Comparison Poetry Essay

Topics: Poetry, Carpe diem, Sonnet Pages: 6 (2387 words) Published: October 14, 2010
Poetry Essay

Each one of the poems offers a unique view upon love. The first poem by Robert Herrick, "To the Virgins to make much of Time," focuses upon the idea of carpe diem. The poem stresses the idea of marriage while love and flesh are still young and believes this gift of virginity to be a great waste if not given while it is still desirable. Marvell also uses the carpe diem theme to his poem ‘To His Coy Mistress,’ however with three certain sections within the poem. The first part elaborates on the idea of unlimited time; this then evolves a ‘but’ into the poem that everything must come to end and death catches up upon us. Then in the last third of the poem the word ‘therefore’ comes into play as the poet says that we should enjoy the time we now have with one another. The last poem by William Shakespeare, Sonnet 18, is much different as it takes a very different approach to the youth of marriage, he uses descriptions of nature, and the power and images that they imply, and directly compares them to the power the young man possesses in his youth. Although all poems are very similar, each has its own unique way to voice its opinion. The two that are more similar to each other would be Marvell and Herrick’s poem as they both use the carpe diem theme, although to different levels.

Robert Herrick, "To the Virgins to make much of Time," focuses upon the idea of carpe diem the most throughout all of the poems. In the opening stanza, the poet articulates the carpe diem theme that urges one to “Seize the Day.” The poem stresses the idea of marriage while ones love and flesh remain young and ripe, or one will have to take consequences in suffering in their later years with loneliness and die, knowing what they may have missed out upon. Herrick believes that the gift each woman is given, the greatest gift, a woman’s virginity to be a great waste if not taken while the desired woman still is so. Virginity is one of; if not the greatest gift a woman can give for the simple reason that it can only be given once. That this gift must also be given to someone special, someone who will succumb to her gift and in turn loves her indefinitely. Therefore, he states that one must go out and find this man, her husband, for youth does not last forever but eventually gives in the effects of old age and loneliness. Herrick uses "The Virgins" in the poem to represent the beginning of life, or youth. With the gathering of roses being a metaphor for living life to the fullest, and grabbing each chance that comes to us and using this. The symbolic young and beautiful when it blooms and becomes in its ‘prime’ but when it surpasses this stage, it will inevitably age and die. Much like any living thing, in comparing the two Herrick tries to scare the women with the story as the rose is of truly beautiful but all good things do come to an end as the poem reminds us time and time again. Herrick also uses another symbolic story much like the rose buds, with the sun showing the rapid ending that everything must eventually has as time passes extremely fast. Like the rose, the sun and its progress across the sky represent the ultimate fate that all humans meet eventually, death In the third stanza, the speaker of the poem stresses that youth is the time when one's blood is "warm", Herrick believes that this is the best time of one's life and at this moment in one’s life they must take initiative and give up their ultimate gift, their virginity . However, in the final two lines of the stanza, Herrick introduces an unusually twist to his idea of pursuing love. He suggests that love does not allow one to escape death, as nothing can do this, but it is in fact a role in someone’s life. Throughout the poem we get an over lining sense of the main point that Herrick is only concerned about marriage and a woman virginity he does not wish to speak of love and passion. Although during the time that Herrick written, women were expected to marry young so...
Continue Reading

Please join StudyMode to read the full document

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Poetry Essay
  • Poetry Essay!
  • Essay on Poetry Comparison
  • Poetry Essay
  • Poetry Essay
  • Poetry Essay
  • poetry essay
  • In poetry Essay

Become a StudyMode Member

Sign Up - It's Free