and he wouldn’t take part in any of it. Shapir was just as wrong because he was aware of what Monus and Finn were doing and he just ignored it until it the fraud got out of hand. Coopers & Lybrand as the auditors did not exercise due professional care in performing the audit. I don’t feel they obtained sufficient competent evidential matter and they did not use professional judgment when they informed Phar-Mor in advance which stores…

    • 617 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Another problem that the Wells Fargo faces is that executives at the top set goals thinking of their personal goals instead of involving employees. The preliminary solutions for these issues would have been for Wells Fargo to get together with employees and make them feel like their goals are more meaningful. You cannot pressure employees as was the case here and not expect them to take the path of corruption. Another solution would be to hold more of the management accountable and remove them from their…

    • 571 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    One of the strategic issues with this case is that William Wallace decided to expand the business by offering automotive maintenance services without making sure that the business can properly deliver the service or that the company will have competitive advantage compared to competitors. There were no properly skilled employees hired to do this job compared to its competitors. Competing companies in the tire industry offer these same services and performs them better the High Performance Tire (HPT). Another issue is that Mr. Wallace cut cost in the wrong areas in order to increase profit. First, in order to compete in the market and lower cost of tires, he elected to purchase and sell low quality tires. Though he was able to lower the prices, customers became concerned and unhappy about the tires they are purchasing due to its poor quality. Sales continued to fall as a result. In order to drive sales, Mr. Wallace changed the salary from the sales staff to commission based salaries. Though this…

    • 1394 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Rosa And Oli Case

    • 691 Words
    • 3 Pages

    I feel the cause of the conflicting is Rosa and Oli’s competition over Corey’s attention (storming stage); whomever wins the attention of Corey gain his support and his or her issues passes first. In addition, the ambiguous information concerning the status of the call center is a cause of concern. Both Rosa and Oli were selected as representatives by their subordinates whom are concerned about the drop in client retention, which affect Nortic’s profitability, and about being replaced by technology with the automation system. During the third stage, norming, the group unites around the complete the set of expectations outlined by Corey and Will. Corey’s responsibility as a manager is to gain support for the raise retention idea, which was an order given to him by Will. The tension between Oli and Rosa make it impossible for Corey to gain support for that idea. Not until Corey resolves Rosa and Oli’s conflict and can the raise retention task pass and subsequently please Will. After Corey uses his power and gets the team focused on completing the right work, instead of stop complaining and a coffee break, he is able to progress into the performing stage.…

    • 691 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In 1996, the division’s third largest customer decided to replace Chattanooga with one of its competitors. Charles Moore decided to call the group together to figure out how to save the division from its downturn. All the senior managers were present at the meeting: Barry Walkins, he is very creative and had a good intuitive sense of what consumers wanted but disorganized and often lacks follow through; Billy Fale, who is a very knowledgeable and disciplined vice president of production but a bit rigid in his thinking and anchored in the past; Kent Donaldson, vice president of research and development who had conflicts with Walkins; Les Holly, the division’s sales manager who has a tendency to withhold information and sometimes does not follow through; and Stephanie Krane, who had a strong record of delivering on her promises. Running the meeting was Charles Moore who, unlike his predecessor who was the division’s indisputable leader for over 30 years, believes in the value of group-based decisions and like to bring people together formally to share information, consult in decisions, and forge consensus.…

    • 958 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Another probable cause for the talent dilemma is the result of a shift in the overall strategy. There has not been a universal buy-in from the three different departments, especially the retiring VP of Sales, Mark Hartley. Further, there has been a lack of cooperation between the departments to work toward selling a solution based product due to the constraints of incentives for sales as well as interdepartmental financials. Currently, departments are set-up as standalone financial reporting units, so selling products across departments are not financially incentivized.…

    • 1130 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays

Related Topics